Is parking easy in West Islip, NY?

As of early 2025, 94% of users say parking is easy

Is a car needed in West Islip, NY?

As of early 2025, 92% of users say car is needed

Are yards well-kept in West Islip, NY?

As of early 2025, 92% of users say yards are well-kept

Is West Islip, NY dog-friendly?

As of early 2025, 90% of users say it's dog friendly

Does West Islip, NY show holiday spirit?

As of early 2025, 84% of users say there's holiday spirit

Would people walk alone at night in West Islip, NY?

As of early 2025, 83% of users say people would walk alone at night

Do kids play outside in West Islip, NY?

As of early 2025, 68% of users say kids play outside

Do residents of West Islip, NY plan to stay at least 5 years?

As of early 2025, 67% of users say they plan to stay for at least 5 years

Is West Islip, NY quiet?

As of early 2025, 65% of users say it's quiet

Are the streets well-lit in West Islip, NY?

As of early 2025, 64% of users say streets are well-lit

Are neighbors friendly in West Islip, NY?

As of early 2025, 62% of users say neighbors are friendly

Does West Islip, NY have sidewalks?

As of early 2025, 54% of users say there are sidewalks

Is West Islip, NY walkable to grocery stores?

As of early 2025, 50% of users say it's walkable to grocery stores

Is West Islip, NY walkable to restaurants?

As of early 2025, 49% of users say it's walkable to restaurants

Are there community events in West Islip, NY?

As of early 2025, 47% of users say there are community events

Is there wildlife in West Islip, NY?

As of early 2025, 42% of users say there's wildlife

OFF MARKET

55 Reilly St
West Islip, NY 11795

Studio

$793,000

Trulia Estimate

as of Oct 17, 2025

Est. Refi. Payment $5,114/mo*

Refinance Your Home

$793,000

Trulia Estimate

as of Oct 17, 2025

Est. Refi. Payment $5,114/mo*

Refinance Your Home

Studio

(on 0.25 acres)

Homes for Sale Near 55 Reilly St

Skip to last item

0.25 ACRES
$499,000
2 bd
2 ba
753 sqft
45 Reilly Street,
West Islip, NY 11795
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
OPEN SAT, 12-2:30PM
0.25 ACRES
$649,000
3 bd
1.5 ba
1,381 sqft
432 Kime Avenue,
West Islip, NY 11795
Listing by: Coldwell Banker American Homes
OPEN SAT, 11-2PM
0.27 ACRES
$595,000
3 bd
1 ba
1,016 sqft
1016 Howells Road,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Listing by: Orion Realty Group Florida LLC
$699,999
5 bd
2.5 ba
1,643 sqft
22 Herman Avenue,
North Babylon, NY 11703
Listing by: Realty Connect USA L I Inc
See more homes for sale in
West Islip
Take a look

Skip to first item

Apartments for Rent

Skip to last item

PET FRIENDLY
$2,210 - $3,160/mo
1-2 bd
1 ba
Fairfield at Babylon | 100 Friendly Ct #4453731ab,
Babylon, NY 11702
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,460 - $3,635/mo
1-2 bd
1-2 ba
Fairfield Tudor At North Babylon | 1593 August Rd #8c71a92a1,
North Babylon, NY 11703
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,390 - $2,965/mo
1 bd
1 ba
Fairfield Eastbrook Gardens | 327 Brook Ave #1427dc0df,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,000/mo
Studio bd
1 ba
140 Orinoco Dr #d99321772,
Brightwaters, NY 11718
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,545 - $3,160/mo
1-2 bd
1 ba
Fairfield at Deer Park | 766 Nicolls Rd #a27e876e9,
Deer Park, NY 11729
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,500 - $3,270/mo
1-2 bd
1-2 ba
Fairfield Courtyard at Deer Park | 45 Golden Ave #4dec895d0,
Deer Park, NY 11729
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$3,275 - $3,495/mo
2 bd
2 ba
Fairfield Knolls at Deer Park | 500 Sutton Ct #aabf2c4ab,
Deer Park, NY 11729
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,025/mo
1 bd
1 ba
105 Howells Rd #6cdac9c4f,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
PET FRIENDLY
$2,295 - $2,850/mo
1-2 bd
1 ba
Fairfield Arms At Bay Shore | 80 S Clinton Ave #bcc3902d4,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,390 - $3,000/mo
1-2 bd
1 ba
Fairfield North at Bay Shore | 25 N Clinton Ave #08b0f22ed,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Fairfield Properties
$2,790/mo
1 bd
1 ba
39 Park Ave #06f700bab,
Babylon, NY 11702
Fairfield Properties
$2,575/mo
1 bd
1 ba
751 Deer Park Ave #e4f25c26f,
North Babylon, NY 11703
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,380/mo
1 bd
1 ba
53 S Clinton Ave #9cb49e563,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Fairfield Properties
$2,730 - $3,305/mo
1-2 bd
1 ba
Fairfield at Babylon Village | 134 Park Ave #be32bcba1,
Babylon, NY 11702
Fairfield Properties
See more homes for rent in
West Islip
Take a look

Skip to first item

Local Information

-- mins to

Commute Destination

Description

This single-family home is located at 55 Reilly St, West Islip, NY. 55 Reilly St is in West Islip, NY and in ZIP code 11795. This property has a lot size of 10890 sqft.

This property is off market, which means it's not currently listed for sale or rent on Trulia. This may be different from what's available on other websites or public sources.

Home Highlights

Parking

No Info

Outdoor

No Info

HOA

None

Price/Sqft

No Info

Listed

No Info

Home Details for 55 Reilly St

Property Information
Property Type / Style Property Type: Single Family Home

Lot Information
Lot Area: 10890 sqft

Price History for 55 Reilly St

Date	Price	Event	Source
10/06/2003	$485,050	Sold	N/A
Recording Date 10/06/2003 Contract Date 09/26/2003 County Transfer Tax N/A Total Transfer Tax $1,942
04/08/2002	$278,000	Sold	N/A
Recording Date 04/08/2002 Contract Date 04/01/2002 County Transfer Tax N/A Total Transfer Tax $1,112

Property Taxes and Assessment

Year	2024
Tax
Assessment	$62,000

Home facts updated by county records

Comparable Sales for 55 Reilly St

Address	Distance	Property Type	Sold Price	Sold Date	Bed	Bath	Sqft
69 Penny St, West Islip, NY	0.08	Single-Family Home	$400,000	04/08/25		-	-
62 Penny St, West Islip, NY	0.10	Single-Family Home	$575,000	11/18/24		-	-
39 Penney Street, West Islip, NY	0.09	Single-Family Home	$735,000	04/29/25	5	2.5	2,743
39 Penny St, West Islip, NY	0.09	Single-Family Home	$735,000	06/11/25	5	2.5	-
17 W Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore, NY	0.19	Single-Family Home	$605,000	12/30/24	4	3	1,962
1017 Fire Island Avenue, Bay Shore, NY	0.31	Single-Family Home	$495,000	12/31/24	3	1	1,170
1046 Sullivan Street, Bay Shore, NY	0.22	Single-Family Home	$665,000	06/26/25	4	2	2,500
1049 Udall Road, Bay Shore, NY	0.24	Single-Family Home	$475,000	10/30/24	2	1	-
12 Stewart Street, Bay Shore, NY	0.35	Single-Family Home	$500,000	06/30/25	3	1	952
91 W Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore, NY	0.24	Single-Family Home	$505,000	10/21/24	3	1	-

Assigned Schools

These are the assigned schools for 55 Reilly St.

GreatSchools ratings are based on test scores and additional metrics when available.
Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these schools. Learn more.

What Locals Say about West Islip

At least 217 Trulia users voted on each feature.

94%
Parking is easy
92%
Car is needed
92%
Yards are well-kept
90%
It's dog friendly
84%
There's holiday spirit
83%
People would walk alone at night
68%
Kids play outside
67%
They plan to stay for at least 5 years
65%
It's quiet
64%
Streets are well-lit
62%
Neighbors are friendly
54%
There are sidewalks
50%
It's walkable to grocery stores
49%
It's walkable to restaurants
47%
There are community events
42%
There's wildlife

Learn more about our methodology.

Pam S.
Resident
7y ago
"I’ve lived here since 1980. Used to know everyone’s name. All kids are grown up and gone. Now every works and stays indoors. Nice weather has neighbors come outside. We say hello, but nothing more."
3
Flag
Seal7df
Resident
7y ago
"It’s a great community, schools and location to shopping is perfect. It’s a beach community. I have put 5 kids through the schools here and have been happy with the results......great community."
0
Flag
swag
10y ago
"I've lived in West Islip all my life - it's the most wonderful area! I pass this house all the time and wonder why no one is purchasing it since it is near so many great recreational places nearby. Love the people, and especially the atmosphere of West Islip!"
1
Flag
D L.
10y ago
"Neighbors are nice and the schools are great!"
0
Flag
janetandward
11y ago
"Nice established, friendly neighborhood in close proximity to all amenities."
0
Flag
Keri W.
14y ago
"schools are just awesome! Theteachersin this district go above and beyond for their students."
0
Flag

LGBTQ Local Legal Protections

Additional Cost

Homes for Rent Near 55 Reilly St

Skip to last item

PET FRIENDLY
$3,275 - $3,495/mo
2 bd
2 ba
Fairfield Knolls at Deer Park | 500 Sutton Ct #aabf2c4ab,
Deer Park, NY 11729
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,460 - $3,635/mo
1-2 bd
1-2 ba
Fairfield Tudor At North Babylon | 1593 August Rd #8c71a92a1,
North Babylon, NY 11703
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,210 - $3,160/mo
1-2 bd
1 ba
Fairfield at Babylon | 100 Friendly Ct #4453731ab,
Babylon, NY 11702
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,390 - $2,965/mo
1 bd
1 ba
Fairfield Eastbrook Gardens | 327 Brook Ave #1427dc0df,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,500 - $3,270/mo
1-2 bd
1-2 ba
Fairfield Courtyard at Deer Park | 45 Golden Ave #4dec895d0,
Deer Park, NY 11729
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,545 - $3,160/mo
1-2 bd
1 ba
Fairfield at Deer Park | 766 Nicolls Rd #a27e876e9,
Deer Park, NY 11729
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,000/mo
Studio bd
1 ba
140 Orinoco Dr #d99321772,
Brightwaters, NY 11718
Fairfield Properties
PET FRIENDLY
$2,025/mo
1 bd
1 ba
105 Howells Rd #6cdac9c4f,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
PET FRIENDLY
$2,315 - $2,850/mo
1-2 bd
1-2 ba
Fairfield Gardens At Bay Shore | 64 S Clinton Ave #940d42041,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Fairfield Properties
$2,730 - $3,305/mo
1-2 bd
1 ba
Fairfield at Babylon Village | 134 Park Ave #be32bcba1,
Babylon, NY 11702
Fairfield Properties
See more homes for rent in
West Islip
Take a look

Skip to first item

Off Market Homes Near 55 Reilly St

Skip to last item

SOLD
OCT 17, 2025
$477,000
3 bd
2 ba
1,437 sqft
30 Arnold Avenue,
West Babylon, NY 11704
Island Advantage Realty LLC
SOLD
OCT 17, 2025
$810,000
4 bd
2 ba
2,103 sqft
174 S Windsor Avenue,
Brightwaters, NY 11718
Netter Real Estate Inc
SOLD
OCT 16, 2025
$640,000
3 bd
1.5 ba
1,619 sqft
343 W 16th Street,
Deer Park, NY 11729
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
SOLD
OCT 16, 2025
$999,999
6 bd
5 ba
3,684 sqft
479 Garden Street,
West Islip, NY 11795
Winkler Real Estate Inc
SOLD
OCT 15, 2025
$718,000
4 bd
2.5 ba
1,746 sqft
163 Albany Street,
Deer Park, NY 11729
E Realty International Corp
SOLD
OCT 15, 2025
$685,000
3 bd
2 ba
978 sqft
31 Orange Street,
Deer Park, NY 11729
Century 21 Crown Homes
SOLD
OCT 15, 2025
$630,000
3 bd
1.5 ba
1,664 sqft
22 Victoria Road,
North Babylon, NY 11703
Realty Connect USA LLC
SOLD
OCT 15, 2025
$650,000
3 bd
1.5 ba
1,420 sqft
810 Tooker Avenue,
West Babylon, NY 11704
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
SOLD
OCT 15, 2025
$675,000
3 bd
2 ba
1,700 sqft
10 Talman Place,
Dix Hills, NY 11746
Kelly Real Estate Inc
SOLD
OCT 15, 2025
$832,000
4 bd
3 ba
2,852 sqft
8 Flower Hill Lane,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
See more homes for sale in
West Islip
Take a look

Skip to first item

55 Reilly St, West Islip, NY 11795 is a studio single-family home. This property is not currently available for sale. 55 Reilly St was last sold on Oct 6, 2003 for $485,050. The current Trulia Estimate for 55 Reilly St is $793,000.

55 Reilly St
West Islip, NY 11795

$793,000

$793,000

Homes for Sale Near 55 Reilly St

Apartments for Rent

Local Information