I agree with Chris, and would say that the Rosewood and CBA schools seem to be the most sought after. In 2008 we moved here, and we chose our home in the Rosewood area based on many factors; proximity to I70 and a shorter drive to Raleigh, a beautiful country setting, quiet neighborhood, AND excellent Rosewood schools. We have been here for 4 years, and are only moving because my husband just retired from the Air Force, and we are going home to Maryland to settle permanently. (We have a home to sell in the area, if you are still looking...! 102 Stonewood Drive, Goldsboro!) :)
*Scott, I see you are from DuBois. My grandfather, George Harvey (of Penn State flyfishing fame) was from DuBois, but lived in State College most of his life. I have been to DuBois a number of times, since I grew up in PA and MD, but it's not the type of town I hear about much. I was pleasantly surprised to see it on your post! Good luck with your move!