What's the average rent in West Islip, NY?

Rental Market Trends in West Islip, NY

SOURCE: TRULIA DATA

Rental market highlights

As of May 2026, the average rent in West Islip, NY is $3,300 per month, which is 71% higher than the national average rent of $1,930 per month.

AVERAGE RENT

$3,300

37.5%$900 increase month-over-month

46.7%$1,050 increase year-over-year

AVAILABLE RENTALS

APARTMENTS

$2,304

HOUSES

$3,450

TOWNHOUSES

$3,300

As of May 2026, apartments are the most affordable rental option in West Islip, NY at $2,304 per month, while houses are the most expensive at $3,450 per month. Townhomes average $3,300 per month, offering a mid-range alternative for renters.

Average rent by number of bedrooms

Floor plan type	Average rent
1 Bedroom	$2,400
2 Bedrooms	$2,650
3 Bedrooms	$3,450
4 Bedrooms	—
All	$3,300

As of May 2026, the average rent for a 1 bedroom rental in West Islip, NY is $2,400 per month, followed by $2,650 for a 2 bedroom rental, and $3,450 for a 3 bedroom rental.

Floor plan type	Average rent
1 Bedroom	—
2 Bedrooms	—
3 Bedrooms	$3,300
4 Bedrooms	—
All	$3,300

Floor plan type	Average rent
1 Bedroom	$1,850
2 Bedrooms	$2,500
3 Bedrooms	$3,500
4 Bedrooms	—
All	$2,500

As of May 2026, the average rent for a 1 bedroom apartment in West Islip, NY is $1,850 per month, followed by $2,500 for a 2 bedroom apartment, and $3,500 for a 3 bedroom apartment.