Recently Sold Condos in Shelter Island, NY

Recently Sold Homes Near Shelter Island, NY

We found 30 more homes matching your filters just outside Shelter Island

• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  OCT 2, 2026

  $382,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,763 sqft

  101 West Main Street #4,
  Niantic, CT 06357

  Assist 2 Sell/Stebbins Buyer & Sellers Realty
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  OCT 2, 2026

  $454,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,434 sqft

  17-D Yankee Glen Drive #17D,
  Madison, CT 06443

  Beycome of Connecticut
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  OCT 1, 2026

  $305,500

  

  2 Beds

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,008 sqft

  25 Riverside Drive #E8,
  Clinton, CT 06413

  Century 21 Classic Homes
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  OCT 1, 2026

  $969,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,132 sqft

  25 Sheffield Street #3,
  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  OCT 1, 2026

  $90,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  460 sqft

  33a Limetree Drive,
  Manorville, NY 11949

  Dream Select Realty Corp
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  OCT 1, 2026

  $425,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,296 sqft

  12 West Sussex Place #12,
  Madison, CT 06443

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  SEP 30, 2026

  $275,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,000 sqft

  229 Branford Road #127,
  North Branford, CT 06471

  Coldwell Banker Realty
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 30, 2026

  $1,500,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  924 sqft

  118 Bay St #4,
  Westerly, RI 02891

  Residential Properties, Ltd.
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 30, 2026

  $16,500

  

  Studio

  

  776 sqft

  379 Whitfield Street #CN1446,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  Pearce Real Estate
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 30, 2026

  $248,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  806 sqft

  10 Brantwood Drive #10,
  Madison, CT 06443

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 28, 2026

  $145,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  775 sqft

  51 Virginia Avenue #C,
  Groton, CT 06340

  eXp Realty
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 25, 2026

  $222,500

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  799 sqft

  310 Boston Post Road #124,
  Waterford, CT 06385

  eXp Realty
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 25, 2026

  $245,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,291 sqft

  5127 Village Circle E,
  Manorville, NY 11949

  Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 25, 2026

  $455,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,116 sqft

  42 Blueberry Common,
  Riverhead, NY 11901

  Douglas Elliman Real Estate
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 25, 2026

  $360,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  

  900 sqft

  10 Masons Island Road #8,
  Stonington, CT 06355

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 25, 2026

  $190,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  

  759 sqft

  24 College Street #6,
  Clinton, CT 06413

  Coldwell Banker Realty
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 25, 2026

  $815,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  3 Baths

  

  1,476 sqft

  23 Aylesbury Circle #23,
  Madison, CT 06443

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 25, 2026

  $449,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,944 sqft

  5 West Sussex Place #5,
  Madison, CT 06443

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 24, 2026

  $640,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,310 sqft

  215 Fox Hill Drive,
  Baiting Hollow, NY 11933

  Douglas Elliman Real Estate
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 24, 2026

  $2,050,000

  

  3 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,597 sqft

  580 Dune Road #5,
  Westhampton Beach, NY 11978

  Serhant East End LLC
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 24, 2026

  $425,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,153 sqft

  110 Cherry Street #5,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 24, 2026

  $595,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  980 sqft

  68 Foster Avenue #3,
  Hampton Bays, NY 11946

  BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 23, 2026

  $885,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,800 sqft

  176 Melody Court,
  Eastport, NY 11941

  Douglas Elliman Real Estate
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 22, 2026

  $320,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,442 sqft

  274 Church Street #7B,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  Coldwell Banker Realty
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 22, 2026

  $925,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  3 Baths

  

  2,625 sqft

  78 BALLAD COURT,
  Eastport, NY 11941

  Coldwell Banker Reliable R E
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 22, 2026

  $226,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  

  969 sqft

  298 Meridian Street #A,
  Groton, CT 06340

  RE/MAX Coast and Country
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 22, 2026

  $289,900

  

  2 Beds

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,178 sqft

  348 Boston Post Road #C14,
  Waterford, CT 06385

  Choice Realty
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 22, 2026

  $1,500,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  

  600 sqft

  100 Deforest Rd #6,
  Montauk, NY 11954
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 22, 2026

  $562,000

  

  3 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,022 sqft

  129 Farm House Court #129,
  Manorville, NY 11949

  Coldwell Banker American Homes
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 22, 2026

  $540,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,476 sqft

  28 Downing Way #28,
  Madison, CT 06443

  Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop.