Is parking easy in Cincinnatus, NY?

As of early 2026, 100% of users say parking is easy

Do kids play outside in Cincinnatus, NY?

As of early 2026, 100% of users say kids play outside

Do residents of Cincinnatus, NY plan to stay at least 5 years?

As of early 2026, 100% of users say they plan to stay for at least 5 years

Are yards well-kept in Cincinnatus, NY?

As of early 2026, 100% of users say yards are well-kept

Is there wildlife in Cincinnatus, NY?

As of early 2026, 100% of users say there's wildlife

Is a car needed in Cincinnatus, NY?

As of early 2026, 100% of users say car is needed

Is Cincinnatus, NY dog-friendly?

As of early 2026, 67% of users say it's dog friendly

Would people walk alone at night in Cincinnatus, NY?

As of early 2026, 67% of users say people would walk alone at night

Are neighbors friendly in Cincinnatus, NY?

As of early 2026, 63% of users say neighbors are friendly

OFF MARKET

4500 May Rd
Cincinnatus, NY 13040

3 Beds
1.5 Baths
1,508 sqft (on 31.80 acres)

$379,100

Trulia Estimate

as of Jul 22, 2026

Est. Refi. Payment $2,709/mo*

Refinance Your Home

$379,100

Trulia Estimate

as of Jul 22, 2026

Est. Refi. Payment $2,709/mo*

Refinance Your Home

3 Beds

1.5 Baths

1,508 sqft

(on 31.80 acres)

Local Information

Map ViewExplore the area around 4500 May Rd.
Schools1 Preschool School2 Elementary Schools1 Middle School1 High School
Shop & Eat

-- mins to

Commute Destination

Home Highlights

Property Type

Single-Family Home

Year Built

2000

Lot Size

31.8 acres

Living Area

1,508 sqft

Price/Sqft

$251

Parking

Garage

Description

Make this private retreat your home! You'll be amazed by the nature that surrounds you inside of this open floor plan 2 bedrooms 1.5 bath log home situated on over 31 acres. The driveway leads you into the attached garage that opens into the kitchen area. The open concept flows into the dining are and living room. The far wing of the residence houses the 2 bedrooms and the full bath. Off of the kitchen is the Laundry and 1/2 bath. Enjoy the summer breeze on the front porch overlooking the wooded acreage. Full basement, ,large pole building for equipment or a hobby farm. Dont miss out!

4500 May Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 1,508 sqft single-family home built in 2000. It last sold for $185,000 on Jul 27, 2018. It is currently off market. The Trulia Estimate is $379,100, with a rent estimate of $2,171/month.

Home Details for 4500 May Rd

Interior Features
Heating & Cooling Heating: Other, Electric, Oil, Propane ButaneHeating Fuel: Other
Levels, Entrance, & Accessibility Stories: 1Floors: Carpet, Hardwood
Interior Details Types of Rooms: Dining Room
Appliances & Utilities DishwasherDryerMicrowaveRefrigeratorWasher
Fireplace & Spa Fireplace

Property Information
Year Built Year Built: 2000Year Updated: 2000
Property Type / Style Property Type: Single Family HomeArchitecture: Log Cabin/Rustic

Exterior Features
Exterior Home Features Exterior: Other, Metal
Parking & Garage GarageParking: Carport, Garage Attached

Lot Information
Lot Area: 31.80 acres

Price History for 4500 May Rd

Date	Price	Event	Source
07/27/2018	$185,000	Sold	NYSAMLSs #S1107493
Recording Date 07/27/2018 County Transfer Tax N/A Total Transfer Tax N/A
06/14/2018	$194,900	Pending	Agent Provided

05/04/2018	$194,900	PriceChange	Agent Provided
Price Change $4,600 (-2%)
03/30/2018	$199,500	PriceChange	Agent Provided
Price Change $25,000 (-11%)
09/22/2017	$224,500	PriceChange	Agent Provided
Price Change $4,400 (-2%)
06/14/2017	$228,900	Listed For Sale	Agent Provided

Market trends in Cincinnatus

Last updated June 2026

Avg. sale price

—

Sale-to-List Price

—

Price per sq ft

—

Available listings

Skip to last item

Results are loading

Skip to first item

Property Tax and Assessment

Year	2025
Tax
Assessment	$301,887

Home facts updated by county records

Comparable Sales for 4500 May Rd

Address	Distance	Property Type	Sold Price	Sold Date	Bed	Bath	Sqft
4339 May Rd, East Freetown, NY	0.48	Single-Family Home	$177,500	05/27/26	3	1	1,440
3541 Preston Rd, Cincinnatus, NY	0.51	Single-Family Home	$311,000	05/04/26	4	3	2,402
2918 State Route 41 Hwy, Cincinnatus, NY	1.48	Single-Family Home	$195,000	12/08/25	3	1	1,184
4743 Clarks Rd, Cincinnatus, NY	1.20	Single-Family Home	$230,000	12/23/25	4	2	3,000
2936 Center Rd, Cincinnatus, NY	2.33	Single-Family Home	$98,000	11/03/25	3	2	1,040
2779 Maricle Rd, Cincinnatus, NY	2.02	Single-Family Home	$380,000	12/17/25	4	2.5	2,770
4059 Stramba Rd, Cincinnatus, NY	1.86	Single-Family Home	$30,000	01/16/26	5	1	1,632
5112 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus, NY	2.17	Single-Family Home	$141,500	10/01/25	2	1	930
3638 Taylor Valley Rd, Cincinnatus, NY	2.53	Single-Family Home	$350,000	02/13/26	4	1	1,817
4280 Freetown Cross Rd, Cincinnatus, NY	2.09	Single-Family Home	$379,000	03/09/26	4	-	2,640

Nearby homes

Get a sense of prices in the area by checking nearby homes.

Skip to last item

SOLD
MAY 27, 2026
$177,500
3 bd
1 ba
1,440 sqft
4339 May Rd,
East Freetown, NY 13040
Yaman Real Estate
SOLD
MAY 4, 2026
$311,000
4 bd
3 ba
2,402 sqft
3541 Preston Rd,
Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty
OFF MARKET
Est. $307,100
5 bd
2.5 ba
2,052 sqft
4305 Baker Schoolhouse Rd,
Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc.
OFF MARKET
Est. $324,100
4 bd
1 ba
2,352 sqft
3540 State Route 41,
Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty
FOR SALE
3D VIEW
0.56 ACRES
$140,000
2 bd
1 ba
1,376 sqft
3078 State Route 41,
Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Listing by: Yaman Real Estate
SOLD
DEC 23, 2025
$230,000
4 bd
2 ba
3,000 sqft
4743 Clarks Rd,
Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Hage Real Estate
SOLD
DEC 8, 2025
$195,000
3 bd
1 ba
1,184 sqft
2918 State Route 41 Hwy,
Cincinnatus, NY 13040
McKee Real Estate
FOR SALE
3D VIEW
225.7 ACRES
$700,000
4 bd
1 ba
1,776 sqft
4891 Telephone Rd #1,
Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Listing by: Yaman Real Estate Whitney Point
FOR SALE
3D VIEW
225.7 ACRES
$700,000
4 bd
1 ba
1,776 sqft
4891 Telephone Rd,
Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Listing by: Yaman Real Estate Whitney Point
OFF MARKET
1 bd
1.5 ba
1,008 sqft
2953 E Freetown Texas Valley Rd,
Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty

Skip to first item

Additional Cost

Assigned Schools

These are the assigned schools for 4500 May Rd.

View nearby schools on GreatSchools

The GreatSchools Rating compares schools on a variety of school quality indicators including test scores, college readiness, equity and more. Learn more.