Recently Sold Condos in Town of Shelter Island, NY

Recently Sold Homes Near Town of Shelter Island, NY

We found 30 more homes matching your filters just outside Town of Shelter Island

• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  JUN 9, 2026

  $240,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,080 sqft

  391 Main Street #504,
  Deep River, CT 06417

  Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop.
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  JUN 9, 2026

  $1,591,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  924 sqft

  118 Bay St #4,
  Westerly, RI 02891

  Lila Delman Compass
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  JUN 9, 2026

  $374,900

  

  2 Beds

  

  1.5 Baths

  

  1,210 sqft

  138 Boston Post Road #11,
  East Lyme, CT 06333

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  JUN 9, 2026

  $675,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  2 Baths

  

  639 sqft

  236 Edgemere Street #223,
  Montauk, NY 11954

  Compass Greater NY LLC
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  JUN 8, 2026

  $1,275,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  2,033 sqft

  66 High Street #47,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  Compass Connecticut, LLC
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  JUN 5, 2026

  $350,000

  

  3 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,567 sqft

  400 Bank Street #104,
  New London, CT 06320

  RE/MAX on the Bay
• 

  

  

  Use arrow keys to navigate

  SOLD

  JUN 5, 2026

  $595,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,645 sqft

  22 Whitehall Landing #22,
  Stonington, CT 06378

  Compass Connecticut, LLC
• 

  SOLD

  JUN 5, 2026

  $1,165,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,839 sqft

  48 Dune Drive,
  Jamesport, NY 11947

  Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
• 

  SOLD

  JUN 5, 2026

  $419,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,368 sqft

  21 Beechwood Drive,
  Waterford, CT 06385

  RE/MAX on the Bay
• 

  SOLD

  JUN 4, 2026

  $625,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,565 sqft

  100 Dudley Avenue #H42,
  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  JUN 4, 2026

  $158,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,164 sqft

  16 Village Circle E,
  Manorville, NY 11949

  Realty Connect USA L I Inc
• 

  SOLD

  JUN 3, 2026

  $2,200,000

  

  4 Beds

  

  4.5 Baths

  

  5,501 sqft

  149 Whitehall Avenue,
  Mystic, CT 06355

  Compass Connecticut, LLC
• 

  SOLD

  JUN 2, 2026

  $210,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  

  768 sqft

  144 East Main Street #5,
  Clinton, CT 06413

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  JUN 2, 2026

  $393,087

  

  3 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,396 sqft

  400 Bank Street APT 402,
  New London, CT 06320

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  JUN 2, 2026

  $775,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  2,150 sqft

  6 Ovation Place,
  Eastport, NY 11941

  Corcoran
• 

  SOLD

  JUN 1, 2026

  $280,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,094 sqft

  92 Main Street #206,
  Deep River, CT 06417

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  JUN 1, 2026

  $236,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  1 Bath

  

  969 sqft

  300 Meridian Street #H,
  Groton, CT 06340

  CENTURY 21 Shutters & Sails
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 29, 2026

  $292,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,266 sqft

  92 Main Street #202,
  Deep River, CT 06417

  RE/MAX Legends
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 29, 2026

  $550,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,686 sqft

  6 Rollwood Drive,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  Compass Connecticut, LLC
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 29, 2026

  $460,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,350 sqft

  1403 Pebble Beach Path,
  Riverhead, NY 11901

  Signature Premier Properties
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 29, 2026

  $650,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,562 sqft

  375 Allyn Street #G34,
  Mystic, CT 06355

  Serhant Connecticut, LLC
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 29, 2026

  $425,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,268 sqft

  6 Cypress Way,
  Waterford, CT 06385

  Coldwell Banker Realty
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 29, 2026

  $2,000,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,750 sqft

  22 West Main Street #5,
  Mystic, CT 06355

  Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop.
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 29, 2026

  $555,000

  

  3 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,185 sqft

  1 Bittersweet Lane #1,
  East Lyme, CT 06333

  Coldwell Banker Realty
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 28, 2026

  $569,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  1,673 sqft

  24 Brookville Way,
  Manorville, NY 11949

  Signature Premier Properties
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 28, 2026

  $750,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2.5 Baths

  

  2,090 sqft

  25 Sunset Road #7,
  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  Cavanaugh & Company LLC
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 28, 2026

  $190,000

  

  1 Bed

  

  1 Bath

  

  768 sqft

  127 Black Point Road #31,
  Niantic, CT 06357

  William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 27, 2026

  $535,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,476 sqft

  6 Sandgate Circle,
  Madison, CT 06443

  Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop.
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 27, 2026

  $380,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,459 sqft

  4 Copper Ridge Circle #4,
  Guilford, CT 06437

  RE/MAX Heritage
• 

  SOLD

  MAY 26, 2026

  $549,000

  

  2 Beds

  

  2 Baths

  

  1,310 sqft

  207 Fox Hill Drive,
  Baiting Hollow, NY 11933

  Douglas Elliman Real Estate