What I am trying to get across is this. You need to look at all aspects of the decision. How does each house affect your commute to work, your quality time for your self and your family? How do the neighborhoods compare? Will you want to send kids to the schools in one area of the other if you have them? If you don't have kids, how will the school district affect your resale one day?
Sorry I cannot answer the question for you. I truly believe the best thing I can for you is to tell you to weigh all aspects of your decision, and then go with what fits your needs and desires the best! Your decision may not be the same as the next person's but it has to be right for you.
BEST OF LUCK!