Shelter Island, NY Real Estate & Homes For Sale
80 homes
NEW - 2 DAYS AGOFOR SALE BY OWNER0.91 ACRES
Use arrow keys to navigate0.78 ACRESListing by: Brown Harris Stevens
Use arrow keys to navigate3.41 ACRESListing by: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES
Use arrow keys to navigate0.91 ACRESListing by: Compass
Use arrow keys to navigate1 ACREListing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Use arrow keys to navigate0.84 ACRESListing by: Saunders & Associates
Use arrow keys to navigate0.7 ACRESListing by: Sotheby's International Realty
2.92 ACRESListing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
0.5 ACRESListing by: RE/MAX Signature Real Estate
0.94 ACRESListing by: Dering Harbor Real Estate
1.4 ACRESListing by: Corcoran Group
1 ACREListing by: Saunders & Associates
0.5 ACRESListing by: Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
NEW CONSTRUCTION2 ACRESListing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
0.99 ACRESListing by: Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
2.2 ACRESListing by: Keller Williams Realty Greater
0.93 ACRESListing by: Corcoran
0.43 ACRESListing by: Saunders & Associates
1.19 ACRESListing by: Saunders & Associates
1 ACREListing by: Corcoran Group
1.43 ACRESListing by: Corcoran Group
0.92 ACRESListing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
1 ACREListing by: Saunders & Associates
7.9 ACRESListing by: Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons
8 ACRESListing by: Brown Harris Stevens
1.1 ACRESListing by: SERHANT.
1.9 ACRESListing by: Corcoran Group
0.31 ACRESListing by: Corcoran Group
0.97 ACRESListing by: Corcoran Group
2.12 ACRESListing by: Sotheby's International Realty
2 ACRESListing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
0.96 ACRESListing by: Corcoran Group
0.54 ACRESListing by: M Wein Realty Inc.
FOR SALE BY OWNER2 ACRES
NEW CONSTRUCTION1.41 ACRESListing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Shelter Island, NY Real Estate Trends
Learn about the Shelter Island, NY housing market through trends and averages.Affordability of Living in Shelter Island, NY
The median home value is $1,757,954
| Month | Median home value |
|---|---|
| May 2025 | $1.69M |
| June 2025 | $1.7M |
| July 2025 | $1.7M |
| August 2025 | $1.71M |
| September 2025 | $1.72M |
| October 2025 | $1.73M |
| November 2025 | $1.74M |
| December 2025 | $1.74M |
| January 2026 | $1.74M |
| February 2026 | $1.75M |
| March 2026 | $1.75M |
| April 2026 | $1.76M |
Trends and affordability stats are provided by third party data sources.
Average Home Value in Shelter Island, NY, by Home Size
Currently, there are 2 new listings in Shelter Island, NY and 80 homes for sale.
| Home Size | Home Value* |
|---|---|
| 2 bedrooms (3 homes) | $1,084,994 |
| 3 bedrooms (22 homes) | $1,473,343 |
| 4 bedrooms (24 homes) | $2,163,645 |
What Locals Say about Shelter Island
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2026-02-06 15:18:24 PST. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. Click here for more information