Shelter Island, NY Apartments For Rent

(179)
$20,000
  • 6bd
  • 6ba
  • 3,800 sqft

4 Bayview Ave

$26,000
  • 5bd
  • 6ba
  • 4,000 sqft

27 Tuthill Dr

$15,000
  • 3bd
  • 3ba
  • 2,960 sqft

8 Manwaring Rd

$12,000
  • 1bd
  • 1ba

Address Not Disclosed

$15,000
  • 3bd
  • 3ba

Address Not Disclosed

$6,000
  • 5bd
  • 3ba

6 Heron Ln

$30,000
  • 4bd
  • 3ba

Address Not Disclosed

$10,000
  • 4bd
  • 2ba

25 Smith St

$17,500
  • 5bd
  • 3ba

Address Not Disclosed

$10,000
  • 4bd
  • 2ba
  • 1,548 sqft

13 Peconic Ave

$12,000
  • 3bd
  • 2ba
  • 1,374 sqft

137 N Ferry Rd

$60,000
  • 4bd
  • 2ba
  • 1,869 sqft

54 Tuthill Dr

$25,000
  • 3bd
  • 3ba

15 Dickerson Dr

$16,000
  • 3bd
  • 3ba

10 Irene Ln

$13,000
  • 3bd
  • 2ba
  • 1,600 sqft

2 Valley Rd

$23,000
  • 2bd
  • 2ba
  • 3,900 sqft

25 Osprey Rd

31 - 60 of 179 Results

Summary for Shelter Island, NY


Median rental price for rentals in Shelter Island, NY for March was $16,000, an increase of 167% compared to the same period last year.