For Rent ·

19 Montclair Ave
Shelter Island, NY 11964

  • 4 beds
  • 3 baths
  • 2,400 sqft
  • Single Family Home
See 24 photos
  • See the local terrain and how close this home is to parks and main streets.

    View More

  • Take a virtual walk around the neighborhood.

    View More

  • Lowest crime relative to the rest of Suffolk county.

    View More

  • 4 Elementary Schools

    4 Middle Schools

    4 High Schools

    View More

  • 76% of residents commute by car.

    View More

  • View More

  • Get a feel for the community.

    View More

For Rent ·
Home Details Report this listing
  • Single-Family Home
  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 2,400 sqft
  • No pets allowed
  • 77 days on Trulia

Stunning Shelter Island Waterfront Beach Cottage

Located at the end of a quiet lane with panoramic water views in each direction, this 1930's Beach Cottage has been renovated in high style. From a tranquil veranda, step into the foyer and behold incredible water views before you. A dining area leads to spacious living area with windows all around in an open floor plan. The kitchen has high end appliances with breakfast area immediately adjacent. The first floor offers three beautifully appointed guest bedrooms with shared hall bath. The second floor has a media room with fireplace and wet bar, and two decks, each with water views. The master suite is immediately adjacent with spa like bath. A separate guest Cottage has a playroom-gym and meditation area, and a second cottage is a fully equipped office/library. The waterfront is breathtaking with a dock, small sandy beach, and lawn area for entertainment and games. A unique, first offering on the rental market! Two week rental minimum.

Update: 10/23/2018 22:07PM
  • Great Views
  • Waterfront
  • Heating: Gas
  • Cooling System: Central
  • Architecture Style: Beach House
Report this listing


TIP: Keep your rent within a third of your gross household income.

The ideal income for this property is at least $1,270,080 annually.

Utility Score



Compared to other listings, the utility score for this listing is


Utility Score
Additional Costs

Local Legal Protections

Provided by

Management Company

Explore More Homes