Contact For Estimate
60 Gardiners Bay Dr
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Off Market · Public Record
Contact For Estimate

60 Gardiners Bay Dr Shelter Island, NY 11964

  • 4 beds
  • 3.5 baths
  • 2,579 sqft
  • 0.9 acres lot size
  • Single-Family Home
See 8 photos
  • See the local terrain and how close this home is to parks and main streets.

    View More

  • Take a virtual walk around the neighborhood.

    View More

  • Lowest crime relative to the rest of Suffolk county.

    View More

  • 3 Elementary Schools

    1 Middle School

    2 High Schools

    View More

Property Details for 60 Gardiners Bay Dr


This property is no longer available to rent or buy. This description is from March 17, 2015
Designed in 1970 by acclaimed architect Norman Jaffe for Bernard Jacobs, President of the Shubert Organization for 24 years and considered one of the most powerful men in the American Theater, and his family who still own the property. This water front modernist home offers a simplicity and elegance that highlights, space, light, and natural scenery. Sited on a shy acre with a gradual slope down to 104' of bulk headed beachfront and private dock on Gardiners Bay. The heated Gunite pool is beautifully ensconced in the garden with views of the water in the distance. Decks, sandy beach and... outdoor space for relaxing and entertaining is plentiful. The open floor plan design on the main floor features a bedroom wing separated by a glass breezeway opening up into the living room, dining and kitchen. Soaring ceilings, natural redwood, a double height stone two-sided fire place and panels of glass are oriented for continual expansive water views of Gardiners Island, Long Beach Point & Bug lighthouse. Upstairs is a second en-suite water view master with fireplace and sitting room. An office/den across the landing provides additional space. This property surrounded by water and specimen trees is a hidden gem and a work of modernist art that functions as a wonderfully warm, and welcoming home. Exclusive: $3,650,000
Show more

60 Gardiners Bay Dr Public Records


Official property, sales, and tax information from county (public) records as of 01/2017:
    • Single Family Residential
    • 1 Partial Bathroom
    • Built In 1970
    • Heating: Central
    • Exterior Walls: Wood
    • Fireplace
    • Tax Rate Code Area: 473201
    • 4 Bedrooms
    • 2,579 sqft
    • Stories: 2 story with basement
    • Parking: Garage
    • Basement: Partial Basement
    • Pool: Pool (yes)
    • 3 Bathrooms
    • Lot Size: 0.9 acres
    • A/C: Central
    • Parking Spaces: 2
    • Style: Contemporary
    • County: Suffolk
See businesses, schools, and crimes near this home

Additional Costs For 60 Gardiners Bay Dr


Property Taxes and Assessment of 60 Gardiners Bay Dr


Land
Improvement
Total
$1,074,300
+
$2,396,700
=
$3,471,000
Year Tax Assessment Market
2016 N/A $3,471,000  $3,471,000 
Source: Public Records

Price History & Trends


Price History for 60 Gardiners Bay Dr


Date Event Price Source Agents
11/06/2015 Sold view detail $3,050,000 Public records Public records  
  • Recording Date
    11/06/2015
  • Contract Date
    10/24/2015
  • Sale Price
    $3,050,000
  • Price Type
    Full amount stated on Document.
  • City Transfer Tax
    $0
  • County Transfer Tax
    $42,700
  • Total Transfer Tax
    $0
  • Transaction Type
    Insured Non-Residential Grant Deed
  • Document Type
    Bargain and Sale Deed

Real Estate Trends in this area

Median sale price for all homes in this area $930,000 0% below listing price

Sold Homes near 60 Gardiners Bay Dr


Address Distance Property Type Sold price Sold date Bed Bath Sqft
10775 Main Rd, East Marion NY 2.04 Single-Family Home $585,000 12/13/16 - - -
350 Marine Pl, Greenport NY 1.58 Single-Family Home $499,000 11/04/16 - - -
880 Old Orchard Ln, East Marion NY 1.68 Single-Family Home $500,000 11/29/16 - - -
240 Cedar Dr, East Marion NY 2.28 Single-Family Home $540,000 11/22/16 - - -
1825 Calebs Way #B7, Greenport NY 2.58 Single-Family Home $349,000 12/07/16 - - -
152 Central Ave, Greenport NY 1.71 Single-Family Home $759,000 11/30/16 - - -
340 Bennet Rd, Greenport NY 2.56 Single-Family Home $375,000 12/02/16 - - -
439 2nd St, Greenport NY 1.99 Single-Family Home $420,000 11/01/16 - - -
75 The Cross Way, East Marion NY 2.19 Single-Family Home $525,000 12/10/16 - - -
1955 Calebs Way #A3, Greenport NY 2.55 Single-Family Home $345,000 09/02/16 - - -