5 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
OFF MARKET

$2,789,000

Trulia Estimate
  • 4 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 3,209 sqft (on 0.64 acres)

5 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580

Greenhaven
Est. Refi. Payment $18,538/mo*
Refinance Your Home
Currently Off Market - Sold Apr 29, 2021 for $1,857,580

Home Value

Trulia Estimate
$2.79M
Since last month
Increased$32K (+1.1%)
Since last year
Increased$346K (+14%)
Since last sale
Increased$952K (+51.3%)
Learn more about this home's value by checking out its Trulia Estimate, the value of nearby homes, and how much similar homes have sold for.

Trulia Estimate

The of this home's value increased by +74% in the last 10 years
MonthEstimated value
2026
October 2026$2.81M
September 2026$2.78M
August 2026$2.78M
July 2026$2.79M
June 2026$2.74M
May 2026$2.62M
April 2026$2.58M
March 2026$2.56M
February 2026$2.51M
January 2026$2.48M
2025
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016

Comparable sales

These are recently sold homes that have a similar location or other similar features to this home, like bedrooms, bathrooms, and square footage. Get a sense of the expected prices in the area by viewing these homes.
Address
Distance
Property Type
Sold Price
Sold Date
Bed
Bath
Sqft
5 Woodland Dr, Rye, NY
0.25
Single-Family Home
$1,799,000
06/24/26
4
3
2,894
8 Douglas Circle, Rye, NY
0.20
Single-Family Home
$2,715,000
07/02/26
4
3.5
2,938
37 Barlow Lane, Rye, NY
0.21
Single-Family Home
$2,250,000
05/19/26
5
3
3,545
10 Walden Ln, Rye, NY
0.42
Single-Family Home
$1,525,000
10/02/26
4
3
2,308
21 Douglas Circle, Rye, NY
0.27
Single-Family Home
$2,500,000
07/21/26
5
3.5
4,046
68 Greenhaven Road, Rye, NY
0.37
Single-Family Home
$2,557,000
11/04/25
5
3.5
3,388
19 John Jay Place, Rye, NY
0.16
Single-Family Home
$3,050,000
07/23/26
6
4.5
3,787
9 Rye Road, Rye, NY
0.16
Single-Family Home
$3,508,000
07/24/26
5
4.5
4,951
16 John Jay Place, Rye, NY
0.17
Single-Family Home
$3,600,000
08/18/26
5
4.5
5,320
38 Brevoort Lane, Rye, NY
0.42
Single-Family Home
$2,750,000
06/18/26
5
4.5
3,656

Nearby home prices

Get a sense of expected prices in the area by checking the value of nearby homes.
Address
Distance
Price
Bed
Bath
Sqft
Status
7 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.02
$2,375,400
5
3
3,383
Off Market
3 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.03
$2,326,800
5
4
2,933
Off Market
9 John Jay Place, Rye, NY 10580
0.04
$1,799,600
3
3
3,266
Off Market
6 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.05
$2,130,100
4
3
2,515
Off Market
23 Barlow Ln, Rye, NY 10580
0.05
$2,701,600
6
4
3,566
Off Market
4 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.05
$3,069,800
4
3
3,727
Off Market
11 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.06
$2,271,500
3
2.5
2,500
Off Market
2 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.07
$2,969,600
6
5
3,590
Off Market
5 Peter Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.08
$2,422,300
3
3
3,255
Off Market
3 Peter Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.08
$2,513,900
5
3
2,898
Off Market
13 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.08
$2,430,700
4
3
3,268
Off Market
27 Barlow Ln, Rye, NY 10580
0.09
$3,009,100
4
4
4,660
Off Market
1 Sound Rd, Rye, NY 10580
0.10
$3,727,700
6
5.5
4,561
Off Market
1 Anchor Dr, Rye, NY 10580
0.10
$6,007,200
7
8
8,500
Off Market
15 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.11
$2,194,900
5
3
2,837
Off Market
4 Peter Jay Lane, Rye, NY 10580
0.11
$3,040,700
4
3.5
4,940
Off Market
4 Peter Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.11
$3,119,400
4
3.5
4,940
Off Market
2 Anchor Dr, Rye, NY 10580
0.11
$4,950,000
5
7
6,316
Off Market
22 Barlow Ln, Rye, NY 10580
0.12
$2,682,300
5
3.5
4,450
Off Market
2 Peter Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580
0.12
$2,864,000
5
4.5
3,253
Off Market

Local Information

  • Map ViewExplore the area around 5 John Jay Pl.
  • Schools2 Elementary Schools1 Middle School1 High School
  • Shop & Eat
-- mins to
Commute Destination

Home Highlights

Single-Family Home
Built in 1968
0.64 acre lot
3,209 sqft
$869/sqft

About this House

Enjoy resort living in Rye! Pristine Greenhaven colonial with beautiful pool and fabulous screened-in porch on cul-de-sac features 4BR/2.1BA in prestigious seaside community. Freshly painted, these generously apportioned rooms offer great flow for stylish entertaining. A luxurious living room features wood-burning fireplace, gourmet eat-in-kitchen and a nearby family room. Screened in porch w/kitchenette has access to beautifully illuminated garden, patio area and heated Shoreline pool w/cabana, hot tub and a waterfall plus a play area with extensive plantings. An add'l 1,000+ sq. ft in lower level has a renovated playroom, newly tiled large mudroom & storage that offers access to attached two-car garage. This smart home has many, many new upgrades throughout, including brand new 3 zone geothermal heating and cooling systems, an endless hot water heater, quality hardie board siding, CAT-6, new garage door, new Anderson windows thru-out and LED lighting just to name a few.
5 John Jay Pl, Rye, NY 10580 is a 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom, 3,209 sqft single-family home in Greenhaven, built in 1968. It last sold for $1,857,580 on Apr 29, 2021. This property is not currently displayed as for sale or rent on Trulia. The Trulia Estimate is $2,789,000, with a rent estimate of $9,573/month.

Home Details for 5 John Jay Pl

Property Information

Year Built
Year Built: 1968
Property Type / Style
Property Type: Single Family HomeArchitecture: Colonial

Interior Features

Fireplace & Spa
Fireplace

Exterior Features

Parking & Garage
Parking Spaces: 2

Community

Units in Building: 1

Lot Information

Lot Area: 0.64 acres

Price and Tax history

DateEventPrice
Apr 29, 2021
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #H6062145
Sold
$1,857,580
Jan 13, 2021
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #H6062145
Pending
$1,920,000
Oct 1, 2020
Source: Agent Provided
PriceChange
$1,920,000
Price decreased by 4%
Aug 21, 2020
Source: Agent Provided
PriceChange
$1,995,000
Price decreased by 5%
Aug 2, 2020
Source: N/A
PriceChange
$2,095,000
Price decreased by 5%

Market trends in Rye

Last updated September 2026
Buyer'sMarketSeller'sMarket
Avg. sale price
—
Sale-to-List Price
—
Price per sq ft
—
Available listings
34
2MoM
Sourced by Trulia Market Trends

Around this home

View nearby schools on GreatSchools
The GreatSchools Rating compares schools on a variety of school quality indicators including test scores, college readiness, equity and more. Learn more.

Neighborhood Overview

Greenhaven
See Local Highlights
Neighborhood stats provided by third party data sources.

LGBTQ Local Legal Protections

Frequently asked questions about 5 John Jay Pl

  • What is 5 John Jay Pl estimated to be worth?
    Trulia's estimated value for 5 John Jay Pl in Rye, NY is $2,789,000.
  • What is the price history for 5 John Jay Pl?
    5 John Jay Pl in Rye, NY last sold for $1,857,580 in April 2021.
  • Is Rye a buyer's or seller's market?
    Rye is currently a seller's market, based on recent for-sale activity.
  • What are the closest schools to 5 John Jay Pl?
    The closest schools to 5 John Jay Pl in Rye, NY are Daniel Warren Elementary School, F E Bellows Elementary School (rated 9/10), Rye Neck Middle School (rated 7/10).
  • How big is the lot at 5 John Jay Pl?
    The lot at 5 John Jay Pl in Rye, NY is about 0.64 acres (27,878 sq ft).
  • Does 5 John Jay Pl have parking?
    Yes, 5 John Jay Pl in Rye, NY has on-site parking.

Explore by feature - Pet Friendly

10 pet-friendly rentals in Rye, NY

Explore by feature - Garage

15 rentals with a garage in Rye, NY

Explore by feature - Air Conditioning

22 rentals with air conditioning in Rye, NY

Explore by feature - Washer/dryer

27 rentals with a washer/dryer in Rye, NY

Explore by feature - Outdoor Space

Apartments for Rent

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Off Market Homes Near 5 John Jay Pl

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Homes for sale near 5 John Jay Pl

Skip to last item
Skip to first item
Skip to last item
  • Results are loading
Skip to first item