I am not using a realtor

Asked by Ahmed Rashed, Brooklyn, NY Mon Jul 14, 2014

I am searching for a house in brooklyn, NY. I am not using a realtor for my search but instead searching on trulia and other similar sites and dealing with the sellers' realtors independently. Am I placing myself at a large disadvantage if and when I find the house I want? Especially considering that in this very tight NYC market houses frequently sell for above asking.

Help the community by answering this question:

+ web reference
Web reference:


Anna M Brocco, Agent, Williston Park, NY
Wed Jul 16, 2014
Be mindful that not all listings may appear on such sites, therefore it's in your better interest to consider working with an agent of your own; he/she can also provide comps, recently sold similar properties in the immediate area and other necessary information so that when the time comes, an informed decision can be made....
0 votes
Annette Law…, Agent, Palm Harbor, FL
Wed Jul 16, 2014
People rarely ask a question they do not already know the answer.
Of course you are at a disadvantage.

I am confident you are aware of the three SIGNIFICANT disadvantages and how they work against you.

It must be recognized that some folk find lasting and enduring pleasure in being able to say, "I did it my way!"

Your choice is, "Use the tested and proven method of buying real estate," or "Do it your way."
0 votes
Steve Quinta…, Agent, Albuquerque, NM
Wed Jul 16, 2014
Maybe...a broker has better market information; you are currently working with Trulia info that is stale and/or incomplete. You are also not getting accurate comparable numbers for properties similar to the one you might buy.

A broker might be able to alert you to properties fresh on the market, whereas Trulia gets their info on a delay feed.
0 votes
Kathryn Lilly, Agent, New York, NY
Wed Jul 16, 2014
The General answer would be yes, you are at a disadvantage.
But depending on what area of Brooklyn, you may not be because there are still too many listing agents that just will not co-broke. They would rather keep the whole commission to themselves, even at the expense of their seller not getting the best price.
But also, unfortunately there are too many buyers agents that are just riding along on the coat tails of a buyer and have no idea what they are doing. They are not helping you the buyer to formulate your qualified best offer, they are not helping you even find the right properties that you are qualified to submit offers on. And remember it is not just people that have to qualify for a mortgage, houses do as well, some properties may not qualify for what you are working with and the sellers broker should know that, so cannot accept your offer.
Also if you are working full time, you will not have time to watch for the new listings and also keep up with the real market. Your buyers agent should be a full time agent that specializes in the area that you want to buy in, that knows every house in the neighborhood, knows all the agents in the neighborhood and that can do a complete records search for you as well as an "inspection" of the condition etc. as you are going through the property, so that you can make a solid offer quickly. Then they can help you structure and present your best offer and hopefully get it to a closing.
I have represented many buyers recently that have been looking on their own for, in some cases many years and the market just kept running ahead of them and they spent 1,000's on home inspectors just to have to withdraw their offer because the property needed too much work etc. they did not know which Bank or what financing was available for what they were trying to buy, or their offers were not presented in a fashion that a sellers Broker could accept, but the sellers agent did not have the time with all the other offers they were getting to get the offer where it could have been accepted.
Working with a good buyers agent is like having your own personal Coach, working with a bad one is like pulling a huge weight along with you.
A good buyers agent will not always tell you what you want to hear, they should give you options of what is possible to get to your end goal.
0 votes
Jonah Landman of http://www.bktothefullest.com is an independent consultant. You pay him a fee, he helps you find the house. He is in Brooklyn and know the market. He helps you put the deal together, the listing agent keeps the full commission.

Vanessa Thatcher
Senior Loan Officer NMLS# 41404

Atlantic Home Capital
4175 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Ste 310
Ronkonkoma, NY 11779

Office: 631-687-3510 x106
Direct Dial: 631-468-8809
Direct Fax: 631-918-5222
Cell: 631-672-4113

“Pennies don’t fall from heaven; they have to be earned here on earth” ~Margaret Thatcher~

Website: http://www.atlantichomecapital.com
You can catch me in the directory at

NEW SITE http://www.bktothefullest.com
Flag Wed Jul 16, 2014
Search Advice
Ask our community a question

Email me when…

Learn more