95 Buttonball Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
3 Beds
2 Baths
1,394 sqft (on 26.28 acres)
$764,000
Last Sold: Dec 10, 2025
23% over list $619K
$548/sqft
Est. Refi. Payment $4,963/mo*
$764,000
Last Sold: Dec 10, 2025
23% over list $619K
$548/sqft
Est. Refi. Payment $4,963/mo*
3 Beds
2 Baths
1,394 sqft
(on 26.28 acres)
Local Information
- Map ViewExplore the area around 95 Buttonball Road.
- Schools1 Elementary School1 Middle School1 High School
- Shop & Eat
-- mins to
Description
This charming and seemingly sturdy antique home needing updating has substantial value in its 26+ acres site. Pretty wide-board floors, 3 fireplaces and a cozy porch contribute to its vintage vibe. A detached garage and additional outbuildings add to the feel of a mini old-timey farm. Subdivision possibilities.
This property is off market, which means it's not currently listed for sale or rent on Trulia. This may be different from what's available on other websites or public sources. This description is from December 10, 2025
Home Highlights
Parking
Garage
Outdoor
No Info
A/C
Heating & Cooling
HOA
None
Price/Sqft
$548/sqft
Listed
180+ days ago
Home Details for 95 Buttonball Road
|
|---|
Interior Details Basement: PartialNumber of Rooms: 7Types of Rooms: Master Bedroom, Bedroom, Den, Dining Room, Kitchen, Living Room |
Beds & Baths Number of Bedrooms: 3Number of Bathrooms: 2Number of Bathrooms (full): 2 |
Dimensions and Layout Living Area: 1394 Square Feet |
Appliances & Utilities Appliances: Oven/Range, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Washer, Water HeaterDishwasherRefrigeratorWasher |
Heating & Cooling Heating: Hot Water,OilHas CoolingAir Conditioning: Wall Unit(s)Has HeatingHeating Fuel: Hot Water |
Fireplace & Spa Number of Fireplaces: 3Has a Fireplace |
|
|---|
Exterior Home Features Roof: AsphaltOther Structures: Shed(s)Exterior: Rain GuttersFoundation: StoneNo Private Pool |
Parking & Garage Number of Garage Spaces: 2Number of Covered Spaces: 2No CarportHas a GarageNo Attached GarageParking Spaces: 2Parking: Detached |
Frontage Not on Waterfront |
Water & Sewer Sewer: Cesspool |
Finished Area Finished Area (above surface): 1394 Square Feet |
|
|---|
Year Built Year Built: 1835 |
Property Type / Style Property Type: ResidentialProperty Subtype: Single Family ResidenceArchitecture: Antique |
Building Construction Materials: ClapboardNot a New ConstructionDoes Not Include Home Warranty |
Property Information Parcel Number: 1551148 |
|
|---|
Price List Price: $619,000Price Per Sqft: $548/sqft |
Status Change & Dates Off Market Date: Mon Nov 03 2025Possession Timing: Immediate |
|
|---|
MLS Status: Closed |
|
|---|
Direction & Address City: Old LymeCommunity: Mile Creek |
School Information Elementary School: Mile CreekJr High / Middle School: Lyme-Old LymeHigh School: Lyme-Old Lyme |
|
|---|
Buyer Agent Buyer Company Name: Nancy Mesham Team |
|
|---|
Building Area Building Area: 1394 Square Feet |
|
|---|
No HOA |
|
|---|
Lot Area: 26.28 Acres |
|
|---|
BasementMls Number: 24136586Attic: Access Via HatchAttribution Contact: (860) 227-9133Above Grade Unfinished Area: 1394 |
Last check for updates: about 17 hours ago
Listed by Vivian Senft, (860) 227-9133
Coldwell Banker Realty, (860) 434-8600
Marilyn Jacobs, (860) 304-6264
Coldwell Banker Realty, (860) 434-8600
Bought with: Nancy Mesham, (860) 227-9071, Coldwell Banker Realty, (860) 434-8600
Source: Smart MLS, MLS#24136586
Price History for 95 Buttonball Road
| Date | Price | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12/10/2025 | $764,000 | Sold | Smart MLS #24136586 |
| 11/03/2025 | $619,000 | Pending | Smart MLS #24136586 |
| 10/28/2025 | $619,000 | Listed For Sale | Smart MLS #24136586 |
Market trends in Old Lyme
Last updated May 2026
Avg. sale price
—
Sale-to-List Price
—
Price per sq ft
—
Available listings
38
4MoM
- Results are loading
Property Tax and Assessment
| Year | 2025 |
|---|---|
| Tax | $5,161 |
| Assessment | $318,010 |
Home facts updated by county records
Comparable Sales for 95 Buttonball Road
Address | Distance | Property Type | Sold Price | Sold Date | Bed | Bath | Sqft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0.66 | Single-Family Home | $590,000 | 09/30/25 | 3 | 2 | 1,224 | |
0.31 | Single-Family Home | $1,100,000 | 01/07/26 | 4 | 2.5 | 4,576 | |
0.60 | Single-Family Home | $360,000 | 01/16/26 | 4 | 2 | 1,632 | |
0.56 | Single-Family Home | $965,000 | 07/25/25 | 4 | 2.5 | 2,614 | |
0.68 | Single-Family Home | $510,000 | 05/29/26 | 3 | 1 | 1,124 | |
0.96 | Single-Family Home | $837,000 | 10/09/25 | 3 | 2.5 | 3,075 |
Nearby homes
Get a sense of prices in the area by checking nearby homes.
OFF MARKETHeritage Properties SPC
SOLDJAN 7, 2026William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
OFF MARKETColdwell Banker Realty
OFF MARKETKennedy Real Estate Solutions
OFF MARKETWilliam Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
SOLDMAY 29, 2026KW Legacy Partners
OFF MARKETColdwell Banker Realty
OFF MARKETColdwell Banker Realty
OFF MARKETWilliam Raveis Real Estate
Assigned Schools
These are the assigned schools for 95 Buttonball Road.
- Lyme-Old Lyme High School
- 9-12
- Public
- 367 Students
8/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageShocked by some of these poor reviews. I have never heard anything but glowing reviews of this school system. As a former student, this high school prepared me well for college/grad school and beyond. For such a small high school, there are a surprising number of extra curricular activities to get involved with- really something for everybody. I think it’s very telling that so many former students choose to move back to Lyme or old Lyme to have their own children attend this school.Other Review2y ago - Mile Creek School
- K-5
- Public
- 334 Students
8/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageMile Creek is a great school that’s close-knit, and smaller-ish in size compared what our kids were used to in our previous town. They’re doing great, and the teachers and staff have been dedicated, compassionate and invested in academic growth for the kids. School is technically forward too, and currently upgrading the building, making for a modern learning environment. Overall, we couldn’t be happier with the Lyme-Old Lyme school system.Parent Review5mo ago - Lyme-Old Lyme Middle School
- 6-8
- Public
- 271 Students
9/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageSuper disappointed with the quality of after school clubs, and especially sports activities for kids at the Middle School. There is literally nothing to select from. No programming, no robotics, no cross-disciplinary courses that prepare kids for the future. Basketball team is impossible to get into and coach just does not care! There are lines of kids that want to play and cannot play. Kids have extremely limited sports options. Instead, there is a big obsession with vaccines. Vaccines are important, but being able to play sports is and develop intellectually is even more important. Would be great if the school was thinking through strong growth and development options for kids instead.Parent Review2y ago 
Check out schools near 95 Buttonball Road.
What Locals Say about Old Lyme
At least 28 Trulia users voted on each feature.
93 % Say yards are well-kept
91 % Say there's wildlife
88 % Say it's dog friendly
87 % Say parking is easy
86 % Say it's quiet
83 % Say car is needed
79 % Say there's holiday spirit
79 % Say people would walk alone at night
71 % Say neighbors are friendly
69 % Say kids play outside
55 % Say they plan to stay for at least 5 years
47 % Say there are community events
33 % Say it's walkable to restaurants
25 % Say streets are well-lit
16 % Say it's walkable to grocery stores
Sourced by Trulia users. Learn more about our methodology.
LGBTQ Local Legal Protections
LGBTQ Local Legal Protections
Apartments for Rent
NEW - 7 HRS AGOPET FRIENDLY
See more homes for rent inOld Lyme
Explore by feature - Air Conditioning
NEW - 2 DAYS AGOAPPLY INSTANTLY
APPLY INSTANTLYPET FRIENDLYFURNISHED
APPLY INSTANTLYPET FRIENDLY
APPLY INSTANTLYFURNISHED- NEW - 7 HRS AGOPET FRIENDLY
APPLY INSTANTLYPET FRIENDLYFURNISHED
PET FRIENDLY
FURNISHED
FURNISHED
Explore by feature - Washer/dryer
- APPLY INSTANTLYPET FRIENDLYFURNISHED
- APPLY INSTANTLYPET FRIENDLY
- APPLY INSTANTLYFURNISHED
- NEW - 7 HRS AGOPET FRIENDLY
- APPLY INSTANTLYPET FRIENDLYFURNISHED
- PET FRIENDLY
- FURNISHED
- FURNISHED
FURNISHED
Homes for sale near 95 Buttonball Road
NEW CONSTRUCTION
NEW CONSTRUCTION
NEW CONSTRUCTION
NEW CONSTRUCTION
NEW CONSTRUCTION
NEW CONSTRUCTION
NEW CONSTRUCTION0.92 ACRESWilliam Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
See more homes for sale inOld Lyme
Off Market Homes Near 95 Buttonball Road
SOLDJUN 22, 2026William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
SOLDJUN 18, 2026Coldwell Banker Realty
SOLDJUN 18, 2026William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
SOLDJUN 18, 2026William Raveis Real Estate
SOLDJUN 15, 2026Coldwell Banker Realty
SOLDJUN 15, 2026William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
SOLDJUN 15, 2026William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
SOLDJUN 12, 2026McDonald Real Estate, LLC- See more homes for sale inOld Lyme
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
95 Buttonball Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371 is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 1,394 sqft single-family home built in 1835. This property is not currently available for sale. 95 Buttonball Road was last sold on Dec 10, 2025 for $764,000 (23% higher than the asking price of $619,000). The current Trulia Estimate for 95 Buttonball Road is $686,900.