The median sales price for homes in Bay Terrace for May 14 to Aug 14 was $440,000. This represents an increase of 10.1%, or $40,500, compared to the prior quarter and an increase of 8.1% compared to the prior year. Sales prices have appreciated 0% over the last 5 years in Bay Terrace, Staten Island. The median sales price of $440,000 for Bay Terrace is 25.68% higher than the median sales price for Staten Island NY. Average listing price for homes on Trulia in Bay Terrace was $475,256 for the week ending Aug 13, which represents an increase of 3.1%, or $14,171 compared to the prior week and an increase of 1.4%, or $6,565, compared to the week ending Jul 23. Average price per square foot for homes in Bay Terrace was $420 in the most recent quarter, which is 65.35% higher than the average price per square foot for homes in Staten Island.