For Rent

11 Locust Ave

Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 See your commute times

  • 4 Bedrooms
  • 3 full, 1 partial Bathrooms
  • 175 days on Trulia
  • Single-Family Home
  • 2,500 sqft
  • Built in 1880

Home Details for 11 Locust Ave

Report this Listing Listing Reported

For Rent > NY > Shelter Island Heights > 11965 > 11 Locust Ave
The Captains House
Also Available - Short-Term starting May 1, 2018 - $5,500 per week, June/July - $25,000This idyllic home, perched atop Chase's creek with both water and village views, in the middle of exclusive Shelter Island Heights, is the perfect vacation destination. The newly re-decorated 1880 Victorian offers 4 bedrooms, 3 baths, a front parlor and games room as well as an open plan, large family living space toward the rear. There is both a large, wrap-around porch as well as a full back yard for outdoor dining and enjoyment. Staying in the Heights gives you access to the tennis courts, golf cou...rse and private beach club offered by the community. Sailing, boating and all water sports are also available. Accessible by Jitney or train to ferry no car necessary. Walking distance from ferry, and into town, where you can find a Hotel, restaurants, gourmet grocery and of course the local bar! Don't miss this chance to throw down a blanket in one of our 6 parks and just watch the boats go by. This Summer...make it Shelter! Memorial Day - Labor Day - $42,000; July - Labor Day - $34,000; July Only - $16,000; August - Labor Day - $19,000; Year-Round - $4,041 Per Month; Other / Short Term - June - $12,000
Show more


Listing Info for 11 Locust Ave

Information last updated on 10/19/2017 02:04 PM
    • Price: $4,041
    • 4 Bedrooms
    • 3 full, 1 partial Bathrooms
    • Single-Family Home
    • Fireplace
    • Status: For Rent
    • Built in 1880
    • MLS/Source ID: 0057297
    • Zip: 11965
    • Provided By: Sotheby's International Realty - Southampton Brokerage
    • 2,500 sqft
Interested in Posting a Listing? Visit Trulia's Post a Rental to learn more.

Additional Costs

See businesses, schools, and crimes near this home

Maps and information about what's nearby. Show more

Affordability Tips

See average rent and utilities to determine what you can afford. Show more




Compared to other listings, the utility score for this listing is


Tip: Keep your rent within a third of your gross household income. The ideal income for this property is at least $155,268 annually.

Utility Score

Create a Rental Listing

Have a property like this one to rent out? Show more
Have a property like this one to rent out?
Find the right tenant by listing it on Trulia. It's free!

Contact Info

Edward Mulderrig
(631) 283-0600
Inquire about this property

We value your privacy! Trulia's Terms of Use & Privacy Policy.

Discover more homes

Discover more homes like this one. Show more