5309 E Sutton St, Indianapolis, IN 46218
OFF MARKET

5309 E Sutton St
Indianapolis, IN 46218

Eastside
  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Bath
  • 750 sqft

$108,400

Trulia Estimate
as of May 24, 2026
Est. Refi. Payment $707/mo*
Refinance Your Home

$108,400

Trulia Estimate
as of May 24, 2026
Est. Refi. Payment $707/mo*
Refinance Your Home
2 Beds
1 Bath
750 sqft

Local Information

Map showing home location
© Google
-- mins to
Commute Destination

Description

If you're looking to rent a new home in the Otterbein Neighborhood in Indianapolis, IN you're in luck! 5309 E Sutton St is a 750 square foot home available to lease today! This home has 2 bedrooms and 1 baths and in the 46218 zip code. This home has a fenced in front yard, a front porch, and with a detached garage. It also comes with a full basement. Browse photos of 5309 E Sutton St and apply for a lease online! The VineBrook Homes property management company will verify your lease application and send you a timely response.

Only one application is accepted at a time - if the Vinebrook website does not allow you to submit an application then the home is on hold for someone. Please check back frequently. Applications are processed within 2 days.
Approved Applicants can hold the home for up to 14 days with down payment. Please apply only if you are able to take possession of home within this time frame.
Utilities are tenant responsibility.
Up to two pets permitted (No Weight Limit but Breed Restrictions apply)
$150 Pet Fee per Pet and $25/month pet rent per pet.
No Pitt Bull, Doberman, Rottweiler, American Staffordshire, Chow Chow or mix containing these breeds.
Home is NOT approved for housing voucher.
This property is off market, which means it's not currently listed for sale or rent on Trulia. This may be different from what's available on other websites or public sources.

Home Highlights

Parking
Garage
Outdoor
No Info
A/C
Heating & Cooling
HOA
None
Price/Sqft
No Info
Listed
No Info

Home Details for 5309 E Sutton St

Interior Features

Heating & Cooling
Heating: Forced AirCooling System: OtherHeating Fuel: Forced Air
Levels, Entrance, & Accessibility
Stories: 1Floors: Hardwood
Interior Details
Number of Rooms: 5
Appliances & Utilities
DishwasherDryerWasher

Exterior Features

Exterior Home Features
Roof: Asphalt
Parking & Garage
GarageParking: Garage Detached

Property Information

Year Built
Year Built: 1953Year Updated: 1953
Property Type / Style
Property Type: Single Family Home

Community

Units in Building: 1

Lot Information

Lot Area: 5488 sqft

Price History for 5309 E Sutton St

DatePriceEventSource
09/08/2022ListingRemovedZillow Rental Manager
09/01/2022$950Listed For RentZillow Rental Manager
11/04/2021$60,000Sold
N/A
05/04/2020$675ListingRemovedAgent Provided
05/01/2020$675Listed For RentAgent Provided
03/16/2015$7,500Sold
N/A
04/10/2006$29,000Sold
N/A
Skip to last item
  • Results are loading
Skip to first item

Property Tax and Assessment

Year2025
Tax$1,758
Assessment$91,800
Home facts updated by county records

Comparable Sales for 5309 E Sutton St

Address
Distance
Property Type
Sold Price
Sold Date
Bed
Bath
Sqft
5418 E 19th St, Indianapolis, IN
0.15
Single-Family Home
$100,000
09/30/25
2
1
768
5349 E 19th Pl, Indianapolis, IN
0.14
Single-Family Home
$84,000
09/10/25
2
1
1,440
5409 E 19th St, Indianapolis, IN
0.19
Single-Family Home
$138,500
09/17/25
2
1
768
5427 E 19th St, Indianapolis, IN
0.18
Single-Family Home
$150,000
06/27/25
2
1
768
2115 N Butler Ave, Indianapolis, IN
0.13
Single-Family Home
$20,000
07/21/25
2
1
840
1825 N Hawthorne Ln, Indianapolis, IN
0.26
Single-Family Home
$128,647
10/16/25
2
1
768
5473 E 19th St, Indianapolis, IN
0.23
Single-Family Home
$150,000
12/04/25
2
1
768
2241 N Butler Ave, Indianapolis, IN
0.31
Single-Family Home
$50,000
03/02/26
3
1
836
5402 E 20th Pl, Indianapolis, IN
0.11
Single-Family Home
$155,000
05/11/26
2
1
1,440
1801 N Bauer Rd, Indianapolis, IN
0.30
Single-Family Home
$152,500
07/28/25
2
1
768

Nearby homes

Get a sense of prices in the area by checking nearby homes.
Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Assigned Schools

These are the assigned schools for 5309 E Sutton St.
View nearby schools on GreatSchools
The GreatSchools Rating compares schools on a variety of school quality indicators including test scores, college readiness, equity and more. Learn more.

Neighborhood Overview

Eastside
See Local Highlights
Neighborhood stats provided by third party data sources.

What Locals Say about Eastside

At least 58 Trulia users voted on each feature.

  • 92 % Say car is needed

  • 82 % Say yards are well-kept

  • 81 % Say parking is easy

  • 76 % Say it's dog friendly

  • 75 % Say there's holiday spirit

  • 72 % Say kids play outside

  • 57 % Say there are sidewalks

  • 52 % Say they plan to stay for at least 5 years

  • 46 % Say neighbors are friendly

  • 45 % Say it's walkable to restaurants

  • 42 % Say streets are well-lit

  • 41 % Say there's wildlife

  • 40 % Say it's quiet

  • 36 % Say people would walk alone at night

  • 34 % Say it's walkable to grocery stores

  • 21 % Say there are community events

Sourced by Trulia users. Learn more about our methodology.
  • Jennifer Leeds Byerly
    "Close community that really watches out for each other and animals in the area. Deep sense of pride in this area"
    0
    Flag
  • Unspecified
    "We play outside play in backyard movie night game night fun night every night sleepovers left to walk the dogs"
    0
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "It has great people, good food, and feels like a small city of its own. You don’t have to go far to get what you need and there are lots of unique one of a kind places to eat and shop. "
    7
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "it's a pretty good place to live and maybe they have there on way to describe how this neighborhood is but I love this neighborhood it's a great place to call home they have everything from the church and play ground for the children and they just built a youth center I think that's awesome for all our children in Arlington woods community great place for all ."
    0
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "There is a pocket of several square blocks around our central location which is almost crime-free. It makes living here comfortable. In addition, there is a diner just two blocks away we really love, Steer Inn."
    10
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "Love the farmers market on Wednesdays, they have wonderful vendors and great products … we go every Wednesdays 😀"
    0
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "Irvington is a wonderful community full of mixed nationalities and backgrounds. I feel safe and at home here in Irvington where I’ve lived since I was 13"
    0
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "Our neighborhood is so quite and nice to walk in the evenings… we love how close we are to restaurants and shopping "
    0
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "This area has such great little shops and places to eat I’m things to do tons of parks and a wonderful neighborhood to walk your doggies "
    0
    Flag
  • Tabitha D. B. .
    "Commute is pretty moderate and manageable unless it’s rush hour and then you have congestion mostly near the highway ramps and that’s it"
    2
    Flag
  • William B.
    "Symphony at the park, local yard sales and the ability to walk down the street safely. My kids play in the yard daily. "
    2
    Flag
  • Tony G.
    "the people are friendly and look out for one another. it's a fairly safe neighborhood. it's also centrally located"
    15
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "it's a nice neighborhood depending on what street you are on. it could be very nice in one are like mine is or you could go up a few streets and it's very bad and very different."
    2
    Flag
  • Amy C.
    "This area is full of history, full of a caring community members. close to downtown , biking trails. "
    5
    Flag
  • Amanda S.
    "Irvington isn’t far nice for walks Halloween festival is awesome Nice shops too walk too nice Neighbors are good and look out as well "
    2
    Flag
  • Camille M.
    "this neighborhood is clean and quiet. you do see alot of people walking their dogs. everyone seems friendly."
    3
    Flag
  • Anmjones
    "Ellenberger Park. Low crime. Fantastic tight-knit, neighbors. Unofficial neighborhood watch, basically everyone looks out for their neighbor’s property and well-being. Responsive policing. Near the hospital, quick drive to all parts of town and cultural events. Thriving new businesses and restaurants. "
    17
    Flag
  • Cheryl
    "I just got neighbors on one side we speak when we see each other they Mexican I can't understand them sometimes"
    7
    Flag
  • Jake_beck
    "We’ve been here five years. We like the small town feel and quick drive to downtown. We know our neighbors and are involved in. Our community. "
    14
    Flag
  • Mary M.
    "Ellenberger Park is close by and there are bike lanes on the main streets which makes bike travel safer"
    0
    Flag
  • Lylefrogers
    "there are families that there with great parking areas to park and for the kids to play i love it here and wanna stay awhile"
    0
    Flag

LGBTQ Local Legal Protections

Apartments for Rent

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Explore by feature

Homes for sale near 5309 E Sutton St

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Off Market Homes Near 5309 E Sutton St

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Homes for rent near 5309 E Sutton St

Skip to last item
Skip to first item
5309 E Sutton St, Indianapolis, IN 46218 is a 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom, 750 sqft single-family home built in 1953. 5309 E Sutton St is located in Eastside, Indianapolis. This property is not currently available for sale. 5309 E Sutton St was last sold on Nov 4, 2021 for $60,000. The current Trulia Estimate for 5309 E Sutton St is $108,400.