Recently Sold Co-Ops in Shelter Island, NY

Recently Sold Homes Near Shelter Island, NY

We found 23 more homes matching your filters just outside Shelter Island

• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAY 14, 2026

  $395,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  550 sqft

  131 S Emerson Avenue #216,
  Montauk, NY 11954

  Realty Connect USA L I Inc
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  APR 28, 2026

  $840,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  3.5 Baths

  

  1,427 sqft

  30 Brittany Lane #30,
  Westhampton Beach, NY 11978

  Corcoran
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAR 24, 2026

  $715,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  735 sqft

  514 Pantigo Rd #11,
  East Hampton, NY 11937
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAR 3, 2026

  $250,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  

  900 sqft

  1000 9th Street #D28,
  Greenport, NY 11944

  Andrew Stype Realty Inc
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  MAR 3, 2026

  $730,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  1,100 sqft

  47 Rampasture Road Apt. M,
  Hampton Bays, NY 11946

  Douglas Elliman Real Estate
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  FEB 24, 2026

  $1,250,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,450 sqft

  514 Pantigo Road #16,
  East Hampton, NY 11937

  Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  FEB 6, 2026

  $545,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  800 sqft

  61 West Tiana Rd #24,
  Hampton Bays, NY 11946

  Compass Greater NY LLC
• 

  SOLD

  JAN 16, 2026

  $225,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  650 sqft

  1000 9th Street #C26,
  Greenport, NY 11944

  Century 21 Albertson Realty
• 

  SOLD

  DEC 16, 2025

  $445,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  13,072 sqft

  30 Little Neck Road #21,
  Southampton, NY 11968

  Compass Greater NY LLC
• 

  SOLD

  DEC 16, 2025

  $2,695,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  600 sqft

  92 Ocean Avenue #3,
  East Hampton, NY 11937

  Engel & Volkers North Fork
• 

  SOLD

  DEC 12, 2025

  $349,000

  

  Studio

  

  1 Bath

  

  450 sqft

  2136 Montauk Highway #112,
  Amagansett, NY 11930

  Douglas Elliman Real Estate
• 

  SOLD

  DEC 4, 2025

  $520,000

  

  Studio

  

  1 Bath

  

  550 sqft

  101 Dune Road #C-13,
  East Quogue, NY 11942

  Corcoran
• 

  SOLD

  NOV 18, 2025

  $425,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  

  800 sqft

  61 W Tiana Rd,
  Hampton Bays, NY 11946
• 

  SOLD

  NOV 18, 2025

  $425,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  

  800 sqft

  61 W Tiana Road #3,
  Hampton Bays, NY 11946

  RE/MAX Edge
• 

  SOLD

  NOV 13, 2025

  $1,250,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,078 sqft

  17 Elizabeth #17,
  Sag Harbor, NY 11963

  Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons
• 

  SOLD

  NOV 11, 2025

  $310,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  250 sqft

  231 Dune Road #919,
  Westhampton Beach, NY 11978

  Kerrigan Country Realty
• 

  SOLD

  NOV 7, 2025

  $290,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  475 sqft

  81 West Tiana Road #b5,
  Hampton Bays, NY 11946

  Douglas Elliman Real Estate
• 

  SOLD

  OCT 31, 2025

  $1,849,500

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,500 sqft

  25 Mitchell Road, Unit 6 #6,
  Westhampton Beach, NY 11978

  Scala Custom Properties LTD
• 

  SOLD

  OCT 20, 2025

  $245,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  650 sqft

  1000 Ninth Street #H63,
  Greenport, NY 11944

  Signature Premier Properties
• 

  SOLD

  OCT 9, 2025

  $385,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  1000 9th Street #B-13,
  Greenport, NY 11944

  Douglas Elliman Real Estate
• 

  SOLD

  OCT 8, 2025

  $500,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  500 sqft

  16 Navy Rd Navy Rd #106,
  Montauk, NY 11954

  Douglas Elliman Real Estate
• 

  SOLD

  SEP 5, 2025

  $675,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  600 sqft

  35 Library Avenue #8X,
  Westhampton Beach, NY 11978

  William Raveis New York LLC
• 

  SOLD

  AUG 28, 2025

  $300,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  600 sqft

  12 E Tiana Road #5,
  Hampton Bays, NY 11946

  Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty