Here's another resource for you to use to compare schools, SOL's, and read parent feedback as well. But as John previously mentioned, York County offers some of the best schools in Virginia, as well as Williamsburg too.
Berkeley & Hornsby are two Williamsburg/James City schools, as well as Toano in north James City County.
If you have not yet contacted a local Realtor in our area to assit you in your new home search, and if you'd like to receive a list of properties currently on the market, please feel free to email anytime and I'll be happy to assist you.
Frank Biganski, Realtor
Reliance Realty at Port Warwick
I think you will find that the schools system in York County is rated among the best in all of Virginia. To say one school is better than another is very subjective and many factors would need to be considered and some of these factors may count more than others in your consideration.
A good site for information on any area and the schools in them is http://www.city-data.com.
Try this site to obtain info.