BuyScuttleholeHomes for SaleOpen HousesNew HomesRecently SoldWater MillHomes for SaleOpen HousesRecently SoldRentScuttleholeApartments for RentHouses for RentTownhomes for RentWater MillHouses for RentTownhomes for RentPost A Rental ListingMortgageWater MillMortgage OverviewGet Pre-QualifiedMortgage RatesRefinance RatesMortgage CalculatorAffordability CalculatorRefinance CalculatorRent vs Buy CalculatorSaved HomesSaved SearchesSign up or Log inWater Mill, NYScuttleholeNeighborhood OverviewNo for sale dataNo homes for saleNo rental dataNo homes for rentNo commute dataRatings unavailableSchoolsPreschoolElementaryMiddleHighThe Hayground SchoolPK-8Private87 StudentsNAGreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageN/AParent Review18y agoThe GreatSchools Rating compares schools on a variety of school quality indicators including test scores, college readiness, equity and more. Learn more.Homes in ScuttleholeFor Sale (0)For Rent (0)No homes for sale in this neighborhoodSearch Homes in ScuttleholeNearby Neighborhoods in Water MillSkip to last itemNoyack52 homes for saleBuy: $899K - $35MSee Local HighlightsNorth Sea60 homes for saleBuy: $799K - $15MSee Local HighlightsSouthampton Village69 homes for saleBuy: $1.1M - $50MSee Local HighlightsNorth Haven24 homes for saleBuy: $1.77M - $29.9MSee Local HighlightsNorthwest Harbor85 homes for saleBuy: $850K - $11.3MSee Local HighlightsEast Hampton Village32 homes for saleBuy: $595K - $38MSee Local HighlightsEast Hampton North42 homes for saleBuy: $489K - $17MSee Local HighlightsDering Harbor1 home for saleBuy: $2.9M+See Local HighlightsSprings58 homes for saleBuy: $625K - $8.49MSee Local HighlightsGreenport West37 homes for saleBuy: $243K - $5.7MSee Local HighlightsSkip to first item
