We are Realtor, we are not Insurance salesmen;
conversely, we do not get a kick-back for referring an Insurance Company.
We have all, including as Realtors, had good experiences and bad experiences with Insurance Companies.
I doubt they we are better qualified to judge them any better than you are.
When someone asks us, the most common answer is to talk to your Automobile Insurance company; most of them have discounts for bundling the coverage. This saves you money.
If you are looking for recommendations based on how they pay out CLAIMS, I would suggest you look at Consumer Reports, or some such publication.