Communities south of Staten Island within that distance include Matawan, Old Bridge, Aberdeen, Freehold, Manalapan, and Middletown, to name a few.
You didn't mention price point. The link will take you to 4 bedroom/2-3bath properties in the above listed towns as well as other towns in the same area. Many of our property data sheets do not include square footage. If I were to search based upon a minimum of 2700 sq feet, I would get inaccurate results since the data is omitted in many listings. Too many lawsuits over 50 square feet +/- depending upon which 'expert' measured resulted in this field being largely omitted by agents. when you see the footage included, it is often because the footage existed in the town tax records and a disclaimer by the agent ins often cited that the figure comes from a 3rd party source.
If there are any specific properties that catch your attention, I can research those individually to find out if any square footage data is available.
The list in the link shows properties beginning at a price point of 375K. If you would like the sales price or other criteria adjusted, please email me and I will send you a refined list.
Deborah Madey - Broker
Peninsula Realty Group
732 530 6350 Direct