Shelter Island, NY Apartments For Rent

(182)
  • 4 Landing Ln Shelter Island NY 11964
    $75,000
    • 6bd
    • 5ba
    • 4,554 sqft
    4 Landing Ln
  • 1 Gardiners Bay Dr #A Shelter Island NY 11964
    $5,500
    • 5bd
    • 3ba
    • 3,100 sqft
    1 Gardiners Bay Dr #A
  • 22 Great Circle Dr Shelter Island NY 11964
    $30,000
    • 5bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,600 sqft
    22 Great Circle Dr
  • 6 Club Dr Shelter Island NY 11964
    $25,000
    • 4bd
    • 4ba
    • 3,500 sqft
    6 Club Dr
  • 22 Peconic Ave Shelter Island NY 11964
    $12,000
    • 3bd
    • 2ba
    • 1,268 sqft
    22 Peconic Ave
  • 10 Country Club Dr Shelter Island NY 11964
    $17,500
    • 3bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,129 sqft
    10 Country Club Dr
  • 33 Lake Dr Shelter Island NY 11964
    $10,500
    • 4bd
    • 3ba
    • 1,343 sqft
    33 Lake Dr
  • 94 S Ferry Rd Shelter Island NY 11964
    $14,000
    • 4bd
    • 1ba
    94 S Ferry Rd
  • 4 Glynn Dr Shelter Island NY 11964
    $48,000
    • 4bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,633 sqft
    4 Glynn Dr
  • 39 S Midway Rd Shelter Island NY 11964
    $75,000
    • 4bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,200 sqft
    39 S Midway Rd
  • 3 Hay Beach Rd Shelter Island NY 11964
    $22,000
    • 4bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,293 sqft
    3 Hay Beach Rd
  • 53 N Midway Rd Shelter Island NY 11964
    $20,000
    • 3bd
    • 3ba
    • 1,404 sqft
    53 N Midway Rd
  • 10 Prospect Ave Shelter Island NY 11964
    $4,000
    • 4bd
    • 2ba
    • 1,421 sqft
    10 Prospect Ave
  • 8 E Brander Pkwy Shelter Island NY 11964
    $3,000
    • 5bd
    • 2ba
    • 2,280 sqft
    8 E Brander Pkwy
  • 5 N Menantic Rd Shelter Island NY 11964
    $10,000
    • 6bd
    • 5ba
    • 3,157 sqft
    5 N Menantic Rd
  • 10 Margarets Dr Shelter Island NY 11964
    $8,000
    • 4bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,393 sqft
    10 Margarets Dr
  • 18 Congdon Rd Shelter Island NY 11964
    $4,500
    • 4bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,445 sqft
    18 Congdon Rd
  • 23 Country Club Dr Shelter Island NY 11964
    $15,000
    • 3bd
    • 2ba
    23 Country Club Dr
  • 5 Simpson Rd Shelter Island NY 11964
    $13,000
    • 4bd
    • 4ba
    • 2,004 sqft
    5 Simpson Rd
  • Address Not Disclosed Shelter Island NY 11964
    $100,000
    • 5bd
    • 7ba
    • 8,000 sqft
    Address Not Disclosed
  • 136 N Ram Island Dr Shelter Island NY 11964
    $7,500
    • 3bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,365 sqft
    136 N Ram Island Dr
  • 9 Pheasant Ln Shelter Island NY 11964
    $45,000
    • 4bd
    • 4ba
    • 3,246 sqft
    9 Pheasant Ln
  • 7 Irene Ln Shelter Island NY 11964
    $3,000
    • 4bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,000 sqft
    7 Irene Ln
  • 1 Gazon Rd Shelter Island NY 11964
    $16,000
    • 4bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,618 sqft
    1 Gazon Rd
  • 137 Ram Island Dr Shelter Island NY 11964
    $60,000
    • 3bd
    • 2ba
    • 1,400 sqft
    137 Ram Island Dr
  • Address Not Disclosed Shelter Island NY 11964
    $60,000
    • 3bd
    • 2ba
    • 2,232 sqft
    Address Not Disclosed
  • 102 W Neck Rd Shelter Island NY 11964
    $22,600
    • 2bd
    • 2ba
    • 755 sqft
    102 W Neck Rd
  • Address Not Disclosed Shelter Island NY 11964
    $40,000
    • 3bd
    • 3ba
    • 1,830 sqft
    Address Not Disclosed
  • 74 E N Cartwright Rd #C Shelter Island NY 11964
  • 99 S Midway Rd Shelter Island NY 11964
    $32,000
    • 4bd
    • 3ba
    • 2,842 sqft
    99 S Midway Rd
First<<12345>>Last
1 - 30 of 182 Results
United StatesNew YorkShelter Island

Summary for Shelter Island, NY


Median rental price for rentals in Shelter Island, NY for March was $21,000, an increase of 111% compared to the same period last year.