23 Smith St
Shelter Island, NY 11964
$727,549 Trulia Estimate

23 Smith St
Shelter Island, NY 11964

  • 2 baths
  • 1,791 sqft
  • 0.62 acres lot size
  • Single-Family Home
Off Market · Public Record
$727,549 Trulia Estimate
23 Smith St
See 10 photos
  • See the local terrain and how close this home is to parks and main streets.

    View More

  • Take a virtual walk around the neighborhood.

    View More

  • 1 Elementary School

    1 Middle School

    1 High School

    View More

  • Lowest crime relative to the rest of Suffolk county.

    View More

  • 76% of residents commute by car.

    View More

  • 11 Restaurants

    1 Grocery store

    3 Nightlife

    View More

  • Get a feel for the community.

    View More

Off Market · Public Record

Home Details

Overview
  • Single-Family Home
  • 2 Baths
  • Built in 1931
  • 0.62 acres lot size
  • 1,791 sqft
Description

This property is no longer available to rent or buy. This description is from November 13, 2012
Open virtual tour for more photos! Step through its gate and experience the enchantment of this charming, turn-key Arts and Crafts bungalow, circa 1931, set on a lovely corner in an old farming area, within close proximity to town, tennis, playground and beaches. With every turn, the lush visuals of flowering perennials, fruit-bearing and specimen trees, cherry blossoms and dedicated garden 'rooms' with organic beds will mesmerize and re-energize your spirit. The cottage, filled with many original details and tastefully restored, features a formal living room with fireplace leading to a breezy screened porch, formal dining room with views to a romantic sequestered garden surrounded by yews, a country kitchen renovated in 2009 with windowed breakfast area, soapstone counters, GE Profile, Bosch and restored vintage O'Keefe & Merritt gas stove, a top floor light-filled master suite with Jacuzzi bath, and two additional guest bedrooms in the main house. A guest house has cathedral ceilings, with summer sleeping area and half bath, an outdoor shower, pantry, and a secluded meditation garden with select plantings is one of the many delights secreted along the grounds, including the focal point, a 60x12 heated lap pool surrounded by yet more enveloping greenery and bluestone coping. Square footage does not include guest cottage. This one-of-a-kind charmer has it all!

Price History
Date
Price
Event

08/15/2013
$850,000
Sold
Recording Date
08/15/2013
Contract Date
08/01/2013
Sale Price
$850,000
Price Type
Full amount stated on Document.
County Transfer Tax
$34
Total Transfer Tax
N/A
Transaction Type
Purchase/Resale Arm's Length Residential Transaction
Document Type
N/A

08/03/2013
$925,000
Posting removed

06/29/2013
$925,000
Pending

04/10/2013
$925,000
Price change
Price Change
-$49,000 (-5.03%)
Source
N/A

11/14/2011
$974,000
Price change
Price Change
-$21,000 (-2.11%)
Source
Penelope Moore, Realtor

10/25/2011
$995,000
Listed for sale

03/30/2005
$850,000
Sold
Recording Date
03/30/2005
Contract Date
03/15/2005
Sale Price
$850,000
Price Type
Full amount stated on Document.
County Transfer Tax
N/A
Total Transfer Tax
N/A
Transaction Type
Purchase/Resale Arm's Length Residential Transaction
Document Type
N/A

03/09/1998
$211,500
Sold
Recording Date
03/09/1998
Contract Date
02/24/1998
Sale Price
$211,500
Price Type
Sales price computed from Transfer Tax. No indication whether tax was paid on full or partial consideration.
County Transfer Tax
N/A
Total Transfer Tax
$846
Transaction Type
Purchase/Resale Arm's Length Residential Transaction
Document Type
N/A

Property Taxes and Assessment
Year
2016
Tax
N/A
Assessments
$850,000
Land
$176,700
Improvements
$673,300
Total
$850,000
Market Value
N/A

Affordability
Additional Costs

Price Trends
Real Estate Trends
Average Listing Price for 11964
$1,992,323
134% above sold price
Median Sale Price for 11964
$750,000
12% below sold price
Average Sale price/sqft for 11964
$373/sqft
Comparables and Estimates
Sold Homes
Address Distance Property Type Sold Price Sold Date Bed Bath Sqft
1.25
Single-Family Home
$900,000
07/31/17
3
2.5
2,610
3.77
Single-Family Home
$470,000
09/22/17
-
-
-
1.05
Single-Family Home
$1,137,500
04/24/17
4
2
2,180
4.33
Single-Family Home
$450,000
05/02/17
-
-
-
2.75
Single-Family Home
$580,000
07/10/17
-
-
-
4.1
Single-Family Home
$425,000
03/09/17
-
-
-
2.34
Single-Family Home
$775,000
09/21/17
2
2
1,888
3.84
Single-Family Home
$540,000
08/09/17
-
-
-
4.28
Single-Family Home
$410,000
04/04/17
-
-
-
0.35
Single-Family Home
$640,000
09/22/17
3
2
2,552

Contact Info


tracking