5309 E Sutton St
Indianapolis, IN 46218
Eastside
2 Beds
1 Bath
750 sqft
$100,200
as of Aug 22, 2026
$100,200
as of Aug 22, 2026
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 750 sqft
Home Highlights
Property Type
Single-Family Home
Year Built
1953
Living Area
750 sqft
Price/Sqft
$134
Local Information
- Map ViewExplore the area around 5309 E Sutton St.
- Schools7 Preschool Schools11 Elementary Schools4 Middle Schools4 High Schools
- Shop & Eat
-- mins to
About this House
Currently Accepting Applications!
Your estimated total monthly payment is $1,092.89
The total estimated monthly payment is comprised of the following:
Mandatory Fees:
Base Rent - $1,045.00
Damage Waiver Fee - $14.95 (Covers up to $100,000 for resident-caused damage from fire, water, smoke, explosions, sewer backups, or falling objects.)
Smart Home Fee - $22.95 (smart front door lock and smart thermostat)
Utility Management - $9.99 (services for managing utility accounts)
-Additionally, a one-time set-up fee of $30.00 is charged on your first month's bill.
Optional Fees: Animal Fees - Approved animals incur a non-refundable pet fee of $250 - $350 per animal and a monthly pet rent of $30 - $35 per animal (subject to applicable law). Pet fees and pet rent do not apply to service or support animals. Please note that we have breed restrictions, including but not limited to Pit Bull Terriers, Doberman Pinschers, Rottweilers, Staffordshire Terriers, German Shepherds, Chows, Bull Mastiffs, Huskies, Alaskan Malamutes, Wolf Dog Hybrids, Great Danes, St. Bernards, Akitas, and Rhodesian Ridgebacks, as well as any mixed breeds containing these types.
Other Fees: In addition to the total monthly payment, Tenant(s) are also responsible for additional costs including, but not limited to, utilities, optional services, conditional and other applicable charges. All fees are subject to change and will be outlined in the lease agreement.
Tours: To ensure a secure process, please schedule tours and apply for our properties exclusively through the official Evergreen Live website.
Property Description: Welcome home to this 2 bedroom, 1 bath home with a nice size backyard perfect for entertaining guests or enjoying a quiet morning with a cup of coffee. The nice kitchen is complete with all appliances and plenty of cabinets. With plenty of natural light throughout, this inviting home is just waiting for you to make it your own. Don't miss out on this incredible opportunity to make this house your home. Schedule your showing today!
Listing Disclosures: All leasing information is believed to be accurate; however, photos are representative only and may not reflect current appliances and/or features of the home. Square footage is estimated, and prices, specials and dates may change without notice and are not guaranteed until a lease agreement is executed.
Application: An application fee of $50 per applicant for 18 and over is required, and the minimum lease term is one year (12 months). Completed applications are reviewed on a first-come, first-served basis, and the security deposit varies based upon TransUnion Resident Score credit criteria. You must have a verifiable source of income that is at least three times the monthly rent. After you submit your lease application, all adult applicants receive an invitation from our income verification service, Payscore, with a link to guide you through your income verification. All applicants must complete the process within 48 hours of receiving an invitation or your application may be delayed or not approved.
Security Deposit: A cash security deposit range from one to one and a half months' rent is due prior to moving-in. Cash security deposits are eligible for refund upon vacating the home, less deductions for damages, unpaid rent or other charges, in each case subject to applicable law.
Please be aware that rental fraud and rental scams are on the rise. Evergreen Live will never ask you to pay any amounts in cash, transfer money via wire, prepaid or digital gift cards, send MoneyGram, or request funds through Zelle or any non-Evergreen Live payment app, such as Venmo, PayPal, Apple Pay, or others.
Your estimated total monthly payment is $1,092.89
The total estimated monthly payment is comprised of the following:
Mandatory Fees:
Base Rent - $1,045.00
Damage Waiver Fee - $14.95 (Covers up to $100,000 for resident-caused damage from fire, water, smoke, explosions, sewer backups, or falling objects.)
Smart Home Fee - $22.95 (smart front door lock and smart thermostat)
Utility Management - $9.99 (services for managing utility accounts)
-Additionally, a one-time set-up fee of $30.00 is charged on your first month's bill.
Optional Fees: Animal Fees - Approved animals incur a non-refundable pet fee of $250 - $350 per animal and a monthly pet rent of $30 - $35 per animal (subject to applicable law). Pet fees and pet rent do not apply to service or support animals. Please note that we have breed restrictions, including but not limited to Pit Bull Terriers, Doberman Pinschers, Rottweilers, Staffordshire Terriers, German Shepherds, Chows, Bull Mastiffs, Huskies, Alaskan Malamutes, Wolf Dog Hybrids, Great Danes, St. Bernards, Akitas, and Rhodesian Ridgebacks, as well as any mixed breeds containing these types.
Other Fees: In addition to the total monthly payment, Tenant(s) are also responsible for additional costs including, but not limited to, utilities, optional services, conditional and other applicable charges. All fees are subject to change and will be outlined in the lease agreement.
Tours: To ensure a secure process, please schedule tours and apply for our properties exclusively through the official Evergreen Live website.
Property Description: Welcome home to this 2 bedroom, 1 bath home with a nice size backyard perfect for entertaining guests or enjoying a quiet morning with a cup of coffee. The nice kitchen is complete with all appliances and plenty of cabinets. With plenty of natural light throughout, this inviting home is just waiting for you to make it your own. Don't miss out on this incredible opportunity to make this house your home. Schedule your showing today!
Listing Disclosures: All leasing information is believed to be accurate; however, photos are representative only and may not reflect current appliances and/or features of the home. Square footage is estimated, and prices, specials and dates may change without notice and are not guaranteed until a lease agreement is executed.
Application: An application fee of $50 per applicant for 18 and over is required, and the minimum lease term is one year (12 months). Completed applications are reviewed on a first-come, first-served basis, and the security deposit varies based upon TransUnion Resident Score credit criteria. You must have a verifiable source of income that is at least three times the monthly rent. After you submit your lease application, all adult applicants receive an invitation from our income verification service, Payscore, with a link to guide you through your income verification. All applicants must complete the process within 48 hours of receiving an invitation or your application may be delayed or not approved.
Security Deposit: A cash security deposit range from one to one and a half months' rent is due prior to moving-in. Cash security deposits are eligible for refund upon vacating the home, less deductions for damages, unpaid rent or other charges, in each case subject to applicable law.
Please be aware that rental fraud and rental scams are on the rise. Evergreen Live will never ask you to pay any amounts in cash, transfer money via wire, prepaid or digital gift cards, send MoneyGram, or request funds through Zelle or any non-Evergreen Live payment app, such as Venmo, PayPal, Apple Pay, or others.
5309 E Sutton St, Indianapolis, IN 46218 is a 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom, 750 sqft single-family home in Eastside, built in 1953. It last sold for $60,000 on Nov 4, 2021 (5,642% above the $1,045 asking price). More recently, it was listed as a rental in June 2026 with an asking price of $1,045 per month. That rental listing was removed on July 6, 2026. It is currently off market. The Trulia Estimate is $100,200, with a rent estimate of $1,065/month.
Home Details for 5309 E Sutton St
|
|---|
Year Built Year Built: 1953 |
Property Type / Style Property Type: Single Family Home |
|
|---|
Lease Term: Contact For DetailsAvailable: now |
Comparable Sales for 5309 E Sutton St
Address | Distance | Property Type | Sold Price | Sold Date | Bed | Bath | Sqft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0.17 | Single-Family Home | $85,000 | 06/08/26 | 2 | 1 | 768 sqft | |
0.15 | Single-Family Home | $100,000 | 09/30/25 | 2 | 1 | 768 sqft | |
0.14 | Single-Family Home | $84,000 | 09/10/25 | 2 | 1 | 1,440 sqft | |
0.19 | Single-Family Home | $138,500 | 09/17/25 | 2 | 1 | 768 sqft | |
0.26 | Single-Family Home | $128,647 | 10/16/25 | 2 | 1 | 768 sqft | |
0.23 | Single-Family Home | $150,000 | 12/04/25 | 2 | 1 | 768 sqft | |
0.31 | Single-Family Home | $50,000 | 03/02/26 | 3 | 1 | 836 sqft | |
0.29 | Single-Family Home | $91,630 | 12/02/25 | 2 | 1 | 1,152 sqft | |
0.26 | Single-Family Home | $116,797 | 07/21/26 | 2 | 1 | 1,096 sqft | |
0.11 | Single-Family Home | $155,000 | 05/11/26 | 2 | 1 | 1,440 sqft |
Nearby homes
Get a sense of prices in the area by checking nearby homes.
OFF MARKETKey Realty Indiana, Sold
OFF MARKETHighgarden Real Estate, Sold
OFF MARKETBecks Real Estate LLC, Sold
OFF MARKETBerkshire Hathaway Home, Sold
OFF MARKETCarpenter, REALTORSĀ®, Sold
OFF MARKETRed Bridge Real Estate, Sold
OFF MARKETTrue Property Management, Sold
OFF MARKETF.C. Tucker Company, Sold
OFF MARKETArtisan, REALTORSĀ®, Sold
OFF MARKETRE/MAX Advantage Realty, Sold
OFF MARKETApter Properties, LLC, Sold
Around this home
- Anna Brochhausen School 88
- PK-5
- Public
- 326 Students
3/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageThe parent community is very involved at this school and the teachers are top notch! Staff are welcoming and try to match new students with the best classroom for their personality.Principal Review2y ago - Brookside School 54
- PK-5
- Public
- 366 Students
3/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageThis school is the worst school I've let my children go to they allow bullying, and fighting, and they are allowed to flip desks, throw stuff, Etc.Also, the teachers in this school are very disrespectful to students, my son came to me saying that his teacher yelled at him for not doing his work because someone broke his pencil, he told me he tried to explain to the teacher but she wouldn't let him explain. You also can't learn at this school the kids are way too loud and you can't hear the teacher. There ain't no way my 2 honor roll kids' grades went down that much over 6 months. In my solid opinion, they learn better in 2020 when online school was in effect. So, you won't see me or my kids here next year.Parent Review3y ago - Eliza A. Blaker School 55
- PK-5
- Public
- 301 Students
5/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating Average
No reviews available for this school. - Thomas D. Gregg School 15
- PK-5
- Public
- 525 Students
4/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageNo reviews available for this school. - Arlington Woods School 99
- PK-6
- Public
- 361 Students
4/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageNo reviews available for this school. - James Russell Lowell School 51
- PK-5
- Public
- 363 Students
3/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageThey genuinely do not teach anything here you are expected to learn yourselfOther Review3mo ago - Center for Inquiry School 27
- PK-5
- Public
- 348 Students
4/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageThis school was amazing the teachers were so nice and kind and they cared about there feelings. I had amazing teachers and friends.Other Review1y ago
Neighborhood Overview
Neighborhood stats provided by third party data sources.
What Locals Say about Eastside
At least 60 Trulia users voted on each feature.
91 % Say car is needed
82 % Say yards are well-kept
82 % Say parking is easy
77 % Say it's dog friendly
75 % Say there's holiday spirit
71 % Say kids play outside
57 % Say there are sidewalks
52 % Say they plan to stay for at least 5 years
46 % Say neighbors are friendly
44 % Say it's walkable to restaurants
41 % Say there's wildlife
41 % Say streets are well-lit
39 % Say it's quiet
36 % Say people would walk alone at night
33 % Say it's walkable to grocery stores
21 % Say there are community events
Sourced by Trulia users. Learn more about our methodology.
LGBTQ Local Legal Protections
LGBTQ Local Legal Protections
Price and Tax history
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
Jul 6, 2026 Source: Zillow Rentals | ListingRemoved | $1,045 |
Jun 10, 2026 Source: Zillow Rentals | Listed For Rent | $1,045 |
Sep 8, 2022 Source: Zillow Rental Manager | ListingRemoved | |
Sep 1, 2022 Source: Zillow Rental Manager | Listed For Rent | $950 |
Nov 4, 2021 Source: N/A | Sold | $60,000 |
May 4, 2020 Source: Agent Provided | ListingRemoved | $675 |
May 1, 2020 Source: Agent Provided | Listed For Rent | $675 |
Mar 16, 2015 Source: N/A | Sold | $7,500 |
Apr 10, 2006 Source: N/A | Sold | $29,000 |
| Year | Property tax | Tax assessment |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $1,758 | $91,800 |
Home facts updated by county records
Frequently asked questions about 5309 E Sutton St
- What is 5309 E Sutton St estimated to be worth?Trulia's estimated value for 5309 E Sutton St in Indianapolis, IN is $100,200.
- What is the price history for 5309 E Sutton St?5309 E Sutton St in Indianapolis, IN last sold for $60,000 in November 2021.
- Is Indianapolis a buyer's or seller's market?Indianapolis is currently a buyer's market, based on recent for-sale activity.
- What's the median sale price in Indianapolis?The median sale price in Indianapolis is $251K. That is up $10K from the prior month.
Homes for rent near 5309 E Sutton St
PET FRIENDLY
NEW - 2 DAYS AGOPET FRIENDLY- NEW - 1 DAY AGO
See more homes for rent inIndianapolis
Affordability
TIP:Try to keep your rent within a third of your gross household income. Learn why in our Renter's Guide.
For this property
PER YEAR
is the suggested income
Win over prospective landlords with your smart budgeting. As a good rule of thumb, ideally you would have at least three times your monthly rent in combined household income.
- Results are loading