Is Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL dog-friendly?

As of early 2026, 100% of users say it's dog friendly

Is a car needed in Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL?

As of early 2026, 92% of users say car is needed

Is Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL quiet?

As of early 2026, 85% of users say it's quiet

Would people walk alone at night in Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL?

As of early 2026, 78% of users say people would walk alone at night

Is parking easy in Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL?

As of early 2026, 77% of users say parking is easy

Does Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL show holiday spirit?

As of early 2026, 77% of users say there's holiday spirit

Are yards well-kept in Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL?

As of early 2026, 71% of users say yards are well-kept

Is there wildlife in Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL?

As of early 2026, 65% of users say there's wildlife

Are neighbors friendly in Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL?

As of early 2026, 60% of users say neighbors are friendly

Is Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL walkable to restaurants?

As of early 2026, 58% of users say it's walkable to restaurants

Do kids play outside in Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL?

As of early 2026, 53% of users say kids play outside

Are there community events in Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL?

As of early 2026, 53% of users say there are community events

Do residents of Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL plan to stay at least 5 years?

As of early 2026, 46% of users say they plan to stay for at least 5 years

Does Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL have sidewalks?

As of early 2026, 42% of users say there are sidewalks

Are the streets well-lit in Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL?

As of early 2026, 40% of users say streets are well-lit

Is Butler Beach, Saint Augustine, FL walkable to grocery stores?

As of early 2026, 37% of users say it's walkable to grocery stores

What is 5143 Holly Rd estimated to be worth?

Trulia's estimated value for 5143 Holly Rd in Saint Augustine, FL is $1,504,500 .

What is the price history for 5143 Holly Rd?

5143 Holly Rd in Saint Augustine, FL last sold for $400,000 in February 1997.

Is Saint Augustine a buyer's or seller's market?

Saint Augustine is currently a buyer's market, based on recent for-sale activity.

What's the median sale price in Saint Augustine?

The median sale price in Saint Augustine is $432K. That is up $13.33K from the prior month.

Does 5143 Holly Rd have air conditioning?

Yes, 5143 Holly Rd in Saint Augustine, FL has air conditioning.

Does 5143 Holly Rd have a pool?

Yes, 5143 Holly Rd in Saint Augustine, FL has a pool.

OFF MARKET

$1,504,500

Trulia Estimate

5 Beds
5 Baths
3,634 sqft (on 1.30 acres)

5143 Holly Rd, Saint Augustine, FL 32080

Butler Beach

Est. Refi. Payment $9,325/mo*

Refinance Your Home

Currently Off Market - Sold Feb 4, 1997 for $400,000

Home Value

Trulia Estimate

$1.5M

Since last month

$1K (+0.1%)

Since last year

$53K (+3.7%)

Since last sale

$1M (+274.5%)

Learn more about this home's value by checking out its Trulia Estimate, the value of nearby homes, and how much similar homes have sold for.

Trulia Estimate

The of this home's value increased by +21% in the last 10 years

Month	Estimated value
2026
August 2026	$1.5M
July 2026	$1.5M
June 2026	$1.52M
May 2026	$1.47M
April 2026	$1.48M
March 2026	$1.44M
February 2026	$1.44M
January 2026	$1.42M
2025
December 2025	$1.43M
November 2025	$1.44M
October 2025	$1.44M
September 2025	$1.4M
August 2025	$1.45M
July 2025	$1.45M
June 2025	$1.45M
May 2025	$1.45M
April 2025	$1.44M
March 2025	$1.41M
February 2025	$1.4M
January 2025	$1.37M
2024
December 2024	$1.38M
November 2024	$1.42M
October 2024	$1.43M
September 2024	$1.42M
August 2024	$1.45M
July 2024	$1.45M
June 2024	$1.46M
May 2024	$1.47M
April 2024	$1.47M
March 2024	$1.47M
February 2024	$1.41M
January 2024	$1.4M
2023
December 2023	$1.4M
November 2023	$1.42M
October 2023	$1.43M
September 2023	$1.45M
August 2023	$1.44M
July 2023	$1.5M
June 2023	$1.51M
March 2023	$1.41M
February 2023	$1.41M
January 2023	$1.41M
2022
December 2022	$1.44M
November 2022	$1.48M
October 2022	$1.52M
September 2022	$1.52M
August 2022	$1.55M
July 2022	$1.58M
June 2022	$1.61M
May 2022	$1.58M
April 2022	$1.55M
March 2022	$1.53M
February 2022	$1.41M
January 2022	$1.36M
2021
December 2021	$1.34M
November 2021	$1.33M
October 2021	$1.32M
September 2021	$1.32M
August 2021	$1.31M
July 2021	$1.31M
June 2021	$1.25M
May 2021	$1.16M
April 2021	$1.17M
March 2021	$1.12M
February 2021	$1.16M
January 2021	$1.12M
2020
December 2020	$1.12M
November 2020	$1.09M
October 2020	$1.02M
September 2020	$1.02M
August 2020	$1.02M
July 2020	$1.03M
June 2020	$1.05M
May 2020	$1.05M
April 2020	$1.05M
March 2020	$1.04M
February 2020	$1.03M
January 2020	$1.01M
2019
December 2019	$1.06M
November 2019	$1.11M
October 2019	$1.14M
September 2019	$1.13M
August 2019	$1.15M
July 2019	$1.15M
June 2019	$1.13M
May 2019	$1.11M
April 2019	$1.04M
March 2019	$1.06M
February 2019	$1.05M
January 2019	$1.03M
2018
December 2018	$1.04M
November 2018	$1.04M
October 2018	$1.07M
September 2018	$1.04M
August 2018	$1.03M
July 2018	$1.05M
June 2018	$1.05M
May 2018	$1.05M
April 2018	$1.01M
March 2018	$988K
February 2018	$973K
January 2018	$965K
2017
December 2017	$1.03M
November 2017	$1.04M
October 2017	$1.05M
September 2017	$1.04M
August 2017	$1.06M
July 2017	$1.08M
June 2017	$1.1M
May 2017	$1.1M
April 2017	$1.08M
March 2017	$1.18M
February 2017	$1.19M
January 2017	$1.22M
2016
December 2016	$1.2M
November 2016	$1.14M
October 2016	$1.21M
September 2016	$1.24M
August 2016	$1.23M

Comparable sales

These are recently sold homes that have a similar location or other similar features to this home, like bedrooms, bathrooms, and square footage. Get a sense of the expected prices in the area by viewing these homes.

Address	Distance	Property Type	Sold Price	Sold Date	Bed	Bath	Sqft
100 GRAND OAKS Drive, Saint Augustine, FL	0.14	Single-Family Home	$610,000	11/25/25	4	3	2,486
345 MICKLERS ROAD, Saint Augustine, FL	0.52	Single-Family Home	$3,450,000	01/08/26	4	4.5	3,660
105 GRAND OAKS Drive, Saint Augustine, FL	0.16	Single-Family Home	$740,000	10/10/25	3	2	2,042
708 EL VERGEL Lane, Saint Augustine, FL	0.19	Single-Family Home	$550,000	08/29/25	3	2	1,775
789 El Vergel Ln, Saint Augustine, FL	0.21	Single-Family Home	$575,000	05/20/26	3	2	1,775
5324 4th St, Saint Augustine, FL	0.44	Single-Family Home	$545,000	09/03/25	3	2.5	1,704
5342 4TH Street, Saint Augustine, FL	0.47	Single-Family Home	$377,400	10/09/25	3	2	2,549
624 Casa Fuerta Ln, Saint Augustine, FL	0.26	Single-Family Home	$530,000	12/23/25	3	2	1,775
757 EL VERGEL Lane, Saint Augustine, FL	0.14	Single-Family Home	$500,000	12/22/25	3	2	1,636
420 Trade Wind Ln, Saint Augustine, FL	0.67	Single-Family Home	$895,000	06/22/26	3	3	1,881

Nearby home prices

Get a sense of expected prices in the area by checking the value of nearby homes.

Address	Distance	Price	Bed	Bath	Sqft	Status
5199 HOLLY Road, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.05	$1,621,300	3	2.5	2,607	Off Market
817 S Griffin Shores Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.10	$1,725,000	-	-	-	For Sale
117 Grand Oaks Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.13	$2,306,400	4	4.5	4,638	Off Market
100 GRAND OAKS Drive, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.14	$610,000	4	3	2,486	Recently Sold
757 EL VERGEL Lane, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.14	$500,000	3	2	1,636	Recently Sold
105 GRAND OAKS Drive, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.16	$745,900	3	2	2,042	Off Market
708 EL VERGEL Lane, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.19	$552,200	3	2	1,775	Off Market
785 El Vergel Ln, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.20	$587,800	2	2	1,775	Off Market
700 EL VERGEL Lane, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.20	$585,000	3	2	1,990	For Sale
789 El Vergel Ln, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.21	$575,000	3	2	1,775	Recently Sold
224 SAN NICOLAS Way, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.22	$591,000	3	2	1,648	Off Market
645 Casa Fuerta Ln, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	0.24	$557,600	3	2	1,810	Off Market

Local Information

Map ViewExplore the area around 5143 Holly Rd.
Schools1 Preschool School1 Elementary School2 Middle Schools1 High School
Shop & Eat

-- mins to

Commute Destination

Home Highlights

Property Type

Single-Family Home

Year Built

1984

Lot Size

1.3 acres

Living Area

3,634 sqft

Price/Sqft

$414

Parking

Garage

About this House

A rare waterfront home on a lush tropical and oak canopy one acre lot, 3634 sq. ft. directly on the Intra-coastal with pool and small boat/jet ski lift dock, circular drive. 1st Floor features: spacious open living area with glass sliders across back for maximum yard, river, pool views, LR with brick fireplace, Brazilian hardwood floor and built-ins, huge family/game room with built-is, 2 wine coolers and bar frig, also 1st floor In-Law or guest suite, 2nd floor features large den/desk alcove, over-sized MBR suite, soaking tub and walk-in shower and dual walk-in closets, 3 additional bedrooms with 2 baths, spiral stairs lead to 3rd floor cupola with wonderful sunset river views. Pool /hot tub, outside kitchen enclosed in 2-story screened lanai, beautifully large treed yard leading to new walkway/dock with 2-jet ski lift and fish cleaning station. 2-car garage and additional carport. Beach nearby along with dining/shopping areas. www.rentstaugustine.com

5143 Holly Rd, Saint Augustine, FL 32080 is a 5 bedroom, 5 bathroom, 3,634 sqft single-family home in Butler Beach, built in 1984. It last sold for $400,000 on Feb 4, 1997. More recently, it was listed as a rental in June 2017 with an asking price of $3,995 per month. That rental listing was removed on September 19, 2017. This property is not currently displayed as for sale or rent on Trulia. The Trulia Estimate is $1,504,500, with a rent estimate of $5,552/month.

Home Details for 5143 Holly Rd

Interior Features
Heating & Cooling Heating: Heat PumpAir ConditioningCooling System: CentralHeating Fuel: Heat Pump
Interior Details Additional StorageTypes of Rooms: Walk In Closet, LibraryStorage
Appliances & Utilities DryerWasher
Fireplace & Spa FireplaceHot Tub or Spa
Levels, Entrance, & Accessibility Floors: Tile, Carpet, Hardwood

Exterior Features
Exterior Home Features Roof: AsphaltDeckExterior: Stucco, WoodFoundation Type: Concrete
Pool Pool
Parking & Garage GarageParking Spaces: 2Parking: Garage Attached

Property Information
Year Built Year Built: 1984Year Updated: 1994
Property Type / Style Property Type: Single Family Home

Community
Units in Building: 1

Lot Information
Lot Area: 1.30 acres

Price and Tax history

Date	Event	Price
Sep 19, 2017 Source: Agent Provided	ListingRemoved	$3,550
Sep 1, 2017 Source: Agent Provided	PriceChange	$3,550 Price decreased by 1%
Aug 16, 2017 Source: Agent Provided	PriceChange	$3,595 Price decreased by 3%
Aug 1, 2017 Source: Agent Provided	PriceChange	$3,695 Price decreased by 3%
Jul 10, 2017 Source: Agent Provided	PriceChange	$3,795 Price decreased by 3%
Jun 27, 2017 Source: Agent Provided	PriceChange	$3,895 Price decreased by 3%
Jun 16, 2017 Source: Agent Provided	Listed For Rent	$3,995
May 30, 2017 Source: Agent Provided	ListingRemoved	$1,195,000
Apr 7, 2017 Source: Agent Provided	PriceChange	$1,195,000 Price decreased by 8%
Nov 14, 2016 Source: Agent Provided	PriceChange	$1,295,000 Price decreased by 1%
May 23, 2016 Source: Agent Provided	Listed For Sale	$1,312,500
Feb 4, 1997 Source: N/A	Sold	$400,000

Year	Property tax	Tax assessment
2025	$10,808	$1,230,997

Additional Cost

Market trends in Saint Augustine

Last updated July 2026

Avg. sale price

$432K

$13.33KMoM

Sale-to-List Price

97.5%

0.3%MoM

Price per sq ft

$227

$1MoM

Available listings

1789

109MoM

Around this home

W. Douglas Hartley Elementary School
PK-5
Public
531 Students
St. Johns
7/10
GreatSchools Rating
Parent Rating Average
For the most part this school does what it can to make life easier for its students but occasionally some of the teachers are more interested in making smart comments then teaching kids to actually be smarter.
Parent Review
4mo ago
7 Reviews

View nearby schools on GreatSchools

The GreatSchools Rating compares schools on a variety of school quality indicators including test scores, college readiness, equity and more. Learn more.

Neighborhood Overview

Butler Beach

168 Homes For You
Buy: $75k - $3.79m

See Local Highlights

Neighborhood stats provided by third party data sources.

What Locals Say about Butler Beach

At least 24 Trulia users voted on each feature.

100 % Say it's dog friendly
92 % Say car is needed
85 % Say it's quiet
78 % Say people would walk alone at night
77 % Say parking is easy
77 % Say there's holiday spirit
71 % Say yards are well-kept
65 % Say there's wildlife
60 % Say neighbors are friendly
58 % Say it's walkable to restaurants
53 % Say kids play outside
53 % Say there are community events
46 % Say they plan to stay for at least 5 years
42 % Say there are sidewalks
40 % Say streets are well-lit
37 % Say it's walkable to grocery stores

Sourced by Trulia users. Learn more about our methodology.

Trulia User
Resident
6y ago
"I drive myself. My commute is about 20 minutes. No public transportation is available except Lyft/Uber. "
0
Flag
Adela
Resident
6y ago
"Too soon to say. We haven’t lived here long enough. Our area where our home is located does have many neighborhood events "
0
Flag
Skyates
Visitor
6y ago
"I drive. It’s about 20-25 mins to downtown. Can feel hard to get around, but that’s Florida I guess. You have to have a car unfortunately."
0
Flag
Joseph S.
Resident
6y ago
"Beautiful place, safe and clean. Friendly neighbors and beautiful beaches. What more can you ask for?"
0
Flag
Annetteabraun
Visitor
7y ago
"beautiful spot for a vacation, year after year. white sand beaches and great places to eat. i reccomend this neighborhood for anyone wanting to have a nice beach vacation. "
0
Flag
Carolina M.
Resident
7y ago
"The beach, close to stores and restaurants and also the neighbors are really nice. Is a farmers market 10 min away on Wednesday, Saturday’s and Sundays. "
1
Flag
Mbaccord01
Resident
7y ago
"Great area. Quiet. Would recommend. Close to beach. Great neighborhood. Salt air is nice. "
0
Flag
Mbaccord01
Resident
7y ago
"Weekly meeting with friends. Great community watch. Everyone walks and speaks to others. Fresh clean. "
0
Flag
Rachkorey
Resident
7y ago
"My neighborhood is a friendly beach community. Most people are retired, yet not everyone is. I would guess around 75% are, plus there are many who rent, mainly in the winter months"
0
Flag
Rhonda M. H.
Visitor
7y ago
"We have visited here for months at a time. The neighbors are terrific and the neighborhood is quiet. No travel-thru traffic, just a quiet little beach paradise that we love."
2
Flag
Danielle D.
Resident
8y ago
"good neighborhood not many kids on our street quiet clean close to beach close to shopping close to intercoastal "
0
Flag
Nikki M.
Resident
8y ago
"My neighborhood has great neighbors and provides a sense of community that many neighborhoods are lacking these days. "
3
Flag
Dotsonkirn
Resident
8y ago
"The oldest city needs no Explanation. But at the beach, I have the benefit of the old city and the ocean and the intercoastal waterway. That is very unique."
2
Flag
Charlie
12y ago
"Love the atmosphere at Ocean Village Club. Plenty to do. Either visiting the old historical areas of St. Augustine or just lolling on the beach. What a terrific place to live and work."
0
Flag
Don D.
14y ago
"We live here for part of the year and will be moving here full time in the next 2 years. The area is well maintained by property owners. Walkability to restaurants, shopping and entertainment is the best we have found. We seldom need to leave the island for anything and when we do, we seldom have to drive more than 5-6 miles."
0
Flag

LGBTQ Local Legal Protections

Frequently asked questions about 5143 Holly Rd

What is 5143 Holly Rd estimated to be worth?
Trulia's estimated value for 5143 Holly Rd in Saint Augustine, FL is $1,504,500.
What is the price history for 5143 Holly Rd?
5143 Holly Rd in Saint Augustine, FL last sold for $400,000 in February 1997.
Is Saint Augustine a buyer's or seller's market?
Saint Augustine is currently a buyer's market, based on recent for-sale activity.
What's the median sale price in Saint Augustine?
The median sale price in Saint Augustine is $432K. That is up $13.33K from the prior month.
Does 5143 Holly Rd have air conditioning?
Yes, 5143 Holly Rd in Saint Augustine, FL has air conditioning.
Does 5143 Holly Rd have a pool?
Yes, 5143 Holly Rd in Saint Augustine, FL has a pool.