The best source for comparable school data can be found at neighborhoodscout.com. They actually have a colorcoded map for quick comparisons. Another source is schooldigger.com. I live in Branford and have a couple of cousins who just have, or are still attending BHS. They all really loved it and they all had very different interests.
You can contact me at email@example.com if you have any further questions.
Weichert Suburban Properties