Herbert Marcus Elementary School

Withers is a great neighborhood school with awesome options for dual language and gen ed (we are in dual but have lots of friends in gen ed and very happy!) There is a ton of parental involvement and lots of opportunities to be involved.

We are new to FBE this year and they have been nothing short of amazing for us. My daughter is in kindergarten. They have helped support through an ADHD diagnosis and provided resources for a 504 plan and specific support with great results. Thankful for the school leadership who is present, available, and there for the families.

I’m honestly very disappointed with my niece’s experience at this school. She is only 4 years old, and instead of being supported and guided, my sister received phone calls almost every single day about her behavior. It felt excessive and unnecessary for a child that young.The teacher struggled to manage her and didn’t seem to use effective classroom strategies or age-appropriate consequences. There was very little effort to turn situations into teaching moments everything immediately escalated to calling home, even for minor things like putting her watch in her mouth. She’s 4. That’s normal behavior that should be redirected, not treated like a major issue.It also felt like unrealistic expectations were placed on her, as if she was expected to behave like a much older child instead of being given grace to learn and grow.What was most frustrating was the lack of support for our family. At one point, they told her she couldn’t ride the bus, which forced my sister who doesn’t even have a car to scramble and figure out transportation last minute. That was incredibly unfair and showed a lack of consideration.Overall, the school did not provide the patience, structure, or support that young children need. I would not recommend this school based on our experience.

Me encanta esta escuela, los maestros muy profesionales siempre

Great school! Highly recommend. The teachers really care.

During my past few years as a parent at this school, I've realized that this school has many shortcomings that prospective parents should be aware of. The first is the class size. Every class in kindergarten is well above the state cap. One class has 31 kinder students- thirty-one!!! That ratio makes it nearly impossible to build teacher/student relationships, monitor student progress, or really provide any individual attention at all regardless of how skilled the teacher is. The classes within a grade level are not balanced either. Some have 16 or 17 while other classes in the same grade have 25 or 26. Several grades have split level classes. This means that your first grader may be put in a class with mostly second grade students. As a result, your first grader will not see any of his or her friends at recess, lunch, or during specials. They will be isolated from everyone they have been friends with for an entire school year. It's really sad to see your child separated and missing all of their friends and working on above grade level curriculum they may or may not be ready for. This school uses and openly supports shame based punishment. Students clip up or down on a behavior chart displayed in front of the whole class. Can you imagine as an adult if every time you made a mistake at work, you had to get up in front of your collogues to move a clip with your number down? Or, if every time you did something compliant, you clipped up above your coworkers? This behavior system is antiquated, goes against current academic research, and creates a competitive community where students are viewed and labeled as good or bad in front of everyone. At a time when youth are struggling with mental health more than ever, this school disregards student emotional well being and places more emphasis on compliance and fear/shame based behavior management. The communication about academics at this school is inconsistent. Only a few teachers send out weekly newsletters. Parents have no clue what their students are working on, which in turn makes it very difficult to support your child academically. Yes, there was one curriculum night that overviewed the entire year, but for parents who want to work with their child at home, you are left on your own guessing what would be beneficial. Many of these shortcomings would be easy to fix; it's just not a priority which is a shame. This could be a great school, but it needs a leader with a vision who strives for growth.