5159 Plaster Point, Cayuga, NY 13034
OFF MARKET

5159 Plaster Point
Cayuga, NY 13034

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,536 sqft (on 0.34 acres)

$622,200

Trulia Estimate
as of Aug 9, 2026
Est. Refi. Payment $4,219/mo*
Refinance Your Home

$622,200

Trulia Estimate
as of Aug 9, 2026
Est. Refi. Payment $4,219/mo*
Refinance Your Home
3 Beds
2 Baths
1,536 sqft
(on 0.34 acres)

Local Information

  • Map ViewExplore the area around 5159 Plaster Point.
  • Schools1 Preschool School1 Elementary School1 Middle School1 High School
  • Shop & Eat
-- mins to
Commute Destination

Home Highlights

Property Type
Single-Family Home
Year Built
1957
Lot Size
0.34 acres
Living Area
1,536 sqft
Price/Sqft
$405
Parking
Garage

About this House

Great room and 2 downstairs bedrooms with bath. Spacious front deck facing Cayuga Lake, gentle slope to the waterfront, screened-in porch on each floor, amazing 2nd floor master suite with sleep area, office space, TV viewing area, master bath, walk-in closet/laundry and french doors out to screened-in porch looking through the trees to the lake.
5159 Plaster Point, Cayuga, NY 13034 is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 1,536 sqft single-family home built in 1957. It is currently off market. The Trulia Estimate is $622,200, with a rent estimate of $2,512/month.

Home Details for 5159 Plaster Point

Interior Features

Interior Details
BasementTypes of Rooms: Walk In Closet, Family Room, Laundry Room, Library, Master Bath, Office, PantryCeiling Fan
Heating & Cooling
Heating: Forced Air, GasAir ConditioningCooling System: WallHeating Fuel: Forced Air
Levels, Entrance, & Accessibility
Stories: 2Floors: Laminate
Appliances & Utilities
Cable ReadyDishwasherDisposalDryerMicrowaveRefrigeratorWasher
Windows, Doors, Floors & Walls
Double Paned Windows

Exterior Features

Exterior Home Features
Roof: CompositionDeckExterior: Other, VinylLawnPorch
Parking & Garage
GarageParking: Garage Detached

Property Information

Year Built
Year Built: 1957Year Updated: 2002
Property Type / Style
Property Type: Single Family HomeArchitecture: Other

Community

Units in Building: 1

Lot Information

Lot Area: 0.34 acres

Market trends in Cayuga

Last updated June 2026
Buyer'sMarketSeller'sMarket
Avg. sale price
—
Sale-to-List Price
—
Price per sq ft
—
Available listings
7
1MoM
Skip to last item
  • Results are loading
Skip to first item

Property Tax and Assessment

Year2025
Tax
Assessment$409,900
Home facts updated by county records

Comparable Sales for 5159 Plaster Point

Address
Distance
Property Type
Sold Price
Sold Date
Bed
Bath
Sqft
5185 Plaster Point, Cayuga, NY
0.12
Single-Family Home
$850,000
08/29/25
3
2
1,600
346 Backus Rd, Cayuga, NY
0.91
Single-Family Home
$1,160,000
08/07/26
5
3
2,944
7 Hillview Dr, Union Springs, NY
1.37
Single-Family Home
$279,000
08/04/26
3
1.5
1,779
300 Cayuga St, Union Springs, NY
1.00
Single-Family Home
$299,900
06/18/26
2
2
1,536
3393 Canoga Is, Seneca Falls, NY
1.66
Single-Family Home
$224,900
08/11/25
2
1
728
9 Park St, Union Springs, NY
1.94
Single-Family Home
$191,489
04/17/26
4
1.5
1,824
1059 State Route 326, Cayuga, NY
1.89
Single-Family Home
$215,000
09/23/25
4
1
1,617
10 Center St, Union Springs, NY
2.08
Single-Family Home
$168,500
04/27/26
4
2
2,548
8 Basin St, Union Springs, NY
1.94
Single-Family Home
$125,000
05/15/26
4
1
1,884
102 Cayuga St, Union Springs, NY
2.09
Single-Family Home
$320,000
05/18/26
2
2
2,344

Nearby homes

Get a sense of prices in the area by checking nearby homes.
Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Assigned Schools

These are the assigned schools for 5159 Plaster Point.
View nearby schools on GreatSchools
The GreatSchools Rating compares schools on a variety of school quality indicators including test scores, college readiness, equity and more. Learn more.

What Locals Say about Cayuga

At least 2 Trulia users voted on each feature.

  • 100 % Say car is needed

  • 100 % Say it's dog friendly

  • 100 % Say people would walk alone at night

  • 100 % Say parking is easy

  • 100 % Say there's holiday spirit

  • 100 % Say yards are well-kept

  • 100 % Say there's wildlife

  • 75 % Say they plan to stay for at least 5 years

  • 75 % Say it's quiet

  • 67 % Say neighbors are friendly

  • 50 % Say kids play outside

  • 50 % Say there are community events

  • 33 % Say streets are well-lit

  • 25 % Say there are sidewalks

  • 20 % Say it's walkable to restaurants

  • 20 % Say it's walkable to grocery stores

Sourced by Trulia users. Learn more about our methodology.
  • George A.
    "I have lived here since 1954. There has been continual upgrading of local properties for the past 25-35 years."
    1
    Flag

LGBTQ Local Legal Protections

Apartments for Rent

Skip to last item
  • Results are loading
Skip to first item

Homes for sale near 5159 Plaster Point

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Off Market Homes Near 5159 Plaster Point

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Frequently asked questions about 5159 Plaster Point

  • What is 5159 Plaster Point estimated to be worth?
    Trulia's estimated value for 5159 Plaster Point in Cayuga, NY is $622,200.
  • Is Cayuga a buyer's or seller's market?
    Cayuga is currently a seller's market, based on recent for-sale activity.
  • What are the closest schools to 5159 Plaster Point?
    The closest schools to 5159 Plaster Point in Cayuga, NY are Andrew J Smith Elementary School (Pre-K, rated 4/10), Union Springs Middle School (rated 8/10), Union Springs Middle School High School (rated 6/10).
  • Does 5159 Plaster Point have air conditioning?
    Yes, 5159 Plaster Point in Cayuga, NY has air conditioning.
  • Does 5159 Plaster Point have laundry facilities?
    Yes, 5159 Plaster Point in Cayuga, NY has in-unit laundry.
  • How big is the lot at 5159 Plaster Point?
    The lot at 5159 Plaster Point in Cayuga, NY is about 0.34 acres (15,022 sq ft).