Find out what your home is worth.


40 New York Ave Shelter Island, NY 11964

See your commute times

Property Details for 40 New York Ave

Description provided by Trulia
This Single-Family Home is located at 40 New York Avenue, Shelter Island, NY. 40 New York Ave is in the 11964 ZIP code in Shelter Island, NY. The average listing price for ZIP code 11964 is $1,696,189. 40 New York Ave has 3 beds, 1 bath, and approximately 1,270 square feet


Price History & Trends

Real Estate Trends in 11964

Listing price for 40 New York Ave  
Average listing price for all homes in 11964 $1,696,189 77% above listing price
Median sale price for all homes in 11964 $852,500 116% above listing price

Contact Info