City Island, New York Real Estate & Homes For Sale

  • See All

27 homes

Real Estate & Homes For Sale Near City Island, New York, NY

We found 30 more homes matching your filters just outside City Island

City Island, New York, NY Real Estate Trends

Learn about the City Island, New York, NY housing market through trends and averages.

Affordability of Living in City Island, New York, NY

The median home value is $661,939
MonthMedian home value
September 2025$643k
October 2025$644k
November 2025$646k
December 2025$647k
January 2026$648k
February 2026$650k
March 2026$653k
April 2026$656k
May 2026$658k
June 2026$659k
July 2026$660k
August 2026$662k
View as a graph
Trends and affordability stats are provided by third party data sources.

Average Home Value in City Island, New York, NY, by Home Size

Home SizeHome Value*
2 bedrooms (See homes)$595,180
3 bedrooms (See homes)$737,511
*Home value over the past month

Explore the Neighborhood

Skip to last item
Skip to first item
Neighborhood stats provided by third party data sources.

What Locals Say about City Island

Review Highlights

City Island, New York: steady, welcoming enclave with a top K-8, safety, and long-term value. People love the safety, close-knit feel, K-8 school, walkability, and waterfront lifestyle. They dislike limited transit, occasional isolation, and heavy, noisy summer visitor traffic.
AI-generated summary of moderated reviews.
Flag
  • Dr. Mikey
    City Island, New York
    "Most people are kind and courteous. However, the dog walkers feel entitled to leave the dogs waste on the grass or street near your property. "
    0
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    City Island, New York
    "A lot of dog owners walk their dogs off leash and/or don't pick up their dog's poop. "
    2
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    City Island, New York
    "It’s very safe and family friendly as well as helpful neighbors which make it easier to make yourself a home "
    0
    Flag
  • Llind410
    City Island, New York
    "Street Fair, Columbus Day parade, seafood restaurants, near the beach, views of the water through out the island and hiking and horse trails. Wouldn’t live anywhere else."
    2
    Flag
  • Joenathan232000
    City Island, New York
    "That everyone is friendly, helpful and makes you feel like family. The teachers at the school are anazing."
    0
    Flag
  • Caleb D.
    City Island, New York
    "City Island is a tight nit community. If you walking your dog, of course you are expected to curb your dog. The community have pride in where they live and cleanliness is a priority when it comes to that. That’s why it attracts people to seek out City Island as home. I work here so you can say that I live here because most of my time I’m here."
    5
    Flag
  • Nicholas A. W.
    City Island, New York
    "this area has a wonderful community. many people are open and inviting and everyone looks out for one another. "
    0
    Flag
  • Jackguzda
    City Island, New York
    "CI needs either a ferry or constant express busses - because we have neither we are labeled a "transportation desert"."
    7
    Flag
  • Karilyn R.
    City Island, New York
    "Being on the island can be isolating at some times. But it also great views of the water and 1 good restaurant. The neighborhood is very safe. "
    13
    Flag
  • Stuso414
    City Island, New York
    "It is a mix of people of all backgrounds and socioeconomic levels. The neighborhood has bars restaurants ice Cream parlors within walking distance. There are three churches and one synagogue. There is one K-8 School that has a great reputation. It is a close knit community "
    14
    Flag
  • Stephanie .
    City Island, New York
    "Beautiful clean neighborhood with good community and good food. On the water and Close to the beach "
    8
    Flag
  • Stuso414
    City Island, New York
    "It is an old fishing and boating village. Nowadays there are a lot of seafood restaurants, a few art galleries and antique stores. There are marinas to keep boats. There are a few yacht clubs to join. There is a wonderful public school that is K-8. There is a library, a supermarket and a small market. Lots of places to walk and you are surrounded by Long Island Sound. The west side of City Island faces Manhattan. "
    1
    Flag
  • Loakes
    City Island, New York
    "This is a great neighborhood to raise a family. Everyone is friendly and welcoming. We moved into our home and the neighbors immediately dropped by, left cards and introduced themselves. "
    0
    Flag
  • Steve
    City Island, New York
    "It’s a small town with New York an hour transit ride away. We just moved here and it’s surreal, we even leave the door unlocked half the time when going out to grab a coffee etc. You can feel a strong sense of community pride here. "
    7
    Flag
  • Jtllr58
    City Island, New York
    "I'm new to the area. I been here since April. Great Sea Food restaurants though; in a peaceful surrounding. "
    0
    Flag
  • Jeff H.
    City Island, New York
    "I have 2 dogs and most neighbors have dogs, as a matter of fact I’d say most homes have dogs. On my block there are 18 homes at least 10 have dogs. We all pick up poop...lol"
    0
    Flag
  • Llind410
    City Island, New York
    "It’s a family oriented community, you get to know your neighbors even if it’s just faces. On the Island we do have an annual street fair, community board meetings, a food CO-OP and many more activities for residents to be involved in. It definitely has a small town feel which we love. "
    0
    Flag
  • Stuso414
    City Island, New York
    "It is a quaint little fishing village that has a large number of seafood restaurants and lots of boaters and tourists. Summer traffic can be a challenge but living here is worth the minor inconvenience. Lovely neighbors and Water views make this little town a slice of heaven"
    5
    Flag
  • Airenice
    City Island, New York
    "I live here for two years and I love my drive home! It's a small town based community with Mom & Pop stores. All this and more in Da' Bronx!"
    4
    Flag

Learn more about City Island

See information on schools, amenities and more.See City Island Insights

Browse City Island, New York, NY homes by type

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2026-09-26 01:03:10 PDT All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. Click here for more information