The New Paltz school district encompasses a large geographic area including Gardiner and some parts of Esopus.Perhaps, by extending your search into these areas, you'll find a great place to live! Good luck to you...Best, Pat
I understand the difficulty you are experiencing Rentals are in high demand in New Paltz due to the student population. Do you have a Realtor looking for a rental for you? You could check New Paltz Gardens to see if they have a vacancy.