I found a nice home selling for 225k, but when I look at the county assessor records it shows the 2009

Asked by Brian Ray, 68059 Sun May 10, 2009

assessed value to be 200k. Is this just the house value without consideration to the upgrades inside? should I talk them down to 200k?

Help the community by answering this question:

+ web reference
Web reference:


Bill Fung, Agent, Centennial, CO
Sun May 10, 2009

Typically, Tax assessment value, does not necessarily equate to Market Value. Best thing to do is check to see what properties similar to the one you are interested in, has sold for in the last 3 to 6 months. Best strategy is use a Realtor's help if you don't have the time to do the research.
Web Reference:  http://www.homesellteam.com
0 votes
Brian L. A.…, Agent, Colorado Springs, CO
Mon May 11, 2009
Hi Brian :o)

The assessor's valuation is to determine the taxable value and is not a good determiner of current market value because it is generally older information from a much broader period of time.

The best determiner of current market value is going to be what a willing seller will sell for and a willing buyer will pay. The best ways to discover that approximate value is to have either an appraisal done by an licensed professional appraiser or a Comparitive Market Analysis (CMA) from a Realtor professional.

While I am a Realtor and not an appraiser, I am known for my fairly accurate CMA's and the farthest I have been off from an appraisal on properties I have worked on, even in the recent market, is only a few thousand dollars. While appraisals and CMA's are in reality educated guesses supported by evidence, they are going to be your best tools to help you determine approximate current market values. Of course appraisals are more in depth and cost money, CMA's are a usually a market snapshot, usually free and can sometimes vary widely depending on the expertiese of the Realtor you are using.

If you are not already working with an agent, because it would be unethical otherwise, I would be happy to assist and advise you in your home purchase. You may feel free to contact me.

Best Regards
Brian L. A. Wess
Realtor®, Broker Associate
Residential & Investment Specialist
Pat Newell & Associates, Inc - Metro Brokers
Colorado Springs, CO
Direct: 719-528-6672
Web: BrianWess.com

Voted "Best Realtor in Colorado Springs 2006 & 2008"
The Independent News Readers Poll: Gold 2006, Silver 2008
1 vote
Darrell Wass, Agent, Colorado Springs, CO
Sun May 10, 2009
Hi Brian,
Right now in El Paso county, the tax value to actual value is all over the board. When the market was booming, most homes had a tax value 10-20% below actual value. Now it can be high or low. An appraiser will take the past 6 months of sales of similar homes, in the same neighborhood to establish a value. If you want to provide me with the property address, I would be happy to run a CMA and email it to you.
1 vote
Stuart Dobson, , Broomfield, CO
Sun May 10, 2009
Hi Brian,

I agree with Bill on this. The $200k assessed valuation is not necessarily market value. Where this really may come into being a factor soon though is with an appraisal if you were to try to purchase the property.

Also, as of May 1, 2009, there has been a change in the way FHA appraisers are selected. The mortgage broker no longer is calling in their own appraisals.

thank you,
1 vote
Kathleen Lor…, Agent, Baxter, MN
Wed May 20, 2009
The best determiner of current market value is going to be what other similar homes in that area have recently sold for. Then you know what buyers other than yourself are willing to pay. The homes that are the most move in ready, with the best amenities and show well will sell for higher prices that similar properties which are lacking in those items.
Web Reference:  http://topbrainerdagent.com
0 votes
Dodi Bateman, Agent, Colorado Springs, CO
Tue May 12, 2009
Hi Brian,
Brian is absolutely correct, most of the time it is older information.
A CMA is a very good tool that we Realtors use to determine the best value of the property.
We are not appraisers, but my CMA's are always only a couple thousand dollars off of the appraisal value.
You can save a lot of money on an appraisal when you find a great Realtor that really knows how to do a good CMA.
I know you are trying to find the best deal for you.
Let me know if you need anything
0 votes
J R, , New York, NY
Sun May 10, 2009
Where I live we have the flip side: tax records show value at 200,000 more than we can sell a house for in some cases. Makes for very unrealistic sellers.
0 votes
Search Advice
Ask our community a question

Email me when…

Learn more