Houses For Rent in Shelter Island, NY
93 rentals
Use arrow keys to navigateNEW - 18 HRS AGOBrown Harris Stevens
Use arrow keys to navigateCompass
Use arrow keys to navigate1.25 ACRESDouglas Elliman Real Estate
Use arrow keys to navigate1.5 ACRES
Use arrow keys to navigate1.5 ACRES
Use arrow keys to navigate6 ACRESSotheby's International Realty
Use arrow keys to navigateNEW - 2 DAYS AGO2.01 ACRES
NEW - 2 DAYS AGO0.84 ACRESDouglas Elliman Real Estate
APPLY INSTANTLYFURNISHED
1 ACREDering Harbor Real Estate
1.5 ACRESDering Harbor Real Estate
1.87 ACRESDouglas Elliman Real Estate
0.92 ACRESSaunders & Associates
1 ACREDouglas Elliman Real Estate
0.35 ACRESDaniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
4 ACRESDering Harbor Real Estate
0.71 ACRESDering Harbor Real Estate
Griffing & Collins Real Estate
0.53 ACRESSotheby's International Realty
1.5 ACRESSaunders & Associates
0.75 ACRESSaunders & Associates
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
7 ACRESDouglas Elliman Real Estate
1.01 ACRESDouglas Elliman Real Estate
0.69 ACRESDouglas Elliman Real Estate
1.4 ACRESDering Harbor Real Estate
1.4 ACRESDouglas Elliman Real Estate
Save Search in Shelter Island, NY
Shelter IslandSingle Family HomeGet emails when new homes match this search
Average Rent Trends in Shelter Island, NY
Rent in Shelter Island, NY varies by number of bedrooms and home type. Use these charts to quickly see how rent changes.
Average rent increased in May 2026 compared to the previous month. Rent previously peaked in Sep 2025.
| Month | Average rent |
|---|---|
| Jun 2025 | $25,000 |
| Jul 2025 | $25,000 |
| Aug 2025 | $28,250 |
| Sep 2025 | $30,000 |
| Oct 2025 | $20,000 |
| Nov 2025 | $21,000 |
| Dec 2025 | $20,000 |
| Jan 2026 | $24,000 |
| Feb 2026 | $25,000 |
| Mar 2026 | $25,000 |
| Apr 2026 | $22,500 |
| May 2026 | $25,000 |
Average Rent By Bedroom and Home Type
In May 2026, Houses were the most affordable home type to rent compared with Apartments and Condos.
| 1 bed | 2 beds | 3 beds | 4 beds | All | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All home types | — | $11,666 | $15,000 | $25,000 | $24,000 |
| Apartments and Condos | — | $40,000 | — | $40,000 | $40,000 |
| Houses | — | $8,750 | $15,000 | $25,000 | $22,500 |
Frequently Asked Questions about Houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY
- What is the average rent of a house in Shelter Island, NY?The average rent of a house in Shelter Island, NY is $22,500 per month. This is about 1066% higher than the national average.
- When is the average rent cheapest in Shelter Island, NY?In the last year, the average rent in Shelter Island, NY was lowest in Jan 2025 when it was $14,000 per month.
- When is the average rent most expensive in Shelter Island, NY?In the last year, the average rent in Shelter Island, NY was highest in Sep 2025 when it was $30,000 per month.
- How many houses are available to rent in Shelter Island, NY?There are 81 available houses to rent in Shelter Island, NY.
- What are some neighborhoods in Shelter Island, NY?Some neighborhoods in Shelter Island, NY include: Dering Harbor.
- What are some zip codes in Shelter Island, NY?
- What are some cities near Shelter Island, NY?Some nearby cities include: Greenport, East Marion, Sag Harbor, Southold, Orient. These cities may have more rental options to explore.
