$2,674,479 Trulia Estimate
7 Montclair Ave
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Off Market · Public Record
$2,674,479 Trulia Estimate

7 Montclair Ave Shelter Island, NY 11964

  • 2 beds
  • 1.5 baths
  • 1,735 sqft
  • 1.19 acres lot size
  • Single-Family Home
See 10 photos
  • See the local terrain and how close this home is to parks and main streets.

    View More

  • Take a virtual walk around the neighborhood.

    View More

  • Lowest crime relative to the rest of Suffolk county.

    View More

  • 4 Elementary Schools

    4 Middle Schools

    4 High Schools

    View More

Property Details for 7 Montclair Ave


This property is no longer available to rent or buy. This description is from November 13, 2012
DESIRABLE MONTCLAIR COLONY COTTAGELocated at the end of the Montclair Peninsula sits this adorable cottage built in 1928 and still retains the original charm, pine paneling and small hidden hideaways that are so hard to find. Featuring a large living room with vaulted ceiling and brick fireplace, eat in kitchen, waterside dining room and sun porch, two bedrooms and a sleeping loft, this house is the quintessential summer cottage. A bonus to this house, is the guest house with living room, kitchen, bedroom and bath and 2 car garage. On over an acre and 200 feet of waterfront on West Neck... Harbor, this house is the perfect location for the boater in you. Only a few minutes to the open water, Sag Harbor, Greenport or Gardiners Bay.
Show more

7 Montclair Ave Public Records


Official property, sales, and tax information from county (public) records as of 01/2017:
    • Single Family Residential
    • 1 Partial Bathroom
    • Built In 1928
    • Parking: Garage
    • Basement: Partial Basement
    • County: Suffolk
    • 2 Bedrooms
    • 1,735 sqft
    • Stories: 1 story with basement
    • Parking Spaces: 2
    • Style: Ranch/Rambler
    • Tax Rate Code Area: 473201
    • 1 Bathroom
    • Lot Size: 1.19 acres
    • Heating: Hot Water
    • Exterior Walls: Siding (Alum/Vinyl)
    • Fireplace
See businesses, amenities, and crimes near this home

Affordability

Additional Costs For 7 Montclair Ave


Property Taxes and Assessment of 7 Montclair Ave


Land
Improvement
Total
$1,498,000
+
$809,000
=
$2,307,000
Year Tax Assessment Market
2016 N/A $2,307,000  $2,307,000 
Source: Public Records

Price History & Trends


Price History for 7 Montclair Ave


Date Event Price Source Agents
07/05/2013 Sold view detail $2,250,000 Public records Public records  
  • Recording Date
    07/05/2013
  • Contract Date
    06/28/2013
  • Sale Price
    $2,250,000
  • Price Type
    Full amount stated on Document.
  • City Transfer Tax
    $0
  • County Transfer Tax
    $315
  • Total Transfer Tax
    $0
  • Transaction Type
    Insured Non-Residential Grant Deed
  • Document Type
    Bargain and Sale Deed
01/09/2013 Sold view detail $1,000,000 Public records Public records  
  • Recording Date
    01/09/2013
  • Contract Date
    12/10/2012
  • Sale Price
    $1,000,000
  • Price Type
    Full amount stated on Document.
  • City Transfer Tax
    $0
  • County Transfer Tax
    $278
  • Total Transfer Tax
    $0
  • Transaction Type
    Purchase/Resale Arm's Length Residential Transaction
  • Document Type
    Bargain and Sale Deed

Real Estate Trends in this area


Sold Homes near 7 Montclair Ave


Address Distance Property Type Sold price Sold date Bed Bath Sqft
1565 Calebs Way #D14, Greenport NY 4.24 Single-Family Home $335,000 03/31/17 - - -
980 Oak Ave, Southold NY 3.88 Single-Family Home $525,000 09/01/17 - - -
600 Cedar Dr, Southold NY 3.88 Single-Family Home $380,000 03/21/17 - - -
49 Rysam St, Sag Harbor NY 4.50 Single-Family Home $1,495,000 01/17/17 - - -
1865 Youngs Ave, Southold NY 4.42 Single-Family Home $325,000 04/12/17 - - -
2030 Bay Shore Rd, Greenport NY 2.96 Single-Family Home $449,000 06/13/17 - - -
80 Crescent St, Sag Harbor NY 4.07 Single-Family Home $1,350,000 01/21/17 3 1 2,029
9 Stock Farm Ln, Sag Harbor NY 2.03 Single-Family Home $1,600,000 05/24/17 4 4.5 3,121
4475 Main Bayview Rd, Southold NY 4.48 Single-Family Home $395,000 06/30/17 - - -
870 Summer Ln, Southold NY 3.79 Single-Family Home $370,000 01/14/17 - - -