I'm not in the area but often have similar questions about local private schools... which one is better, A or B?
In many of these cases it can be amatter of opinion, or even just subjective. Does your child have a dominate temperment that might be better suited by a certain philosophy? Does he/she have a special educational need, art, language, music-- speech, gifted classes, or the like?
Make a list and ask around. Ask specialty teachers, ask parents, ask administration. Gather as much information as you can... then decided for yourself.
Sorry, I know this wasn't a definitive answer, but as a mother of three myself, the above has been my approach.
Best of luck, Carmen in Davis,CA