Shelter Island, NY Apartments For Rent

(180)
$45,000
  • 4bd
  • 4ba
  • 3,964 sqft

3 Shorewood Ln

$75,000
  • 6bd
  • 5ba
  • 4,554 sqft

4 Landing Ln

$14,000
  • 4bd
  • 1ba

94 S Ferry Rd

$48,000
  • 4bd
  • 3ba
  • 2,633 sqft

4 Glynn Dr

$16,000
  • 4bd
  • 3ba
  • 2,618 sqft

1 Gazon Rd

$2,300
  • 3bd
  • 2ba

13 Marc St

$32,000
  • 4bd
  • 3ba
  • 2,842 sqft

99 S Midway Rd

$22,600
  • 2bd
  • 2ba
  • 755 sqft

102 W Neck Rd

$27,000
  • 5bd
  • 3ba
  • 3,000 sqft

6 Pennys Path

$30,000
  • Studio

14 S Midway Rd #B

$20,000
  • 3bd
  • 2ba

5 Shorewood Rd

$15,000
  • 4bd
  • 3ba

8 Southwick Ln

$20,000
  • 5bd
  • 3ba

4 Gazon Rd

$22,000
  • 3bd
  • 4ba
  • 1,800 sqft

53 N Midway Rd

First<<12345>>Last
1 - 30 of 180 Results

Summary for Shelter Island, NY


Median rental price for rentals in Shelter Island, NY for March was $16,000, an increase of 167% compared to the same period last year.