Not sure how familiar you are with Fishers, but it routinely receives accolades in national publications, such as Forbes, as one of the best communities in the US to raise a family, best small city, great schools, and the list goes on. It's hard to go wrong in Fishers. There are several neighborhoods throughout the area that offer a variety of amenities. It really depends on your definition of "great," as to which ones may be the best fit for you and your family.
For some, great community means it's within walking distance to parks and amenities. Others consider a "great" place a home with a big yard. Others like neighborhoods that are really active with lots of organized events, and other tell me their idea of a great neighborhood is being on the golf course with a community pool, or living on the water with a private dock.
As someone who's lived in Fishers almost 20 years, I'd be happy to help you sort out which neighborhoods and houses will be the best fit for you and your family, just shoot me an email or give me a call. If you want to scope out some areas on your own, you'll find a great list of community events at www.eightgreattowns.com and www.Fishers.in.us.
Best of luck,