BEST ANSWER
Hi MrsC-
Depending on the quality of the work (too nice or not nice enough for the complex), permit status, and final layout (does it look like it was meant to be that way, or does it feel at all awkward?), the change from the original layout to 1 3/4 baths should definitely add value. How much the value was changed is a difficult question to answer online because of the many factors involved. If I were to throw out a percentage range you're probably going to be worth between 3% and 8% more than a similar original condition unit (size, upgrades, location in complex, etc) as long as the work is quality and seamless. If it is, and you're in a complex where the demographic wanting to purchase would appreciate two ensuite bathrooms, you may be on the high side of that range.
Based on your description it sounds like the remodel was completed very nicely and professionally, so the following concerns may not be warranted: First, you could realize little or no value if the layout is awkward because the home could prove more difficult to sell. Second, if permits were NOT obtained and the condo is located in the City of Santa Barbara, you're would have an issue when you sell because properties are inspected by a City official during the escrow period. The inspector could require that it be returned to its original layout or that someone (either the new owner or you) is responsible for monetary penalties and legalizing the work (which probably means opening the walls and flooring to inspect all aspects of the construction). It's possible the homeowner's association would assess penalties or require removal as well if modifications are required to have prior HOA approval. Finally, if you "overbuilt" the complex by upgrading the bathrooms too much, you may find you won't get all of the money you spent out of the unit.
I've just touched on factors that go into an evaluation. If you're looking for a "hard percentage" for legal purposes an appraiser might be the best solution because they're trained to break down specifics that contribute to a property's value. If you're looking for a current value, experienced Realtors that work in your specific price range and area of town would give a more accurate value versus comparables. You'll find that we get a "gut" feeling of value that comes from knowing the comparables and what's currently important to local buyers.
I only represent buyers and focus on the high-end, but I would be happy to provide an opinion if I felt qualified. If not, I'm happy to recommend a few associates that regularly sell similar properties. I can be reached most anytime at (805) 284-3660 or via email at jon@timeforsb.com.
Best regards,
Jon
Fri Jan 16 2009, 22:47