Whole Foods Market...one of the life savers of New York city. Good quality products, large choice of organic products. Great selection of cheese, coffee, daires etc. Avoid rush hour times, it gets crazy, although the cashier system is smartly done and most efficient. A bit pricey but this is New York...You can get it delivered as well.
Or you can simply go online to fresh direct and avoid the madness for similar quality products.
Hope this helps.
More questions about local stores? I am here to help! Get to know your neighborhood!