5 N Menantic Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
$2,680,168 Trulia Estimate

5 N Menantic Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964

  • 4.5 baths
  • 3,206 sqft
  • 2.94 acres lot size
  • Single-Family Home
Off Market · Public Record
$2,680,168 Trulia Estimate
5 N Menantic Rd
See 3 photos
  • See the local terrain and how close this home is to parks and main streets.

    View More

  • Take a virtual walk around the neighborhood.

    View More

  • 1 Elementary School

    1 Middle School

    1 High School

    View More

  • Lowest crime relative to the rest of Suffolk county.

    View More

  • 76% of residents commute by car.

    View More

  • 13 Restaurants

    1 Grocery store

    4 Nightlife

    View More

  • Get a feel for the community.

    View More

Off Market · Public Record

Home Details

Overview
  • Single-Family Home
  • 4.5 Baths
  • Built in 1860
  • 2.94 acres lot size
  • 3,206 sqft
Description

This property is no longer available to rent or buy. This description is from March 12, 2010
This classic 1860's waterfront home evokes the grand estates reminescent of the South. With 3 acres of beautifully manicured lawn and gardens, the aesthetic beauty runs throughout- from the moment you arrive on this property, across the sprawling lawn and down to the water and dock. A true "gem" on the southern tip of Shelter Island.

Price History
Date
Price
Event

08/03/2013
$3,450,000
Posting removed

07/03/2013
$3,450,000
Listed for sale

06/21/2009
$3,900,000
Posting removed

01/09/2009
$3,900,000
Price change
Price Change
-$99,000 (-2.48%)
Source
Daniel Gale

12/28/2008
$3,999,000
Listed for sale

09/04/2003
$2,000,000
Sold
Recording Date
09/04/2003
Contract Date
08/26/2003
Sale Price
$2,000,000
Price Type
Full amount stated on Document.
County Transfer Tax
N/A
Total Transfer Tax
$8,000
Transaction Type
Purchase/Resale Arm's Length Residential Transaction
Document Type
N/A

Property Taxes and Assessment
Year
2016
Tax
N/A
Assessments
$3,521,000
Land
$1,608,200
Improvements
$1,912,800
Total
$3,521,000
Market Value
N/A

Affordability
Additional Costs

Price Trends
Real Estate Trends
Average Listing Price for 11964
$1,992,323
Similar to sold price
Median Sale Price for 11964
$750,000
63% below sold price
Average Sale price/sqft for 11964
$373/sqft
Comparables and Estimates
Sold Homes
Address Distance Property Type Sold Price Sold Date Bed Bath Sqft
3.08
Single-Family Home
$1,737,500
05/08/17
-
-
-
0.7
Single-Family Home
$1,450,000
10/31/17
4
3.5
1,928
5.82
Single-Family Home
$952,000
10/02/17
-
-
-
8.17
Single-Family Home
$1,950,000
06/15/17
6
5.5
3,944
6.5
Single-Family Home
$1,500,000
08/01/17
3
2
2,562
6.39
Single-Family Home
$1,500,000
03/24/17
3
4
3,981
5.69
Single-Family Home
$1,225,000
05/01/17
2
2
1,514
5.86
Single-Family Home
$1,300,000
04/28/17
3
2
1,841
4.62
Single-Family Home
$1,275,000
05/10/17
-
-
-
2.8
Single-Family Home
$1,600,000
05/24/17
4
4.5
3,121

Contact Info


tracking