Wow, Janice, it is incredible what a difference 10 miles makes - I'm in Lafayette, and it is a different world of real estate a few miles down I-680. I knew Antioch was getting hammered, but I didn't realize it was that bad: "20+ months of unsold inventory and around 30% of owners needing to acomplish a short pay transaction or loose their home to forclosure". I totally agree that under these circumstances, it is better to get help from the professionals and get it quick. - Sun Aug 5 2007, 22:35
As judged by the plethora of heated emails I’ve received recently, it seems I hit a nerve with my esteemed colleagues in the real estate profession by suggesting that a homeowner can sell a home by themselves and obtain positive results.
The question of whether or not to choose the FSBO route is not as cut and dry as some agents would have consumers think. The people I run into in the San Francisco Bay Area are graduates (and post-graduates) of Berkeley, Stanford, and the like, and I feel confident these individuals (and similar demographics across the country) are literate enough and computer savvy enough to sell their own home with better results than an agent. Historical and current real estate data is easy to find online, as is marketing collateral, marketing strategies, negotiation strategy, etc. Despite what some agents would have you think, selling a home is not rocket science that only seasoned agents are able to navigate.
I've run into more than my fair share of agents that don't do their clients justice for the 3% commission on a 900k house in the San Francisco Bay Area. As such, I would recommend any savvy individual to attempt to sell their property themselves if they are so inclined. I believe part of the problem lives in the misaligned incentives of the agent and seller. Agents care little about the last 20-30k in sales prices - as it has little effect on their commission at the margin. The agent wants the home sold quickly while the seller wants to weigh the risk of prolonged carry costs against the prospect of a higher sales price.
However, I totally agree that not everyone (or even a majority) of people should attempt to sell a home by themselves. Agents serve a valuable purpose to a majority of home buyers and sellers, but it is inaccurate to insinuate that everyone attempting to navigate the home selling process on their own is heading for disaster.
Josh - Sat Aug 4 2007, 23:01
I'm not going to make any friends on this forum with other agents, but I am a real estate broker and Realtor, and I whole-heartedly believe you can and should sell your house by yourself. I have done so in the past, prior to getting my license, and had much success. One caveat is that you should get help if you are not able to generate traffic and offers on your own within the first month or so.
My reasoning is this: 1.) the agent doesn't care too much between selling your house for $250k versus $200k. At the margin, the commission to the agent doesn't change too much, so the agent is mostly concerned with selling fast and moving on the next property. Obviously, this is not always the case, and there are a lot of good agents out there. But the reality is that the barriers to entry in becoming a real estate agent are low, and most agents are not as competent as I would personally like. My blog recently had a post on how to sell without an agent - here is an excerpt from the blog post:
Disclosure: I am a licensed real estate broker and Realtor (though that isn't what I do for a living).
Despite what you've read all over the place (Trulia Voices included), you can sell your home without the help of an agent.
Before I moved to California, and before I got my real estate broker's license, I successfully sold a home in St. Louis without the help of a broker. I read plenty of articles telling me that trying to sell a home without professional help is crazy, and that my house would sit on the market indefinitely until I got smart and crawled back to my agent to bail me out. If you feel confident that you can negotiate well, and are reasonably adept with Google searches and the like, there is no reason you shouldn’t give it a go just like I did – at least for the first few weeks on the market. Here are the steps I recommend:
1.) Bite the bullet and get the house listed on your local MLS. You can usually pay a discount service a fee ($500-800) to get the property listed on MLS. Get the property listed on MLS the cheapest way you can find. If you list on MLS, expect to pay 3% to the agent that brings you a buyer. Unfortunately, Realtors are the gatekeepers to buyers in a lot of areas, so you may, at a minimum, have to pay the buyer's agent, but at least you can save 3% on the selling end of the transaction. You are going to have a hard time avoiding this 3% commission if you want any agent to show your house to potential buyers.
2.) Most buyers start their search for a home on-line, so post a listing wherever you can: Zillow.com is the place to start. Then do a Google search for real estate and start checking out the sites and see where you can post an ad. Don't skimp on this step - make sure you get the word out on the web before you waste time anywhere else.
3.) Get a decent looking sign printed for the front yard, and have professional looking flyers available for people driving by to stop and pick one up. Make sure to by a sign rider than mentions OPEN SUNDAY 1-4. You can buy these at your local Realtor association (even without being a member). Obviously, put your cell phone number prominently on the sign.
4.) Ads in the newspaper may be effective where you live, but they are not the best value in Northern California, and are not really effective at driving traffic out here. This may not be the case at all where you live, so if the cost is not prohibitively expensive, then place an ad.
5.) If you do post an ad in the paper, advertise the OPEN HOUSE dates prominently in the ad.
6.) Hold Open Houses often. Open Houses are not the most effective way to sell a home, but this is your best shot since Brokers cannot just stop by with buyers.
7.) This one is obvious, but answer every call and return every message immediately. Be ready to show the house to buys on extremely short notice.
You can sell the home by yourself if you are focused and diligent. But remember, if the house doesn't sell quickly, then get help before the property sits on the market and becomes 'stale' in the eyes of the buyers. Worst case is that you have to bring an agent on board and you are out 2 weeks of debt service. The upside, in my opinion, is worth the risk so give it a shot. Best of luck to you! - Mon Jul 23 2007, 21:48