BuyMessenger BayHomes for SaleOpen HousesNew HomesRecently SoldCanastotaHomes for SaleOpen HousesRecently SoldRentMessenger BayApartments for RentHouses for RentTownhomes for RentCanastotaHouses for RentTownhomes for RentPost A Rental ListingMortgageCanastotaMortgage OverviewGet Pre-QualifiedMortgage RatesRefinance RatesMortgage CalculatorAffordability CalculatorRefinance CalculatorRent vs Buy CalculatorSaved HomesSaved SearchesSign up or Log inEnglishEnglish / ENEspañol / ESCanastota, NYMessenger BayNeighborhood OverviewNo for sale dataNo homes for saleNo rental dataNo homes for rentNo commute dataRatings unavailableSchoolsPreschoolElementaryMiddleHighNo schools available in this neighborhoodThe GreatSchools Rating compares schools on a variety of school quality indicators including test scores, college readiness, equity and more. Learn more.Homes in Messenger BayFor Sale (0)For Rent (0)No homes for sale in this neighborhoodSearch Homes in Messenger BayNearby Neighborhoods in CanastotaSkip to last itemOneida Castle3 homes for saleBuy: $235K - $395KSee Local HighlightsMattydale17 homes for saleBuy: $110K - $270KSee Local HighlightsEastwood29 homes for saleBuy: $3K - $380KSee Local HighlightsSalt Springs11 homes for saleBuy: $20K - $258KSee Local HighlightsMeadowbrook22 homes for saleBuy: $159K - $449KSee Local HighlightsLyncourt15 homes for saleBuy: $17.5K - $500KSee Local HighlightsSedgwick6 homes for saleBuy: $165K - $3.05MSee Local HighlightsLincoln Park4 homes for saleBuy: $116K - $279KSee Local HighlightsNorthside21 homes for saleBuy: $12.5K - $3.3MSee Local HighlightsWescott11 homes for saleBuy: $189K - $795KSee Local HighlightsSkip to first item