Trulia is often not the best source of up to date info. Work with a Realtor who will assist you in your rental search. Feel free to contact me should you need any assistance.
Property taxes alone on the property are aprx. $687 per month. If someone put 5% down at the current list price with a 3.5% interest rate the Principal and Interest payment would be $1,062.21. Add the property taxes and your are at $1749.13. Add your annual property insurance divided by 12 and you can see that it would take a lot to get to the quoted monthly rent.
There are 6 rentals in Aurora in the $1100 month rental rate but none are single family homes. Feel free to contact me if you have any other question.