5187 Plaster Pt
Cayuga, NY 13034
4 Beds
1 Bath
1,368 sqft
4 Beds
1 Bath
1,368 sqft
Local Information
- Map ViewExplore the area around 5187 Plaster Pt.
- Schools1 Preschool School1 Elementary School1 Middle School1 High School
- Shop & Eat
-- mins to
Description
A wonderful lakeside property located in Plaster Point,a community of seasonal and year round homes,beautiful views and lovely decks to enjoy amazing sunsets.The open floor plan and vaulted ceilings, wood burning fireplace and sliding glass doors that face the lake really make this a perfect lake home.3 bedrooms on main floor and the large loft above adds extra sleeping area, the 4th bedroom if needed.Fully equipped newer kitchen and countertops.Located in the heart of the Finger Lakes,40 minutes to Ithaca,1 hr to Rochester or Syracuse.This property is in excellent condition.
5187 Plaster Pt, Cayuga, NY 13034 is a 4 bedroom, 1 bathroom, 1,368 sqft single-family home built in 1974. It last sold for $255,000 on Jun 24, 2015. It is currently off market. The Trulia Estimate is $717,700, with a rent estimate of $1,770/month.
Home Highlights
Parking
No Info
Outdoor
Deck
A/C
Heating only
HOA
None
Price/Sqft
No Info
Listed
Less than a day ago
Home Details for 5187 Plaster Pt
|
|---|
Heating & Cooling Heating: Baseboard, ElectricHeating Fuel: Baseboard |
Levels, Entrance, & Accessibility Stories: 2Floors: Carpet, Linoleum Vinyl |
Appliances & Utilities Cable ReadyDishwasherDryerMicrowaveRefrigeratorWasher |
Fireplace & Spa Fireplace |
|
|---|
Exterior Home Features Roof: OtherDeckExterior: Vinyl |
|
|---|
Year Built Year Built: 1974 |
Property Type / Style Property Type: Single Family HomeArchitecture: Other |
|
|---|
Units in Building: 1 |
|
|---|
Lot Area: 2613 sqft |
Price History for 5187 Plaster Pt
| Date | Price | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 06/24/2015 | $255,000 | Sold | NYSAMLSs #S315108 |
| 04/27/2015 | $265,000 | Pending | Agent Provided |
| 02/25/2015 | $265,000 | PriceChange | Agent Provided |
| 08/15/2014 | $270,000 | PriceChange | Agent Provided |
| 07/09/2014 | $285,000 | Listed For Sale | Agent Provided |
Market trends in Cayuga
Last updated May 2026
Avg. sale price
—
Sale-to-List Price
—
Price per sq ft
—
Available listings
8
- Results are loading
Property Tax and Assessment
| Year | 2015 |
|---|---|
| Tax | $7,021 |
| Assessment | $269,881 |
Home facts updated by county records
Comparable Sales for 5187 Plaster Pt
Address | Distance | Property Type | Sold Price | Sold Date | Bed | Bath | Sqft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0.03 | Single-Family Home | $850,000 | 08/29/25 | 3 | 2 | 1,600 | |
0.97 | Single-Family Home | $87,010 | 07/17/25 | 3 | 1 | 840 | |
1.10 | Single-Family Home | $299,900 | 06/18/26 | 2 | 2 | 1,536 | |
1.60 | Single-Family Home | $245,000 | 07/07/25 | 4 | 2 | 1,358 | |
1.41 | Single-Family Home | $192,000 | 12/09/25 | 2 | 1 | 1,068 | |
1.93 | Single-Family Home | $215,000 | 09/23/25 | 4 | 1 | 1,617 | |
1.70 | Single-Family Home | $224,900 | 08/11/25 | 2 | 1 | 728 | |
2.06 | Single-Family Home | $191,489 | 04/17/26 | 4 | 1.5 | 1,824 | |
2.09 | Single-Family Home | $200,000 | 02/18/26 | 2 | 1 | 1,266 | |
1.76 | Single-Family Home | $139,000 | 07/25/25 | 3 | 2.5 | 2,128 |
Nearby homes
Get a sense of prices in the area by checking nearby homes.
FOR SALE
3D VIEW0.58 ACRESListing by: Finger Lakes Sothebys Intl.
OFF MARKETHunt Real Estate ERA/Columbus
OFF MARKETHunt Real Estate ERA/Columbus
OFF MARKETLake Country Real Estate
SOLDJUN 25, 2026Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices CNY Realty
OFF MARKETLand of Lakes Realty, Inc.
SOLDJUN 17, 2026Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices CNY Realty
FOR SALE3D VIEW0.94 ACRESListing by: Lake Country Real Estate
Assigned Schools
These are the assigned schools for 5187 Plaster Pt.
- Andrew J Smith Elementary School
- PK-5
- Public
- 332 Students
5/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageN/AStudent Review17y ago - Union Springs Middle School High School
- 9-12
- Public
- 212 Students
6/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating AverageThe teachers are very dedicated to helping students achieve their greatest potential and there are plenty of tools in each classroom to support that.Student Review11y ago - Union Springs Middle School
- 6-8
- Public
- 165 Students
9/10GreatSchools RatingParent Rating Average
No reviews available for this school. 
Check out schools near 5187 Plaster Pt.
What Locals Say about Cayuga
At least 2 Trulia users voted on each feature.
100 % Say car is needed
100 % Say it's dog friendly
100 % Say people would walk alone at night
100 % Say parking is easy
100 % Say there's holiday spirit
100 % Say yards are well-kept
100 % Say there's wildlife
75 % Say they plan to stay for at least 5 years
75 % Say it's quiet
67 % Say neighbors are friendly
50 % Say kids play outside
50 % Say there are community events
33 % Say streets are well-lit
25 % Say there are sidewalks
20 % Say it's walkable to restaurants
20 % Say it's walkable to grocery stores
Sourced by Trulia users. Learn more about our methodology.
LGBTQ Local Legal Protections
LGBTQ Local Legal Protections
Apartments for Rent
- Results are loading
Homes for sale near 5187 Plaster Pt
- 0.58 ACRESListing by: Finger Lakes Sothebys Intl.
- 0.94 ACRESListing by: Lake Country Real Estate
0.34 ACRESListing by: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices CNY Realty
0.3 ACRESListing by: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices CNY Realty
24.72 ACRESListing by: Lake To Lake Real Estate
5.96 ACRESListing by: The Real Estate Agency
See more homes for sale inCayuga
Off Market Homes Near 5187 Plaster Pt
SOLDJUL 2, 2026Cornerstone Realty Associates
SOLDMAY 8, 2026Lake Country Real Estate
SOLDAPR 28, 2026Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices CNY Realty
SOLDMAR 3, 2026Cassara Realty Group- SOLDDEC 29, 2025
SOLDDEC 23, 2025Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester
SOLDDEC 10, 2025Howard Hanna Real Estate
SOLDDEC 8, 2025Emmi's Realty Inc
SOLDDEC 3, 2025Century 21 Steve Davoli RE- See more homes for sale inCayuga
