Well, without knowing your location requirements (do you need to be within a certain commute of your job or certain area amenities?) or what you are looking for in a home I would just be taking a shot in the dark as to what area's I'd recommend for you specifically.
I hate to assume, but based on Rio Pinar, I"m guessing you'd like to be on or near a golf course at least? Price range between 200-400ish?? Prefer a larger lot home? Obviously a safe area.
In that case, I'm thinking Tuskawilla Country Club in Winter Springs, perhaps Timicuan in Lake Mary, Several area's around Winter Park, check out Eastwood and Stoneybrook East. I'm guessing if you didn't like Celebration you would not like Baldwin Park at all either.
If considering the West side of town, Bay Hill, Summerport, StoneyBrook west, or even Orange Tree may fit.
However each of these neighbohoods will have major differences and could easily be narrowed down knowing your preferences in a home. But I would need to conduct a quick interview to give you any specific recommendations as to what might fit your needs.