The biggest issue that many of the websites have is understanding the differences between the databases from each public record. Unfortunately there is no "key" that they use so that the information comes across correctly. In your instance the misinformation happens to be the difference between a owner's address and owner's mailing address. Your information is correct in Hillsborough County Property Appraisers office but someone must have the same address of your property within their public record information - this is usually the mailing or tax address. Since you bought the property as an REO - I definitely understand the concern especially since I have seen the incorrect legal multiple times for bank-owned properties but luckily your information is fine. Hope this helps.
Wow what a gorgeous pool area; it looks llke a tropical Oasis.
Normally Trulia pulls the data from public records and here is the Property Appraiser's sale history and there isn't a sale in Jan 2011:
There must be a glitch because even Zillow is showing a sale in Jan 2011:
All the best,
Alma Rose Kee PA
Future Home Realty