89 Cotter Street, West Islip, NY 11795
SOLD
MAY 8, 2026

89 Cotter Street
West Islip, NY 11795

  • 3 Beds
  • 1 Bath
  • 1,582 sqft (on 0.25 acres)

$730,000

Last Sold: May 8, 2026
6% over list $689K
$461/sqft
Est. Refi. Payment $4,788/mo*
Refinance Your Home

$730,000

Last Sold: May 8, 2026
6% over list $689K
$461/sqft
Est. Refi. Payment $4,788/mo*
Refinance Your Home
3 Beds
1 Bath
1,582 sqft
(on 0.25 acres)

Local Information

Map showing home location
© Google
-- mins to
Commute Destination

Description

Amazingly well-maintained expanded cape with a full basement, situated on a quarter-acre in West Islip School District. This home offers beautiful wood floors throughout and a spacious, inviting layout. The first floor features a formal dining area, large open eat-in kitchen, one bedroom, a full bath, a formal living room, and a gorgeous den with a gas fireplace. Sliders from the kitchen and the den, lead out to a beautifully manicured backyard, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The second floor offers two king-sized bedrooms with plenty of space and natural light. Dont forget about the attached garage! Ideally located just a short distance to local schools, shopping, parks, and the Long Island Rail Road. Dont miss your opportunity!
This property is off market, which means it's not currently listed for sale or rent on Trulia. This may be different from what's available on other websites or public sources. This description is from May 12, 2026

Home Highlights

Parking
Garage
Outdoor
No Info
A/C
Heating & Cooling
HOA
None
Price/Sqft
$461/sqft
Listed
85 days ago

Home Details for 89 Cotter Street

Interior Features

Interior Details
Basement: FullNumber of Rooms: 7
Beds & Baths
Number of Bedrooms: 3Number of Bathrooms: 1Number of Bathrooms (full): 1
Dimensions and Layout
Living Area: 1582 Square Feet
Appliances & Utilities
Utilities: Electricity Connected, Water ConnectedAppliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Electric Oven, Microwave, Refrigerator, WasherDishwasherDryerLaundry: In BasementMicrowaveRefrigeratorWasher
Heating & Cooling
Heating: OilHas CoolingAir Conditioning: Wall/Window Unit(s)Has HeatingHeating Fuel: Oil
Fireplace & Spa
Number of Fireplaces: 1Fireplace: GasHas a Fireplace
Gas & Electric
Has Electric on Property

Exterior Features

Exterior Home Features
Fencing: Back YardExterior: Awning(s)No Private Pool
Parking & Garage
Number of Garage Spaces: 1.5Number of Covered Spaces: 1.5No CarportHas a GarageHas Open ParkingParking Spaces: 1.5Parking: Driveway,Garage
Water & Sewer
Sewer: Cesspool

Days on Market

Cumulative Days on Market: 14

Property Information

Year Built
Year Built: 1957
Property Type / Style
Property Type: ResidentialProperty Subtype: Single Family Residence, ResidentialArchitecture: Exp Cape
Building
Not Attached Property
Property Information
Parcel Number: 0500286000100072000

Price & Status

Price
List Price: $689,000Price Per Sqft: $461/sqft
Status Change & Dates
Off Market Date: Thu Mar 26 2026

Active Status

MLS Status: Sold

Location

Direction & Address
City: West Islip
School Information
Elementary School: Manetuck Elementary SchoolJr High / Middle School: Udall Road Middle SchoolHigh School: West Islip Senior High SchoolHigh School District: West Islip

Building

Building Area
Building Area: 1939 Square Feet

Community

Not Senior Community

HOA

No HOA

Lot Information

Lot Area: 10890 sqft

Listing Info

Special Conditions: None

Offer

Listing Agreement Type: Exclusive Right To Sell

Miscellaneous

BasementMls Number: 970427Attic: ScuttleAttribution Contact: 631-450-4777Showing Requirements: Lockbox
Last check for updates: about 13 hours ago
Listed by Patrick Imondi, (631) 903-2577
Exit Family Realty, (631) 450-4777
Bought with: Patrick Imondi, (631) 903-2577, Exit Family Realty, (631) 450-4777
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID, MLS#970427

Price History for 89 Cotter Street

DatePriceEventSource
05/08/2026$730,000Sold
OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #970427
03/27/2026$689,000PendingOneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #970427
03/12/2026$689,000Listed For SaleOneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #970427

Market trends in West Islip

Last updated April 2026
Buyer'sMarketSeller'sMarket
Avg. sale price
—
Sale-to-List Price
—
Price per sq ft
—
Available listings
43
11MoM
Skip to last item
  • Results are loading
Skip to first item

Property Tax and Assessment

Year2025
Tax
Assessment$39,000
Home facts updated by county records

Comparable Sales for 89 Cotter Street

Address
Distance
Property Type
Sold Price
Sold Date
Bed
Bath
Sqft
85 Cotter Street, West Islip, NY
0.01
Single-Family Home
$715,000
05/20/26
3
1
988
7 W Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore, NY
0.39
Single-Family Home
$540,000
12/30/25
3
1
1,402
28 W Oakdale Street, Bay Shore, NY
0.37
Single-Family Home
$655,000
06/18/25
3
2
1,758
5 Breslau Street, Bay Shore, NY
0.56
Single-Family Home
$650,000
05/20/26
3
1
1,262
1118 Brookdale Avenue, Bay Shore, NY
0.38
Single-Family Home
$600,000
11/18/25
3
1
1,451
432 Kime Avenue, West Islip, NY
0.42
Single-Family Home
$670,000
01/09/26
3
1.5
1,381
1017 Fire Island Avenue, Bay Shore, NY
0.58
Single-Family Home
$680,000
02/18/26
3
1
1,170
1090 Brookdale Avenue, Bay Shore, NY
0.27
Single-Family Home
$582,250
02/05/26
3
2
1,316

Nearby homes

Get a sense of prices in the area by checking nearby homes.
Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Assigned Schools

These are the assigned schools for 89 Cotter Street.
View nearby schools on GreatSchools
The GreatSchools Rating compares schools on a variety of school quality indicators including test scores, college readiness, equity and more. Learn more.

What Locals Say about West Islip

At least 218 Trulia users voted on each feature.

  • 94 % Say parking is easy

  • 92 % Say car is needed

  • 92 % Say yards are well-kept

  • 90 % Say it's dog friendly

  • 84 % Say there's holiday spirit

  • 83 % Say people would walk alone at night

  • 68 % Say kids play outside

  • 67 % Say they plan to stay for at least 5 years

  • 65 % Say it's quiet

  • 64 % Say streets are well-lit

  • 62 % Say neighbors are friendly

  • 54 % Say there are sidewalks

  • 50 % Say it's walkable to grocery stores

  • 49 % Say it's walkable to restaurants

  • 47 % Say there are community events

  • 42 % Say there's wildlife

Sourced by Trulia users. Learn more about our methodology.
  • Kelley S.
    "We love our community! My kids are involved with different sports and have more friends then I ever did growing up! "
    0
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "There aren’t many dog dedicated spaces, like dog parks, agility areas and many apartment complexes have long lists of breed restrictions. "
    1
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "The nearby Good Samaritan hospital medical center is close but not as good as other hospitals on the island"
    0
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "You see some dogs being walked daily, and there are schools near by with plenty of fields for the dogs to run. There is also a dog park one town over. "
    1
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "I see people walking their dogs all the time around the neighborhood. A lot of them are all really friendly and love to have you stop and pet them! "
    0
    Flag
  • Erica B.
    "Great neighborhood very safe. Great schools! You can’t go wrong living in any part of west islip. Super clean and lots to do. Just a short walk to babylon village which has many restaurants and shops. Love this area and have loved here for 15 years and will live here the rest of my life. "
    10
    Flag
  • Cesimmons014
    "I’ve grown up in this neighborhood my entire life, I am now raising my own family here. It’s a great, safe town "
    4
    Flag
  • Colcolwalsh
    "I live in this neighborhood for 23 years. It has a great school district. Great sports programs! Close to the beach, and marina. Perfect for families. "
    7
    Flag
  • 6shomeimprovements
    "nice area great place for children and a nice safe neighborhood close too many major highways and South Shore Beach"
    3
    Flag
  • Kevin H.
    "Easy to get here. Not too much traffic. Plenty of places to eat and shop. Friendly and quiet neighborhood "
    2
    Flag
  • Brendon P.
    "Lives here when I was younger and moved back about 4 years ago. Might wind up staying around. I like the stores and places to eat and neighbors are friendly"
    6
    Flag
  • Daniel L.
    "Wonderful and safe neighborhood and- great schools and between 2 of Long Islands most popular downtown areas "
    2
    Flag
  • Colcolwalsh
    "I’ve lived here for 22 years and everyone is very friendly and neighborly. Great schools and great sports programs for the kids. "
    4
    Flag
  • Kelsey McCarthy
    "It a pretty good area to walk your dog in good weather but it’s near a highway and there are quite a few feral cats around."
    0
    Flag
  • Wayne Smith
    "quiet streets. boating & fishing neighborhood. walk sidewalks any time day or night, safely and friendly"
    6
    Flag
  • Wayne Smith
    "Family Centric. Dog Friendly. Multi Generational. Solid School System. Quick to Beaches, boating and recreation."
    5
    Flag
  • Colcolwalsh
    "Close to local beaches and only 2 miles from the ocean. Great neighborhood with parks. Dog park near by as well. Family friendly "
    0
    Flag
  • Erica B.
    "Easy commute to anywhere you need to go. Sunrise highway and southern state super close by. Babylon train station about a mile away"
    0
    Flag
  • Barbara D.
    "This is a family neighborhood in every sense. Really safe and community oriented. Good schools. The epitome of suburbia. "
    0
    Flag
  • Colcolwalsh
    "Good friendly neighborhood with lots of kids, decent schools. Very low crime. Great community. Restaurants and some shopping near by. "
    0
    Flag
  • Colcolwalsh
    "It is a great town with lots of great people. School district is good. Restaurants in town and near by. Near Babylon train station. "
    0
    Flag
  • Teresa
    "I see a lot of people walking all different kinds of dogs. But There are Not really a lot of places you can take your dog off leash."
    0
    Flag

LGBTQ Local Legal Protections

Apartments for Rent

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Homes for sale near 89 Cotter Street

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Off Market Homes Near 89 Cotter Street

Skip to last item
Skip to first item
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2026-02-06 15:18:24 PST. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. Click here for more information

Homes for rent near 89 Cotter Street

Skip to last item
  • Results are loading
Skip to first item
89 Cotter Street, West Islip, NY 11795 is a 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom, 1,582 sqft single-family home built in 1957. This property is not currently available for sale. 89 Cotter Street was last sold on May 8, 2026 for $730,000 (6% higher than the asking price of $689,000). The current Trulia Estimate for 89 Cotter Street is $730,800.