25 Rector St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Property image
Property image
FOR SALE

$4,695,000

Original price: $4,995,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths

25 Rector St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Est. Mortgage $31,699/mo*
Get Pre-Qualified

Home Highlights

Multi-Family

Local Information

  • Map ViewExplore the area around 25 Rector St.
  • Schools1 Preschool School1 Elementary School1 Middle School1 High School
  • Shop & Eat
-- mins to
Commute Destination

About this House

Two houses positioned just one block from Main Streets' American Hotel and the famous Sag Harbor Superyacht docks; 25 Rector Street offers an exceptionally rare and legal multi-family configuration. Comprising two character-rich structures-The Whaler's Cottage and The Artist's Retreat-the property benefits from a highly coveted, pre-existing non-conforming status, making it an incredibly unique find in the heart of Sag Harbor Village. Steeped in heritage, the one and a half bedroom Whaler's Cottage anchors the eastern portion of the property and dates back to the mid-1800s as a whaling industry supply building. Directly adjacent on the western side sits the one bedroom Artist's Retreat, which was beautifully renovated in 2016 and features an enchanting studio-turned-bedroom. A massive 1500 sq ft brick patio flows from the kitchen's French doors, and offers a spacious finished area for outdoor dining and relaxation. The property has a rich artistic legacy, which is only matched by its incredible future potential. Because the property is not on the list of the Village's inventory of historically significant structures, it allows more freedom to make the house your own. For those seeking multi-generational living, an irreplaceable location, and unrepeatable history- this is a once-in-a-generation opportunity.
Contact this Building
Property Website
Last check for updates: about 8 hours ago
Listing by: Sotheby's International Realty, (631) 907-8444
Robert Kohr - Associate Real Estate Broker, (631) 871-8774
Source: Out East, MLS#396787

Home Details for 25 Rector St

Interior Features

Interior Details
Basement: Yes
Beds & Baths
Number of Bedrooms: 3Number of Bathrooms: 3Number of Bathrooms (full): 3
Heating & Cooling
No Heating
Fireplace & Spa
No FireplaceNo Spa
Levels, Entrance, & Accessibility
Stories: 2

Exterior Features

Exterior Home Features
No Private Pool
Parking & Garage
No CarportNo GarageNo Attached GarageParking: None
Frontage
Not on Waterfront

Days on Market

Days on Market: 45

Property Information

Property Type / Style
Property Type: Residential IncomeProperty Subtype: Multi Family
Building
Not a New Construction

Price & Status

Price
List Price: $4,695,000

Active Status

MLS Status: Active

Location

Direction & Address
City: Sag Harbor

Agent Information

Listing Agent
Listing ID: 396787

Miscellaneous

BasementMls Number: 396787Listing Url

Around this home

What Locals Say about Sag Harbor

At least 47 Trulia users voted on each feature.

  • 86 % Say it's dog friendly

  • 85 % Say car is needed

  • 80 % Say yards are well-kept

  • 77 % Say it's quiet

  • 75 % Say they plan to stay for at least 5 years

  • 73 % Say people would walk alone at night

  • 71 % Say there's wildlife

  • 67 % Say parking is easy

  • 63 % Say it's walkable to grocery stores

  • 62 % Say it's walkable to restaurants

  • 59 % Say neighbors are friendly

  • 59 % Say there's holiday spirit

  • 52 % Say kids play outside

  • 42 % Say there are sidewalks

  • 42 % Say there are community events

  • 34 % Say streets are well-lit

Sourced by Trulia users. Learn more about our methodology.
  • Trulia User
    "Good schools, plenty of things to do."
    0
    Flag
  • Renee
    "Great school district with new facilities being built. Lovely community. The best of Long Island in a small town."
    0
    Flag
  • Alex26dario
    "The neighborhood is quiet. I have lived here for 3 years and the people are friendly and grateful. "
    0
    Flag
  • Trulia User
    "This is in the Hamptons which is a secondary home area near beaches. In off season, it is quiet and not many children live here. "
    2
    Flag
  • Josue
    "Chill neighborhood, busy road, not very close to parks or school approximately 8 minutes by car to get to sag harbor town but great place overall "
    12
    Flag
  • Mjmnyny
    "There is a lot of self policing. People walk up to your property and into your home without invites to tell you how things are done. Oh yes. They’ll tell you how long they’ve lived here as to show superiority. Many rent their homes and don’t use the shops or restaurants. They suck the town dry but don’t contribute. Others put the seasonal residents down who pay for the great schools and all the extras this town would not have without their tax dollars. They even point out who belongs and who doesn’t. Not as laid back as the picture they paints. Keep to yourself. You’ll love it here "
    1
    Flag
  • Stephen C.
    "Great for family retreat. Excellent town and beaches. Nice quiet neighborhoods for bike rides with children. "
    0
    Flag
  • Kjduchemin
    "I have lived here my whole life ! Safe place to raise your family . Schools good , locals friendly , and nice place to raise your kids "
    0
    Flag
  • sloaneharbor
    "Near to bay beach and village business district. The downtown has all the necessary shops, and though quite overcrowded in the summer, it’s a beautiful place to live. "
    0
    Flag
  • Kfsanderson666
    "Short walk into town. sidewalks are well maintained. Area is as safe as can be at all times of day or night. lots of year round families here. Perfect American small town. "
    0
    Flag
  • Victoria H.
    "I drive to New York City in 2 hours. This is my weekend home. I use my car. You can also take the HAMPTON Jitney bus."
    0
    Flag
  • Wendy T.
    "We have a beautiful private beach around the corner. Gorgeous trees and lush landscaping all over our neighborhood, kid friendly, warm community"
    0
    Flag
  • Kjduchemin
    "Safe, Friendly upscale neighborhood where every knows everyone and looks out for each other’s children and property "
    0
    Flag
  • Kjduchemin
    "Nice place , friendly people , a tad bit expensive , not much walking or biking to delis , shops or restaurants . Beaches are beautiful , get there early to grab a parking space and a space on the beach . "
    0
    Flag
  • Lizlesar
    "The neighborhood of Sag Harbor Village is a wonderful location to live or vacation in. There's so much to do here, you can't do it all in one season. I've been living here one year and have barely scratched the surface. The area retains a neighborhood-y, genuine ambience even in the summertime. It's the perfect antidote to Manhattan or other city living. And if you love antique homes, this is the place to be."
    0
    Flag

Market trends in Sag Harbor

Last updated August 2026
Buyer'sMarketSeller'sMarket
Avg. sale price
—
Sale-to-List Price
—
Price per sq ft
—
Available listings
82
6MoM

Home Value

Trulia Estimate
$4.65M
Since last month
Decreased$305K (-6%)
Since last year
Increased$3M (+169.7%)
Since last sale
Increased$4M (+635.6%)
Learn more about this home's value by checking out its Trulia Estimate, the value of nearby homes, and how much similar homes have sold for.

Trulia Estimate

The of this home's value increased by +196% in the last 10 years
MonthEstimated value
2026
August 2026$4.78M
August 2026$4.65M
July 2026$5.09M
June 2026$1.94M
May 2026$1.82M
April 2026$1.81M
March 2026$1.84M
February 2026$1.98M
January 2026$1.83M
2025
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016

Comparable sales

These are recently sold homes that have a similar location or other similar features to this home, like bedrooms, bathrooms, and square footage. Get a sense of the expected prices in the area by viewing these homes.
Address
Distance
Property Type
Sold Price
Sold Date
Bed
Bath
Sqft
109 Hampton St, Sag Harbor, NY
0.45
Multi-Family Home
$2,650,000
09/26/25
5
4
4,000
3625 Noyac Rd, Sag Harbor, NY
2.19
Multi-Family Home
$1,700,000
02/20/26
3
3.5
2,113

Nearby home prices

Get a sense of expected prices in the area by checking the value of nearby homes.
Address
Distance
Price
Bed
Bath
Sqft
Status
45 Division St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.02
$2,422,000
8
5
4,000
Off Market
10 Rector St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.03
$4,890,000
3
3
-
Off Market
18 Rysam Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.03
$2,724,800
3
2
2,300
Off Market
25 Church St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.06
$5,999,000
4
4
3,059
For Sale
15 Church St #G120, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.11
$2,862,200
3
3
1,990
Off Market
15 Church St #G108, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.11
$2,170,000
1
1
1,070
For Sale
20 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.12
$5,575,000
4
6
9,000
Off Market
2 Sage St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.13
$4,207,000
4
3.5
3,012
Off Market
25 Meadow St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.14
$2,395,000
4
1
1,088
For Sale
49 Rysam St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.13
$3,938,200
2
2.5
1,950
Off Market
8 Rose St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
0.15
$1,753,100
3
2
1,500
Off Market

Price and Tax history

DateEventPrice
Sep 1, 2026
Source: Out East #396787
PriceChange
$4,695,000
Price decreased by 6%
Jul 29, 2026
Source: Out East #396787
Listed For Sale
$4,995,000
Jan 9, 2012
Source: N/A
Sold
$650,000

LGBTQ Local Legal Protections

Robert Kohr - Associate Real Estate Broker, Sotheby's International Realty, (631) 907-8444
Agent Phone: (631) 871-8774

Similar Homes You May Like

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

New Listings near 25 Rector St

Skip to last item
Skip to first item

Frequently asked questions about 25 Rector St

  • What is the estimated monthly payment for 25 Rector St?
    Based on a $4,695,000 list price with 20% down at today's rates, the estimated monthly payment for 25 Rector St in Sag Harbor, NY is approximately $32,441 (about $25,128 principal & interest, $7,238 property taxes, and $75 homeowner's insurance). This is an estimate. Actual payment depends on your loan terms.
  • What do residents say about Sag Harbor?
    Residents describe Sag Harbor, NY as dog-friendly, well-kept, and quiet. Most residents say you need a car. See homes for sale in Sag Harbor, NY.
  • What are the closest schools to 25 Rector St?
    The closest schools to 25 Rector St in Sag Harbor, NY are Pierson Middle High School (rated 8/10), Sag Harbor Elementary School (Pre-K, rated 8/10).
  • What is 25 Rector St estimated to be worth?
    Trulia's estimated value for 25 Rector St in Sag Harbor, NY is $4,652,300.
25 Rector St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 is a 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom multi-family. This property is currently available for sale and was listed by Out East on Jul 29, 2026. The MLS # for this home is MLS# 396787.