Recently Sold Condos in Shelter Island, NY

Recently Sold Homes Near Shelter Island, NY

We found 30 more homes matching your filters just outside Shelter Island

• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAY 19, 2026

  $962,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,932 sqft

  18 Fair Street APT 5,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  Coldwell Banker Realty
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAY 15, 2026

  $1,850,000

  

  3 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,364 sqft

  520 Hampton Road #5,
  Southampton, NY 11968

  Nest Seekers International LLC
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAY 15, 2026

  $235,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,088 sqft

  92 Main Street #417,
  Deep River, CT 06417

  Sailpoint Property Group
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAY 15, 2026

  $735,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,310 sqft

  100 Dudley Avenue #F31,
  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  Coldwell Banker Realty
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAY 15, 2026

  $319,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,272 sqft

  310 Boston Post Road #76,
  Waterford, CT 06385

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAY 15, 2026

  $406,000

  

  3 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,786 sqft

  125 Murphys Drive #125,
  Groton, CT 06340

  First Choice Realty
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAY 15, 2026

  $280,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,148 sqft

  130 Meridian Street #301,
  Groton, CT 06340

  Assist 2 Sell/Stebbins Buyer & Sellers Realty
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 15, 2026

  $662,500

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,239 sqft

  103 Main Street #1103,
  Stonington, CT 06378

  Mott & Chace Sotheby's Intl Rt
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 15, 2026

  $360,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,472 sqft

  97 West Main Street #30,
  Niantic, CT 06357

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 15, 2026

  $629,000

  

  3 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,200 sqft

  151 - 153 East Main Street #11,
  Clinton, CT 06413

  RE/MAX Right Choice
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 13, 2026

  $73,500

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,110 sqft

  75 Village Circle W,
  Manorville, NY 11949

  OverSouth LLC
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 13, 2026

  $360,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,224 sqft

  42 Granite Road #42,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  RE/MAX One
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 12, 2026

  $525,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,760 sqft

  3 Village Crossing #3,
  East Lyme, CT 06333

  Lamacchia Realty
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 11, 2026

  $670,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,235 sqft

  367 Main Street #7,
  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 11, 2026

  $740,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,051 sqft

  2 Riverwalk,
  Branford, CT 06405

  Margaret Bennett Realty
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 11, 2026

  $280,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  

  894 sqft

  7 River Colony #7,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  William Raveis Real Estate
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 8, 2026

  $810,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,447 sqft

  64 Brittany Lane,
  Westhampton Beach, NY 11978

  Douglas Elliman Real Estate
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 8, 2026

  $346,500

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,760 sqft

  330 Crystal Avenue #2,
  New London, CT 06320

  Century 21 AllPoints Realty
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 8, 2026

  $209,900

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  839 sqft

  66 Mohawk Trail #66,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  Mercuriano Realty Company
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 7, 2026

  $475,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,569 sqft

  14 Centre Village Drive #14,
  Madison, CT 06443

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 7, 2026

  $699,000

  

  3 Beds

  

  3 Baths

  

  2,107 sqft

  153 Stoneleigh Drive #153,
  Riverhead, NY 11901

  Howard Hanna Coach
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 6, 2026

  $227,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  844 sqft

  91 Crown Knoll Court #130,
  Groton, CT 06340

  Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop.
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 5, 2026

  $268,500

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,113 sqft

  2590 Gold Star Highway #311,
  Groton, CT 06355

  RE/MAX One
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 4, 2026

  $3,425,000

  

  4 Beds

  

  4.5 Baths

  

  2,801 sqft

  1 Spruce Court,
  Water Mill, NY 11976

  Sothebys Int'l Realty Hamptons
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 1, 2026

  $248,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  730 sqft

  16 Pine Orchard Road APT 27,
  Branford, CT 06405

  Houlihan Lawrence WD
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 1, 2026

  $619,900

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,145 sqft

  80 Seaview Terrace #31,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 1, 2026

  $369,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,459 sqft

  16 Copper Hill Dr,
  Guilford, CT 06437
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 1, 2026

  $1,050,000

  

  3 Beds

  

  3.5 Baths

  

  3,545 sqft

  11 Longview Terrace #11,
  Madison, CT 06443

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 1, 2026

  $725,000

  

  3 Beds

  

  3 Baths

  

  1,884 sqft

  91 Legend Hill Road #91,
  Madison, CT 06443

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  APR 30, 2026

  $282,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,088 sqft

  81 Founders Village #81,
  Clinton, CT 06413

  Coldwell Banker Realty