I have clients that are from NYC right now that are looking to buy in Tuxedo Park, and they love the location because it is walking distance to the train and the train ride "in their opinion" is very nice and smooth. It is about an hour- an hour and fifteen minutes. You have to transfer at Secacus, but it is not that bad. Tuxedo Park brings nature and beauty of the Harriman State Park, with just a short ride to the city full of opportunities. Its a great location!
If you have any more questions about Tuxedo/Suffern area, please give me a call at 845.664.2144. I would be glad to help you out!... more