I am wondering if I should rent my current home in order to purchase a new bigger one.

Asked by Diane Viggiano, Richmond, MA Wed Aug 22, 2012

I'm moving out of a rural area into a small city and wondering which would see home values rise quicker.

Help the community by answering this question:

+ web reference
Web reference:


Anne Meczywor, Agent, Lenox, MA
Thu Aug 23, 2012
First of all, Richmond, MA is a rural area that is part of The Berkshires. What applies in "the Citiies" has little bearing hear. Remember that renting here is a bit more complicated. We have no MLS for rentals, so a great deal of the work will fall squarely on your shoulders.

Right now (August of 2012), we are experiencing a rapidly declining inventory of properties on the market, along with double digit percentage increases in the number of properties going under contract and closing over the same period last year. There are more multiple offer situations, but only careful negotiation bring them to fruition. Listings of well-priced homes are selling in 45-60 days, at an average of 92-94% of listing price. We are also in our summer buying season for second homes, so it might be worth considering taking advantage of the uptick in demand to price your property correctly and sell it rather than rent it.

When you rent a property out, there are many things of which you need to be aware. If your home was built prior to 1978, you are subject to MA Lead Paint laws. If a child under 6 moves into the property for a period longer than 30 days, and lead was used in any stains or paints on the property, you are obligated by law to remediate at your expense. YOU MAY NOT REFUSE TO RENT TO SOMEONE WHO HAS A CHILD, unless your property has only one bedroom and the child is over 6 months old. If a child under 6 years old moves in, you are required to test for the presence of lead, and once the results of that testing is known you will be obligated to disclose that information from that point on.

You will need to be acutely aware of Fair Housing laws. Know the requirements and follow them to the letter...there are testers out there and the penalties are steep. For instance, can you advertise that you will not take on smokers or pet owners? Can you describe your property as great for a family or a singe person? Can you describe the location as near a church or synagogue?

How comfortable are you collecting rents if things get contentious? How will you handle being called in the middle of the night for a clogged toilet? Will you be able to take care of emergencies from afar? Do you know how to legally handle deposit/escrow checks? Will you still be able to afford a larger home if the rent doesn't come in or if the property is vacant, still costing you for heat, taxes, repairs, utilities, insurance?

House prices are beginning to rise, and interest rates may follow suit. Selling now will allow you to purchase your larger home elsewhere at it's most affordable. If you delay, prices rise and interest rates go up, you may not be able to afford as much house later. The financing question also comes into play. Will a lender give you a loan for a new primary residence while you use the former property as a rental?

Talk with a local lender. They will be happy to give you sound advice. Have a local Berkshire Realtor do a market analysis for you so you know what you are likely to get for your property. Have that agent refer you to a Realtor in your new community and have them show you SOLD property information so that you can see what your budget is likely to afford there.

Then, be really, really honest with yourself. Knowing what you can reasonably afford, what you can reasonably expect to get for your present property, and how well you can deal with legalities and inconvenience, decide whether renting or selling is a better option for you.
0 votes
Ruth and Per…, Agent, Los Gatos, CA
Wed Aug 22, 2012
Hi Dianne

Longer term you will do better in the Cities with regards to appreciation than other.

You should rent, provided you are comfortable with being a landlord or hire a Property Management
company to rent ti for you, as there are always issues to cover and go over.

Good luck.

0 votes
All real estate is local, The rate of appreciation in the Berkshires is higher than many metropolitan areas. We aren't talking about the back woods of a sparsely populated state, but a home in a highly sought after center for cultural and outdoor activities.
Flag Thu Aug 23, 2012
Tom Lynch, Agent, Great Barrington, MA
Wed Aug 22, 2012

First question is, how comfortable will you be renting out your home? Ask any realtor for nightmare rental stories... and you will get plenty. I always advise my clients to rent out their home only as a last resort.

In terms of home values, it depends on the location, condition, and curb-appeal of your home... but as you know, the Berkshires is very desirable. The market is VERY busy right now, and sales are strong. If we have truly hit "bottom," then I expect prices will begin to rise... albeit slowly.

Please call me if you would like to discuss your options further.


Tom Lynch
Associate Broker, Massachusetts, New York, and Connecticut
Berkshire Property Agents
12 Railroad Street
Great Barrington, Massachusetts 01230
0 votes
George "Loca…, , Houston, TX
Wed Aug 22, 2012
yes renting your home can be a path to buying a larger one. currently the rental market is very strong so you can probably get a premium rent for your home.
0 votes
Tucker Welch…, Agent, Richmond, MA
Wed Aug 22, 2012
Rentals can be tough to get in the off season months and there is always the possibility of damage to the house that will decrease its value. You should evaluate how much you need to get out of the house and price it as competively as possible for a quick sale. Tucker Welch Properties Richmond MA
0 votes
this agent sounds like a used car salesperson. What a seller "needs to get out of a house" has NOTHING to do with what its worth- I'll never call this company-
Flag Sat Mar 9, 2013
Sarah Goulart…, Agent, Plymouth, MA
Wed Aug 22, 2012
One of the first things you need to ascertain to even consider this as an option (assuming you need a mortgage) is whether you would qualify for a second mortgage in that situation. For most loans, rental income has to be proven over a long period of time, otherwise you have to qualify for both your current mortgage and the additional mortgage amount you would take on the new home.
0 votes
Dagmar Kubes, Agent, Great Barrington, MA
Wed Aug 22, 2012
Hi Diane,
wherever you live, the value derives from the demand and if the location is desirable and the property has a potential, than you are OK.
Let me know if I can be of any other assistance to you.
Call me.
Dagmar Kubes, Barnbrook Realty, 413 528-6485 or e-mail: dagmarrealty@verizon.net.
Serving the Sellers as well as the Buyers trough-out the entire Berkshire County, MA.
0 votes
Search Advice
Ask our community a question

Email me when…

Learn more