There are as of today 39 units in Plantation, Davie and Cooper City under your parameters.
Call me, so we can exchange email address and I will send you this information.
Charles Rutenberg Realty LLC
Yes you been spoiled if you had a brand new and for that price. Why did you leave it?
There is only a little hope for you, I only found very few somewhat similar, what you describe, I can count them on one hand! There are townhomes or villas with garage, not sure about granite, but it is in your budget and has garage.
I am aware of your request through Trulia regarding Davie rentals. If you would be willing to send me an email to: firstname.lastname@example.org. I will start the process by which we will see what's available now (and a little later) containing all the requirements you have.
Let me know if I can assist you.